9/17/2012 5:31 PM ET|
Are dollar stores really worth it?
With their ultralow prices, dollar stores offer serious bargains for thrifty consumers. But in some cases, it's better to shop elsewhere.
It costs just a dollar. What a deal! Even Wal-Mart, the Goliath of retailing, has added a $1 bargain shopping area in its stores, and you can't walk into a Target without passing the $1 specials right at the front door. Even families with incomes that allow them to shop at the best stores are choosing to cruise the aisles of the local dollar store.
Dollar stores are a bargain hunter's dream. Or are they? In their lust to grab a deal, many shoppers fail to realize dollar stores aren't always the bargain they seem. In fact, some big-box retailers can actually be a better place to buy, both in quality and in price.
Is it really $1?
A lot of really great deals can be found at dollar stores, but you have to search for them. If you look, you'll discover that not all dollar stores are equal. There are some where every item is truly $1 or less, there is the 99 cents store where everything costs that amount, and there are dollar store retailers where items can be as high as $10 or more. To get the best deals at any dollar store, you should determine the items you are shopping for and plan accordingly. Make a list, scour the ads in the paper, and call to see if the store accepts coupons.
The better deals
Here are a few of the best buys to be found at dollar stores:
Disposable items: Paper plates, napkins, party decorations and greeting cards can be found at significant savings. Dollar stores have an abundance of these items in many themes, for $1 or less. If you're buying items for a child's birthday party, graduation party or any other "get-together" where you need paper products, the dollar store is going to have the best value.
Seasonal items: These are another great deal. If you need holiday cards, decorations or ornaments, particularly for a school or office party, shop at a dollar store. They have a good assortment of traditional holiday items for most major holidays. Don't expect them to hold up over one or two seasons, however, and don't expect to find anything unique. The seasonal items for sale here will be very traditional (think pumpkins, Santa and the Easter Bunny).
Baby: Surprisingly, the dollar store is an inexpensive store to purchase a pregnancy test. At larger retailers, these tests can run $7 to $12. AAt the dollar store they cost $1, and they are the same testing kits as those sold at drugstores.
Kitchenware: One of the best dollar-store bargains where you truly get great value is kitchen items. Rubber spatulas, serving tongs, glassware and most kitchen gadgets can be purchased here for 50% to 90% less than at Wal-Mart or Target. Whether you are buying supplies for a dorm or your first apartment or replacing those that are worn out, the dollar store is the place to get them at a great price and at a decent quality.
Books: Children's books are a great buy at dollar stores. You can buy an assortment of easy readers, coloring books and activity books for 50 cents to $1 each. Sometimes the store will even bundle them so you can get several for $1. These stores occasionally have young adult books and novels, though the selection isn't always great.
Other items: Other bargains are paintbrushes and paint trays, masking tape, duct tape and, surprisingly, garden seeds. Unless it's a special paintbrush, many of us will throw it away after one use. It's far better to throw away a paintbrush that cost $1 than a $5.99 paintbrush from a large retailer.
- Calculator: When will you become a millionaire?
If you look, you can also find great deals on plastic storage tubs, but you do have to look. Many times these items are cheaper when they are on sale at Wal-Mart, and you must carefully look at the quality of the plastic. Some storage tubs from the dollar store simply don't hold up to even moderate use.
Changing shopping habits
There's no doubt there are bargains to be found at dollar stores. According to Britt Beemer, the chairman and founder of America's Research Group, these stores are growing in sales, taking "20% to 25% of annual sales from other retail categories."
The customer base is changing as well. Originally, dollar stores tended to serve lower-income customers, but with the stagnant economy, upper-income and even affluent customers are now shopping there. In response, dollar stores have been adding more merchandise, such as frozen or refrigerated food; they are staying open later; and they are improving their storefronts, creating more inviting stores.
It's cheaper at the big-box stores
While all of these are great incentives to step inside a dollar store, the bottom line that will bring consumers back is price. Often, better deals can be found at larger retailers, particularly when they have sales and when they accept coupons. That's when prices can be significantly better than at a dollar store.
Cheaper is not always better, and you will actually save money by spending a bit more. Purchasing quality clothing, brand-name food products, batteries, electronics and toys will save you dollars and ensure safety.
More from Investopedia:
- Top 6 mindless money wasters
- How much does your pet truly cost?
- How to save money at the grocery store
Consumer Reports warns against purchasing medications and vitamins at dollar stores, noting that these items might not contain the same ingredients as the name brands. Sometimes they are out of date, and often they don't list the country where the product was manufactured. This can be a concern, as some countries do not adhere to the food and pharmaceutical regulations in the United States.
Consumer Reports also recommends that you don't purchase electrical cords at dollar stores, as many of them are not UL-approved (such cords were the subject of a recent recall). Do not purchase toys, particularly those for infants, as many toys on dollar store shelves contain lead and other ingredients that could be harmful.
Toothpaste is another item that you should purchase at a large retailer carrying name-brand products. The Food and Drug Administration issued a warning about toothpaste from China (which is sold mostly at dollar stores), saying it was "found to be contaminated with diethylene glycol."
You should also carefully consider food purchases at a dollar store. Many food items found on dollar store shelves are from "unregulated" countries, meaning they may not have the same quality as name-brand products.
The bottom line
Dollar stores are a great place to save serious money, but you must be an astute shopper. As the old adage says, "If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is." Comparison-shop for not only price but quality as well. Paying a few more dollars for a premium product that will give you years of use will save you more money than buying a cheaper item that won't be around very long. If you have any doubts about a product, don't purchase it. That advice should be followed in every store where you shop.
More from Investopedia:
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
One thing that the article didn't mention was to watch out for size differences in the products at dollar stores. The product may be cheaper than at Wal-mart but it may also be a smaller size. In other words, you need to be aware of the cost per unit.
I can vouch for those dollar store pregnancy tests. They really do work. Ive used them with all 3 of my children. I think its ridiculous that pregnancy tests are anywhere from 12 to 20 bucks when all your going to do is pee on it!
You need to bargain shop everywhere you go unless your made of money.
Dollar stores have a lot to offer. Have you ever noticed that the people who shop in the Dollar store appear to be unstressed, happy, and courteous? People from all income levels love to shop in the Dollar store. Who really likes to pay $4-5 for a greeting card and then add gift wrap for another $4-5 when you can get a card and gift wrapping for $2. Who wants to spend $3-5 on a disposalbe tin when you can buy a tin for $1. Let's be honest. The Dollar store has good value. Yes, a person could shop in greater quanties and bulk and pay less, but who wants to lug and store cases of any product for six months, etc. If you can shop, store, and lug in bulk, good for you, but for those who physically can't or who are on a budget or just don't like to or want to spend money unless they must, the Dollar store is the place for them. Before I go into the A&P, I stop at the dollar store first - fill up my cart (tin foil, disposable pans, plastic baggies, plastic wrap, dish detergent, laundry detergent, bleach, air freshners, hand soap, napkins, paper plats, shampoo, body wash, batteries, lip gloss, nail polish, cotten balls, nail polish remover etc. and go to the register. I usually don't buy food items--just my personal preference, but I know many who do and they are fine. I have tried their frozen ice and pizza and they were perfectly fine - same brand as the store just less. I give Dollar store, especially mine, a rating of ten. Ten being the highest and best.
I love the dollar stores for party and office supplies, cleaning products, hair accesories, spices, and anything name brand, but I will not buy toilet paper, paper towels or detergent. First of all the toilet paper is of poor quality and most of the paper towels are not as absorbent and do not last long unless it is bounty of course. I rather buy a 12 pack name brand toilet paper and eight pack bounty paper towel at Walmart and Walgreens because they are quality and last for a very long time. I have bought many kitchen gadgets at the dollar store which I have been using for years and they all seem to be good quality. So, like many said you just have to know what to purchase at the dollar stores. I save a lot of money at dollar stores. Thank God for them especially in such a depressing economy.
What a load of crap! How much did Wal Mart pay you to right this BS? Dollar stores are amazing, and the quality of what they sell if every bit as good, or better, than similar goods sold elsewhere for much more money. I despise WalMart, and our local discount chain (similar to WM) sells very low quality items.
Your comments "don't expect them to last more than a year or two--NONSENSE. And "unregulated", "from countries with poor oversight--THAT IS JUST AN OUTRIGHT LIE!! Virtually everything is made in China, regardless of which store you buy it from, and China is famous for selling defective, dangerous stuff: poison pet food, watered down milk beefed up with formica, toys with cadmium, lead, date-rape drug (really--on toys!). This is about the point of origin--NOT THE STORE IT IS SOLD IN.
Pharmaceuticals are made almost exclusively in China, with little or no regulation or oversight, and legendary corruption in what oversight there is. Don't blame the dollar stores, and don't think that by paying more you are any better off. The Chinese are polluting the world, and flooding the world market with cheap, dangerous goods--but it is happening because of the greed of US companies--the Almighty Dollar! If you buy defective crap in China, the grossly overpaid CEOs can make $200 million per year, instead of a mere $100 million.
You should be sued for such blatantly biased and inaccurate information. Cheap, defective, dangerous goods are not the fault of dollar stores--they are sold at virtually all stores, regardless of what you pay.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'