So, what does work?
One of the best ways to stop people from driving drunk is requiring ignition interlocks, which prevent the car from starting if the driver registers a blood alcohol level of 0.02%, Withers says. Thirty-two states require interlocks for first offenders, according to a MADD report. The devices allow drivers to keep their cars so they can drive to work, but prevent them from driving while drunk, Withers says.
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration estimates ignition interlocks would reduce recidivism by 75% and alcohol-related fatalities by 7%.
Here are some other prevention tactics NHTSA has looked at, and estimates of success:
- Automobile impoundment: Many states automatically impound a DUI suspect's car for 12 to 24 hours to prevent the driver from climbing immediately back behind the wheel. Other states have adopted more aggressive seizure laws -- even selling repeat offenders' cars. These tactics decrease recidivism by an estimated 38% and DUI crashes by about 4%.
- Electronically monitored house arrest: This tactic can require offenders to relay a breath test when prompted by a random phone call. The program decreases recidivism by an estimated 31%, causing DUI crashes to decrease by about 3%.
- Intensive probation supervision with treatment: Decreases recidivism by an estimated 48%, causing DUI crashes to decrease by 4%.
- Intensive sobriety checkpoint program: Highly visible sobriety checkpoints would reduce alcohol-related fatalities by at least 15%.
- Enforcement of intoxicated-patrons laws: Using undercover police officers to enforce the state laws against serving alcohol to intoxicated bar and restaurant patrons would reduce alcohol-related crash fatalities by an estimated 11%.
- Server training: Training bar employees to prevent patrons from driving drunk could reduce nighttime DUI injury crashes by 17%. An estimated 40% to 60% of intoxicated patrons drive after consuming alcohol in bars, clubs or restaurants.
Alcohol-related crashes accounted for an estimated 18% of the $103 billion in U.S. auto insurance claims, according a 2000 study by NHTSA. Reducing alcohol-related crashes by 10% would save $1.8 billion in claims payments and loss adjustment expenses.
More from CarInsurance.com:
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
There is no incentive to not take your chances on the road, since the penalty is the same in either case. Be caught sleeping in the backseat of your own car while drunk, or be driving down the road drunk, either way you get a DUI.
We need to spend Money on the real drunk to try to keep them off the road. Trying to keep someone off the road who is under .12 is ridiculous and a waste of money
Drunk driving isn't a felony, but selling a joint to a cancer patient with a month to live is. Welcome to America, land of hypocrites and jackwagons but we're sooooo much better than anyone else of course.
I am speaking as a recovering alcoholic. The only trouble I’ve ever been in was a direct result of drinking alcohol. I’m very thankful I’ve not hurt anyone but myself due to my poor decisions, but with me, when I was drunk, I always thought that “it would be different this time”.
My brother was a drinker. He got one DUI and quit cold turkey. One night in the drunk tank was good enough for him. But me, I always chalked up my alcohol offenses to everything but the real problem…..myself. I would blame the cops, bad luck, you name it. My Mother, God rest her soul, was a police officer. She has booked me into jail. You would think that would be a deterrent, but it wasn’t. And folks, believe me, if I ever feared anyone in this world, it was my mother, but in a good way. I feared disappointing her. Well…..and that scolding she would give me every time I screwed up.
I guess what I’m trying to say is, if you are racking up multiple offenses, more than likely, you are well on the road to alcoholism. Alcoholism is very powerful. Common sense takes a back burner to feed that craving. It’s been almost 10 years since I’ve had a drop and what do ya know……I’ve not been in trouble since. Peace and be careful. :o)
This article is ridiculous. Drunk driving is a crime, but not something that we do on purpose. It is a mistake, and its not one where people are easily let off the hook.
I got arrested for DUI last Ocober. I was treated like a hardened criminal. The police officers were rude, they were worse when I envoked my right to speak to an attorney. I was yelled at because I wouldn't sign anything until I understood it, the officer in the jail told me that she doesn't have to explain their policies to me and that she wasn't going to. I cooperated with everything the officers asked of me, even after they laughed at my answers to their questions about my religion.
$500 was put down on my bail, and I got to go home, only to be repremanded by the tow company the next day. The man told me that my car was totalled, and charged over $100 a day to hold it, and it was mandatory for the car to be held for a certain amount of time after my arrest. I didnt get to my car until over a day later, I paid $374 to get my car out. It was in perfect condition.
I hired a lawyer, I paid him $1500, a bargain compared to the $3500 I was quoted from another lawyer.He told me that I needed to take a DUI Awareness class ($40), an Assessment of my alcohol dependency ($100) where I was found to be a .5 risk because of my mother's drinking habits not my own, an 8 hour drug/alcohol dependency class ($100), a Defensive Driving class ($85).
After I was done in court I had to pay the bail bond company another $15.
Court costs of $800 plus a $150 administrative fee
My car insurance has gone up because I am required to have SR-22 insurance.
I pay $95.97 a month to have an ignition interlock in my car, plus a small $5 fee every two months when it is serviced.
I didn't think that I was driving drunk. Neither did the friend that I had just dropped off. I blew a .08. I've done everything required of me and I know that I will always be more careful about drinking and driving. As someone who has dealt with this, I think that first time offenders are punished to the extreme and that society needs to understand that people make mistakes
A buddy of mine got a DUI for blowing a .08 after using mouthwash before heading out to work.
We need to adjust the laws to give stiff penalties to the true drunks. Police and judges need to use a little common sense and not punish the mouthwash users or people who had a glass of wine with dinner. No drunk would ever blow a .08 because it's impossible for them to stop drinking with that little amount of alcohol in their system.
It's a business, the courts run off dwi and misdemenor offences, they know people will pay everything they have to get out of jail time and or get thery're liscense back, if you don't believe me ask any prosecuting attourney.
I don't like how they make an arbirary number up and then it's magic! You have a DUI. Not everyone is the same.
It's a big money maker for everyone.
We have dry townships in our state and you can't walk to a local bar.
No public transportaion and they will give you a DUI if you ride a bicycle.
In Atlanta, I saw a measure to prevent drunk driving more effective than any of these.
The person who's drunk usually doesn't want to drive that way, but he must get home, and he must have his car the next morning. Taxis don't solve this problem - the drunk's car is towed to a remote impound lot while he's home sleeping it off, costing hundreds of dollars, possibly making him miss work, school, an appointment or other activity. Draconian laws don't solve the problem either - as a society we're dependent on the automobile, and our right to consume alcohol was established with the repeal of Prohibition. So jailing them or taking their cars just makes them dependent on the state for survival.
One entrepeneur in Atlanta bought a small folding motorcycle with a vinyl carrying case. For $25, he comes to the bar on his bike, puts it in the trunk or bed or back seat of the drunk's vehicle, drives the drunk home in his own vehicle, then leaves on the bike to pick up the next drunk.
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
Even those who don't like to shop are probably hitting the stores this month. Here's what to be on the lookout for and here's what to avoid.