Updated: 9/22/2010 9:00 AM ET|
Can paying old bills hurt your credit?
A reader wonders whether paying debts from a half-decade ago is a good idea -- or whether it would restart the clock for their inclusion in his credit reports.
Dear Debt Adviser:
I have several collection accounts from long ago -- more than five years ago -- that are for relatively small amounts. I am wondering: If I pay those debts, does that restart the seven-year period where they will remain on my credit reports? Or is it seven years from when they were first reported?
Most of those accounts would drop off my credit reports within two years anyway. Am I better off not paying them for this reason? -- Scott
Better off not paying them? Dream on! Sure, it would be great if you could improve your credit and not have to pay the bills. I'm afraid that in your case, it just ain't so. You are confusing the time limit for negative items to appear on your credit reports and the statute of limitations for collecting a debt in court.
You are far from alone in mistaking one for the other. Here's how it works.
The Fair Credit Reporting Act states that most negative items must be removed from a person's credit reports seven years after the first date of "uninterrupted delinquency," which is more than 180 days past due. Bankruptcies, federal debts and child support are among a few exceptions.
Making payments on the account or paying off the account does not in any way affect the allowable time the item can appear in credit reports. For example, the original account that was turned over to collections must be removed from your account seven years after it was first reported delinquent. So, if that date was March 3, 2004, the account would be removed from your credit reports March 2, 2011.
That brings up another misconception I'd like to address: Many people believe once a collection account is paid, it will be removed from their credit reports. That is not true. An account less than 7 years old will remain on your reports even if it is paid. However, any potential lender, landlord or employer would much rather see a paid collection account than an unpaid one. This is why I recommend paying off your collection accounts.
Statute of limitations
The statute of limitations on a debt is a different issue and varies by state. It has nothing to do with credit reporting. You can find the statute of limitations for your state by visiting your state's attorney general website. The clock starts from the last date of a payment activity on the account. So, if you have not made a payment on an account for five years and the statute in your state is four years, you may use the statute of limitations to prevent the account from being collected in court.
The important thing to keep in mind is the last date of activity. Any type of payment or, in some states, a written agreement to pay is considered an activity and can restart the clock on the statute of limitations.
Another somewhat fine point of the statute of limitations is that although the debt cannot be enforced in court, you'll need to show up to dispute the debt. A second point is that although creditors can't use the courts to collect, they can do everything short of getting a court order for garnishment to collect the debt. They can still write, call and generally be a royal pain.
The best way I know of to get an expired debt -- one past the statute-of-limitations date -- out of your life is to have an attorney write to the collection agency saying it is to contact only the lawyer regarding the debt and that you don't intend to pay anything. This will generally deter even the most determined collector, because pursuing a debt that is past the statute of limitations will be a waste of time.
Whether an account has passed the statute of limitations for collection has no bearing on how long it stays on your credit reports. If it were me and the amounts were small, I'd pay off the debts to put an end to any future collection activity and clean up my credit reports for anyone who sees them for the next two years.
This article was reported by Steve Bucci for Bankrate.com.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
I'm sorry but this article, while somewhat factual, is contradicting.
For instance: "Making payments on the account or paying off the account does not in any way affect the allowable time the item can appear in credit reports" BUT "Any type of payment or, in some states, a written agreement to pay is considered an activity and can restart the clock on the statute of limitations."
In my case I had 6 doctor bills from 2003 on my credit report. In 2008 I paid three of them and was planning to pay the last three when I notice the dates increased on the "This item will be removed" section. After doing some research I did not pay the last three bills adn they are now off my credit report. The three I paid will be on there until 2013, because the LAST ACTIVITY was that I paid them, therefore ADDING 7 MORE years!
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.