11/29/2010 9:54 PM ET|
Is peer-to-peer lending coming back?
It's a variation on loans between friends or family members, but websites offer investors with money to lend a way to check out prospective borrowers' history.
Last year, my sister and brother-in-law wanted to remodel their kitchen.
They both have good, secure jobs and great credit scores, and could easily have raised the money they needed, even in this economic climate.
However, at the same time my mom had quite a hefty balance in a high-yield savings account.
With bank rates running low, it didn't take them long to work out that my mother could earn more interest, and my sister pay less, if they cut out the bank, and worked out loan terms between themselves.
And that, in essence, is what peer-to-peer lending (aka person-to-person or P2P lending ) is all about.
By eliminating the costly overheads and shareholder profits of banks (not to mention those bonuses), a loan between individuals can make both the borrower and lender better off.
None of this is new. Families and friends have been helping each other out for millennia.
P2P lending websites
What is new is the Web. This allows strangers to lend and borrow through a middleman website that charges a fraction of the mark-up that banks take for, in effect, brokering a loan. The first of these sites in America, Prosper, began in 2006, and by October 2010 had attracted more than a million members and funded $205 million worth of loans.
The other big player in this country is LendingClub, which was founded the following year and, also by October 2010, had funded 17,630 loans worth over $170 million.
You've already spotted the flaw in this model. You wouldn't lend your hard-earned cash to some guy who walked up to you in the street and asked for money, so why would you do so to a total stranger?
Well, Prosper, LendingClub and similar sites do all they can to tell you what you need to know about that stranger. Prosper lets pretty much anyone post a request to borrow money, but it also allows prospective lenders to view each person's history, credit details and loan-to-income ratio. LendingClub goes even further. It vets every loan application before it's posted, and 90% of those never make it onto the site. And it, too, provides detailed information on every borrower.
If you're really smart, you may have spotted another problem. Prosper was founded in 2006, LendingClub in 2007 and in 2008 . . . we saw the biggest crash in recent history. People lost huge sums of money in real estate and the stock market. And some did -- although usually smaller sums -- in peer-to-peer lending, too. And, of course, these person-to-person loans aren't secured by the FDIC.
Let's face it: Hard-nosed bank managers and credit card underwriters -- all trained professionals who know a thing or two about risk -- also had enormous losses. The same applied in P2P lending. Those who lent to people with poor credit in return for 20%-plus rates tended to take the biggest hits.
That may explain why LendingClub claims that many fewer of its members -- especially those who spread risk widely -- had losses than those in some other programs. Its pre-screening prevented lenders from making subprime loans.
Eggs and baskets
Of course, not everyone had losses, which is, presumably, why these sites are not only still in business, but also adding lenders and borrowers all the time. And there are ways to spread your risk.
Suppose you have $10,000 to invest. You'd be either mad or very brave to hand the whole lot over to one stranger, no matter how stellar his or her credit score is.
A better strategy is to put a bit of your lump sum into a number of loans -- up to 400, in fact. Because $25 is the minimum you can put into one loan note. Now, the only way you could lose all your money would be if all 400 defaulted before their first payments were due, an exceedingly unlikely scenario even today.
Prosper rates are largely determined by the borrower, who states the highest he or she is prepared to pay. Lenders then review the file and decide whether or not to invest by balancing risk against return. They can bid under the highest rate that the borrower has indicated, and -- when the full amount needed has been subscribed -- those who bid the lowest get to make the loan. Obviously, borrowers who set their rates too low don't get their loans.
LendingClub operates differently. It sets the rate (usually between 8% and 25%) in accordance with its appraisal of the credit risk. Because this site pre-screens borrowers, pretty much 100% of applications that appear succeed.
Published Nov. 29, 2010
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.