Central bankers out of their depth
With the market hitting record highs even as the US runs up huge deficits, officials around the world are embracing the very Fed policies hurtling us toward financial ruin.
Paul Singer, the founder and CEO of the extraordinarily successful Elliott Management, recently wrote an essay ("The Fed, Lost in the Wilderness") that was the most succinct and accurate discussion I have seen of where we are, how we got here and where we are headed.
Regular readers will not be surprised (given that I wrote the book "Greenspan's Bubbles: the Age of Ignorance at the Federal Reserve") that the first point I appreciate about the essay is that Singer lays the blame where it belongs -- something a surprisingly small number of people are able (or willing) to do.
"The Fed is primarily responsible for (the current) state of affairs, and it is out of its depth," Singer writes. "Former Chairman (Alan) Greenspan created -- and reveled in -- a cult of personality centered on himself, and in the process created a tremendous and growing moral hazard."
By embracing, rather than discouraging, his "maestro" mystique, Greenspan helped foster the sense that not only was he able to keep the economy "just right," but also that he could quickly correct any problems that might arise.
Jerk of all trades, maestro of none
As Singer puts it, Greenspan "cultivated an ever-increasing (but unjustified) faith in the Fed's apparent ability to fine-tune the American (and, by extension, the world's) economy. Ironically, this development was occurring at the very time financial innovations and leverage were making the system more brittle and less safe."
In short, the Greenspan era represents the greatest failure of Fed policy this country has ever experienced. Not only did Greenspan fail to grasp the consequences of his leadership, but his "solutions" also laid the groundwork for the bigger problems of the housing/credit crisis. If not for his incompetence, none of the problems he created would have befallen us.
If Greenspan's tenure is marked by hubris, current Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke's tenure is (in Singer's view), "one of lower and lower discipline (and) less and less conservative stewardship of the precious confidence that is all that stands between fiat currency and monetary ruin. . . . Speculators win, savers are destroyed and the ties that bind either fray or rip."
The other invisible hand: Risk
Singer correctly points out that while the Federal Reserve's money printing seems to be all gain and no pain, it comes at a price (greater risk) that present-day investors have been conditioned to ignore.
Inflation, dislocations in stock and bond prices, and instability of financial institutions are all problems more likely to mount as a result of Fed policy. Yet, since stock markets continue to rise (on weak fundamentals) and there is no widespread concern about inflation (yet), many investors seem content to believe that our problems are being resolved.
Reality, according to Singer, is quite different: "We believe that the global central bankers, led by the Fed as 'thought leader,' have no idea how much pain the world's economy may endure when they begin the still-undetermined and never-before-attempted process of ending this gigantic experimental policy."
And keep in mind, central bank recklessness is a global phenomenon, not a local one. In addition to rampant money printing by the Fed, the Bank of Japan, the Swiss National Bank, the Bank of England, the European Central Bank (in word, if not deed) and, just last week, the central banks of Australia and South Korea have all joined the party.
Also this past week, ECB President Mario Draghi made some bold claims when he stated during a speech in Rome that: "For the southern European countries, a euro above $1.30 would be too high for their economy. Among major central banks, the ECB has been the only bank that is not expanding its balance sheet. But it will likely consider such a step."
Assuming that Draghi follows through with the action he is implying, we will have unanimous and massive fiscal and monetary stimulus from every single G-7 country and, by extension, others as well.
Green with envy
The amount of stimulus being applied is unfathomable. Thus far, the United States is perceived as being in the best position (i.e., the sweetest of the sweet spots), with Japan quickly catching up. It would seem that world governments are in the process of concluding that their stimulative policies are solving all problems and have no negative consequences (thus we are going to see more of them).
How long the deflationists can hold out with their bond bets remains to be seen, but only the bond market can stop these policies -- a point I have made many times. (I should also be clear that it does not look like the policies will be halted anytime soon.)
With the Dow Jones Industrial Average ($INDU) and Standard & Poor's 500 Index ($INX) hitting all-time highs even as we run trillion-dollar deficits, we are the financial and economic envy of the G-7 world, even with our massive problems. So you can be sure the Europeans are going to emulate us.
Summing up the current environment, Singer writes:
"Printing money by the trillions of dollars has had the predictable effect of raising the prices of stocks and bonds and thus reducing the cost of servicing government debt. It also has produced second-order effects, such as inflating the prices of commodities, art and other high-end assets purchased by financiers and investors. But it is like an addictive drug, and we have a hard time imagining the slowing or stopping of QE (quantitative easing) without large adverse impacts on the prices of stocks and bonds and the performance of the economy. If the economy does not shift into sustainable high-growth mode as a result of QE, then the exit from QE is somewhere on the continuum between problematic and impossible."
It is impossible to say when all this will unravel, but one thing I am certain of is that those who think it won't be painful are in for yet another rude surprise.
In the same way, Ben Bernanke and the Federal Reserve are enabling the Too Big To Fail (or Jail) banks to make sub-prime mortgages destined for failure (after the reflated housing bubble collapses), which will again have to be bailed out with taxpayer money.
And then these executives at the Too Big To Fail (or Jail) banks become the largest corporate welfare recipients and multi-millionaires for skillfully manipulating the U.S. Government into bailing them out, after they have earned huge bonuses for making bad loans which eventually default.
Read your economic history.
There is NOT ONE instance in the history of paper currency that is not backed by anything that a government has not inflated out of existence. NOT ONE.
The FED is doing the same thing every other government has done throughout history.
There WILL be horrendous hyperinflation and this time it will be in all the advanced countries of the world.
A lot of people think that there will be blood in the streets, once this hyperinflation sets in.
I don't think any person [outside of bankers and their government cronies] wants this to happen, but a lot of people thinks it's going to happen.
By the way if YOU believe the what the government is saying, I pity you.
Folks want you to think that for the first time in World History, stocks are safer than bonds. Well they aren't, you can still lose 100 percent of your stock investment. Treasuries, if you lose 100 percent in those, the World must have ended so it really won't matter about anything at that point. The biggest thing is making sure you have a Stable place to live. Jobs come and go so of course, everyone tries to put money aside for rainy days when you do have one.
Fact is some workers don't make enough additional cash to even contribute to any investment plan, 401K or anything else. Make your own choices but if your company matches dollar for dollar, that's hard to beat. However there is no such thing as stable when the Global Feds are running Wild. Why do you think they are running wild? Because it's a stinking mess that's only getting worse.
"the still-undetermined and never-before-attempted process of ending this gigantic experimental policy."
One thing you can count on is that any great unwind won’t be orderly and controlled. No Central Bank wants to be the one responsible for starting it. They will all jawbone it, but none will actually do it voluntarily. So, the honors and the blame for it all will go to the one that snaps first; like a wound up spring being released.
How convenient that the collapse and ensuing calamity will all be blamed on Cyprus, The Maldives, or some other tangential player instead of the ones who started it all in the first place.
Oh, I almost forgot, "No one will have seen it coming." That's Wall Street's 21st centrury addition to that other tired old disclaimer, "Past performance is no guarantee of future outcomes."
Is anyone ever going to see inflation for what it is, destroying savings of everyone that saves a little. This has been going on forever, all over the world. I could see this in 1946, others must have seen the same thing. Little people cannot work at a job and study money at the same time. We have to make a day to day living. I though Germany might hold out, but it looks like they are about to cave in, with the rest of the world. 100 to 1 inflation makes saving worthless. No one will mention inflation.
Thanks for saying something about the problem.
You know things are really bad, and that something is up, when the religious "end-of-the-world arguments are identical with the seculiar "collapse" arguments.
What I find particularly intriguing is the "when". The religious theorists are smart. They say that only God knows when the end will come. The seculiarists haven't a clue. The system has been running on evil for so long that they can't find anything but the devils passing for God.
The devils are perfectly happy to be obliging. Everyday is the end of days. Buy that house now while interest rates are low, low, low (again). Buy stocks while you still can (again). There has never been a better time to contribute to your 401k (yeah, I really like that one). If you try to protect yourself with gold and silver, the totally and completley manipulated markets trash commodities.
The end will probably will start when all those retired folks, who counted upon 3-6 percent interest on their savings, are bled down to nothing by trying to live on almost zero interest rates. That could be years. The end will come when the Baby Boomers join them.
The end will probably come when the end of fiat currency comes to the U.S. dollar. All faith and trust must be lost before that happens, and there are so many zombified Americans walking around, saying how everything is so wonderful, that it could be a decade, or another market crash, before they even try to wake up.
The end? Could come when the USD loses its status as the Reserve Currency, then it is "Welcome to the Banana Republic." This really could happen anytime. If Japan defaults, the world will make the U.S. pay. If Europe collapses (meaning if just one of the PIIGS goes), the world will make the U.S. pay. It could come if the BRICS come together to form their own Reserve Currency. This could happen anytime. Even in 2013. And the new Reserve Currency will be backed by something, like gold.
The end could come when people realize that there is a difference between paper gold and physical gold. I can't believe how stupid people are to even own paper gold. The end could come when banks say they do not have the gold to pay off all these ETFs floating around. Germany has already discovered this when they tried to claim their physical gold from the Bank of New York. The bank doesn't have their gold, anymore. Who has Germany's gold? Who knows.
But people are so stupid the facts don't even register. When ABM Ambro said they would no longer be allowing their gold customers to redeem their paper gold with physical gold you would have thought people would have gotten the hint.
Meanwhile, hang onto your gold and silver. As soon as the end comes the value of commodities will go through the roof.
lol i have already seen we might have a depression with the feds stupidity and the world following us. I am putting as much money as i can in a safety deposit box. I am starting to stock pile food and i am buying two guns a shotgun and an automatic pistol. I for one don't trust our government anymore. the democrats and republicans are lying to us on a daily basis.
I dont know why these stupid evangelists cant figure this out and get some politicians in office that can save us because believe it or not in a depression a lot of them gonna be losers also.
I don't think anyone that understands what is happening, believes QE is going to fix the problems. It's a band aid and most are keeping their fingers crossed that the economy would start holding it's own before inflation forces QE to retrench. Deficit spending & QE are both both band aids and go hand in hand to balance money suppy in our economy. If any one is looking for a good policy, it's to start reducing our public debt, and QE along with it. And, it's going to take awhile. We can't just axe government programs over night which would have brutal consequences on people, but we can begin to slowly reverse the trend and correct the imbalance in revenues & spending.
I keep reproducing this quote attributed to Thomas Jefferson: Big government will spend too much and tax too little. The implication being the big government has it's real problems, not that it's constituents should be taxed out of productivity. Or stated differently, there is no free lunch,.
Funny thing, the Real Economy isn't supposed to be played as some ponzi game via graduate level courses. In fact, they are they ones that created the CRAP we keep bailing Big Banks out for. Problem is, there is far more bogus crap on Big Banks balance sheets then what Uncle Ben and the Global Feds can buy on Credit. Now, empowered by the backward Global Feds, the Big Banks are creating more crap, and the corrupt Feds are willing to buy more.
So sure, the Feds are printing Money, it's just a far more complex way of doing it. It's not quite like a fiscal Dollar, but once all the bogus accounting is done, the effect is the same, more Money in the System then what you would see in a normal free market.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
ABOUT BILL FLECKENSTEIN
This column is a synopsis of Bill Fleckenstein's daily column on his website, FleckensteinCapital.com, which he's been writing on the Internet since 1996. Click here to find Fleckenstein's most recent articles.
[BRIEFING.COM] The major averages punctuated a solid week with a subdued Friday session. The S&P 500 shed 0.2% to narrow its weekly gain to 1.7%, while the Nasdaq Composite (+0.1%) displayed relative strength. The tech-heavy index finished the week in line with the benchmark average.
Market participants went into today's session expecting to hear some new insight from Fed Chair Janet Yellen, who delivered the keynote address at this year's Jackson Hole Symposium. Unfortunately, the ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|
As the devil-may-care bravado of Wall Street marches on, history warns that -- in the end -- there will be the devil to pay.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'