3/1/2013 7:00 PM ET|
Does rent-to-own ever make sense?
A consumer who chose to rent in order to boost her credit score weighs in on whether this strategy is worthwhile.
Under normal circumstances, Amy Willingham would never buy furniture from a rent-to-own store. After all, getting furniture and electronics on a rent-to-own contract is usually much more expensive than buying goods from a traditional retail store.
But Willingham had a special reason to go the rent-to-own route: poor credit, and the lure of boosting it. Someone at a national chain of rent-to-own stores told her that the company "will report your positive credit once you have made six diligent payments." "I got furniture from them just for that reason," she said.
Willingham made six on-time payments, and then asked the store manager about reporting them to the three national credit bureaus. "He balked," Willingham says.
That makes sense, especially since the company's website explicitly states that there is no credit needed to make a purchase, and there's no credit check involved. In fact, the industry exists specifically to help people who have been shut out of mainstream credit, says Richard May, public affairs director for the Association of Progressive Rental Organizations, a rent-to-own industry trade association.
"The credit world is the reason why rent-to-own exists," May says. "These customers were rejected (for credit), so they have nowhere else to go. With rent-to-own you never go into debt, and you never have to make the next payment."
Which means that any salesman who promised a credit score boost from a rent-to-own purchase was probably embellishing the facts to try to make the sale, says Barry Paperno, a credit scoring expert and Credit.com's community director.
"They don't report to credit bureaus, period," May says.
Rent-to-own customers agree to pay weekly, biweekly or monthly. If they make all the payments, they get to keep the item. If they miss a payment, the store can repossess it. But unlike a repossessed car or a foreclosed home, that repossession is not reported to the national credit bureaus, so it has no impact on the consumer's credit score.
There are approximately 8,600 rent-to-own stores in the U.S. and Canada, according to APRO. The number of rent-to-own customers has grown from 3.3 million in 1998 to 4.1 million in 2010, and the industry's annual sales have grown from $4.7 billion to $7.6 billion during the same period, the association says.
Meanwhile, rent-to-own retailers are consistently criticized by regulators and consumer advocates. Customers who ultimately purchase items from rent-to-own stores (as opposed to renting for a while before returning the goods) wind up paying two to three times more over the life of the contract than they would have by simply buying the same things outright at retail price, according to congressional testimony last summer by the Federal Trade Commission.
Most consumers find themselves paying too much, since 70% of rent-to-own customers eventually purchase their rented items, the FTC found.
Other customers complain that the rental contract wasn't adequately explained, that they were given used merchandise that was advertised and sold as new, and that they were treated poorly when their payments were late or the merchandise was repossessed, the FTC found.
"(T)hese sales are made at astronomic, and undisclosed, annual percentage rates," according to Americans for Financial Reform, a coalition of consumer advocate groups. "Under most (rent-to-own) contracts, the customer will pay between $1,000 and $2,400 for a TV, stereo, or other major appliance worth as little as $200 retail, if used, and seldom more than $600 retail, if new.
Industry representatives acknowledge the high costs.
"You can wind up paying two to 2.5 times the retail price," says May.
All of which means that, in most cases and for most consumers, buying goods on a rent-to-own plan is the wrong way to go, credit experts say.
"I have a hard time thinking of a situation where rent-to-own is a good idea," says Gerri Detweiler, Credit.com's consumer credit expert.
Rent-to-own does offer some advantages, however, especially if a consumer needs furniture for only a short time. For example, if someone's employer or client is planning to send her to a different city for a few months to work, rent-to-own might be a quick way to furnish an apartment and make such a stay comfortable, Paperno says.
"If money is no object, and you're just looking for a convenient way to get furniture for a temporary residence, then it might make sense," Paperno says.
The industry acknowledges that short-term rentals are the way to go.
"The fewer payments you make and the less time you make them, it's not that expensive," May says. "The longer you go, the more it's going to cost."
Rent-to-own might also make sense for consumers whose income is unsteady, says May. If a person is worried about a pay cut or a layoff, a rent-to-own contract could help furnish a home without putting the items on a credit card, since an unpaid credit card bill surely would hurt the person's credit score.
"It makes sense to different customers, including those who have unsure financial stability," May says. "It all comes down to the premise of that no obligation, no debt."
But for someone with an unstable income, paying too much for furniture now could cause more serious financial stress later. Most consumers can easily find cheaper options online.
If she could do it over again, Willingham certainly would make a different choice. Paying too much, with no help for her low credit score, "made me wish I would have gone elsewhere to purchase furniture," she says.
More from Credit.com:
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
You can't legislate away stupidity. You can't regulate away bad choices and decisions. Everyone has a right to fail and inevitably, some will exercise this right repeatedly.
Once upon a time, there were shysters,then loansharks and now Rent-to-Own....
Wonder what's next ?? Oh yeah, I forgot Reverse Mortages..
When you look a auto ads today, you seldom see the purchase price - it's almost always the lease price - and something like $2000 up front in small print at the bottom of the screen. If you're foolish enough to change cars every few years, that might be the way to go. But for people like me that keep their cars for 10-16 years, the $18,000 I just paid total for a Honda Fit works out to $100 per month in 2013 dollars if I keep it for 15 years.
Rent to own is almost always a loser's game but not always. My son played minor league baseball for about 6 seasons all over the country. The seasons are about 5 months or so and you never know who you might be traded or moved to on very little notice.
They would usually rent a 2 bedroom apartment and share with at least one other person and rent furniture, tv, etc. Worked out good for them and the rental places treated the players well since they knew if they did not, the teams would blackball any rental place that screwed with the players. That is one of the few instances that I would say these short term rental places works out financially.
This article is not entirely correct. The rent to own companies do not report your payments to the credit agencies after 6 payments but they do report once you've completed paying on the contract. Additionally, you can pay any amount you want (like a credit card) not just the minimum payment. Also they offer 90 days same as cash and their purchase prices are very competitive with other retailers. Sure, if you pay the minimum throughout the term of your contract then absolutely you will pay 2 1/2 times the original purchase price but that is no different from credit cards - so all you judgemental hypocrites bashing people who use RTO companies - hope you dont have credit card debt because you are no different then the people purchasing from RTO companies.
and RTO companies are not Rental companies. rental companies are not in the business to sell things, they are in the business to rent items that you may only need once or twice or cannot afford to purchase on your own. Rental companies want their item back so they can rent it to someone else who doesnt want to buy it. RTO companies are in the business to sell items - they dont want the item back once you've used it - they want you to keep it and pay it off. Some companies call it "in house financiing" - it's still a sale, they just agree to let you make payments.
it's cause most of the younger society are brainwashed by liberals and media that if you don't have it
all NOW your not worth anything! so people borrow, cheat, steal, charge things they don't really need
to live! back in the day you bought the necessities and saved up for a tv or stereo or car etc...now they
have to have big screen tvs and video games and iphones and ipads etc....and don't care they don't
have the money! many are on welfare and foodstamps have all these things driving new fing cars! I
see it in my apt building! i work everyday and can't afford a new car but i see people i know don't work
and some have part time and low paying jobs driving new cars! how is that possible? the liberals and
govt have made people think that they shouldn't have to work hard to have the extra things in life! it's
the liberal mentality if i can have it then the govt will give it to me!
Rent to own places now have kiosks set up in retailers like furniture stores. They do report to only 1 credit bureau and charge up to three times the retail value. If this merchandise is picked up before the lease is fully paid for, the rent to own company puts it in as a repossession. They will call you on the day the payment is due at work, home or friends. They will come to your door, contact your neighbors and show up at your work. Do we need our "things" that bad, or can it wait? I say, "let it wait".
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
RECENT ARTICLES ON CREDIT SCORES
State Farm says cost of deer-strike repairs up 14 percent, and drivers' odds of hitting one have increased as well.