6/23/2011 3:27 PM ET|
Skip Pimco's flagship bond fund
Bill Gross is the world's pre-eminent bond fund manager. But his Pimco Total Return fund is too big, and there are better alternatives.
Pimco's Bill Gross -- the world's most famous and influential bond fund manager -- suggested at this month's Morningstar Investor Conference that anyone looking for good yields should forgo Treasurys and turn instead to foreign bonds and, notably, high-quality, dividend-paying stocks.
The message wasn't exactly new, but the takeaway was different.
If the recommendation was to buy stocks -- something Gross' flagship fund, Pimco Total Return (PTTAX) can't do -- and become a more nimble purchaser of bonds, then Gross was effectively suggesting that investors buy something besides his fund.
And he's right, because a strong case can be made that Pimco Total Return is the Stupid Investment of the Week, a regular MarketWatch feature that highlights conditions and characteristics that make a security less than ideal for the average investor.
While it is hard to imagine that the world's pre-eminent bond manager has suddenly turned stupid relative to his peers -- and this column is not intended as a sell signal -- there's a strong case to be made that investors would be better off going elsewhere, even in the bond-fund world.
That said, there is no denying Gross' greatness. Since he started Pimco Total Return in the middle of 1987, it's had an annualized average return of more than 8%, roughly a full percentage point ahead of its benchmark, the Barclays Capital U.S. Aggregate Bond Index.
In the income-generating space, that difference -- for a quarter-century -- is huge.
And there's no evidence Gross has lost his touch over time, either, as the spread between the fund and the index has been wider over the past five years.
While more recent results have been below par -- the fund is below average and trailing the index year-to-date -- the real problem here is not the past but the future. There, Gross' success actually creates a bit of a problem.
According to investment researcher Morningstar, Pimco Total Return now has $245 billion in assets spread over all of its share classes. That makes it the world's largest mutual fund, bigger all by itself than a number of the bond-market subcategories that it invests in. Pimco manages an equivalent sum across more than five dozen public and private pools, the best known being Harbor Bond Fund (HABDX), a fund I like enough to have once recommended it to my father.
That's roughly $500 billion invested in this one strategy, and Gross is about to open an exchange-traded-fund version of Pimco Total Return. The ETF won't be a perfect match for the fund's approach, which benefits from derivative strategies that Gross won't be able to use under the new structure. But it is likely to swell the assets by a few more billion dollars pretty quickly.
With Gross having shown his disdain for Treasurys -- though he is heavily invested in mortgage-backed securities, which, functionally, is a distinction without much difference -- finding yield elsewhere is a huge challenge for a fund as large as Pimco Total Return.
Where Gross might once have added value by finding the best bond deals and executing them better than the competition, even the best deals today are too small to have much impact on the fund.
Think of it as if your town suddenly floated a great bond issue, and Gross was ready to take the whole thing for the fund; if the float was $100 million -- enough to address a lot of financial issues in most municipalities -- it would still represent just 0.04% of Total Return's portfolio. In short, Gross could make a killing on the deal, but it would be too little to truly notice when absorbed into the fund.
Steve Goldberg of Tweddell Goldberg Investment Management in Silver Spring, Md., noted that if Gross can't use his unique gifts for identifying undervalued bonds as a way to outperform the competition, his ability to stay a step ahead will depend entirely on his macroeconomic market forecasts being right.
"Pimco has done better than any other firm in getting its bond calls right," Goldberg said, "but every market cycle makes someone look like a genius, only to lose it and look like a fool in the next cycle. . . . It's tough to make a living, or a mutual fund that is better than all the others, when your only way to add value is to have every market call be right, because no one -- not even Bill Gross -- is right all the time."
Goldberg also noted in a story he wrote on the Kiplinger website that "with the fund so big, the natural tendency is to play not to lose. After all, if you give investors decent performance, they probably won't bail out, even if they can do better elsewhere."
And the point is that, going forward in the bond space, investors most likely will be able to do better elsewhere, by picking lower-cost funds run by managers who are doing the things now that made Gross' fund famous in the first place. Pimco's expense ratios for Total Return are no better than average, which seems ridiculous for a fund so large, and its prospects are worse.
You buy this fund for Bill Gross, but, at its current size, he can't actually do much to affect performance.
"He talked at Morningstar about entering a period when interest-rate duration plays are not going to make it, so if you want to make money in bonds, you will have to make plays on credit risk," Goldberg said. "But the days when he can turn those plays into something that really makes Pimco Total Return continue to beat the average bond fund by so much are gone."
With that in mind, you might want to follow Gross' advice and diversify into bonds from Brazil, Canada and Germany, and into high-quality, dividend-paying stocks. But you don't want to diversify your holdings by owning his Total Return Fund.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
maybe Mr. Gross wants money to move from the cumbersomely large flagship fund to higher yielding foreign / corporate bond funds. i hope the author feels as smug after thinking this though as when he wrote such an easy article. it seems to me that Mr. Gross knows more than just bonds.
Joe in Japan
Who is Chuck Jaffe and why is he shilling for the investment companies? "Come on, people, move your money around! With Boomers retiring and this high unemployment, we can only make money by shuffling your investments... we're in the moving business, not the storage business" - Wall Street.
Please list the alternative bond funds and their relative performance after load; don't tell me which fund you recommended to your father.
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
[BRIEFING.COM] S&P futures vs fair value: +5.50. Nasdaq futures vs fair value: +13.70. U.S. equity futures hover near their pre-market highs with the S&P 500 futures trading six points above fair value.
Reviewing overnight developments:
- Asian markets ended on a mixed note. China's Shanghai Composite -0.3%, Hong Kong's Hang Seng +0.1%, and Japan's Nikkei +0.4%.
- Economic data was limited:
- Japan's industrial production increased 1.0% ... More
- Economic data was limited:
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|