12/21/2012 3:30 PM ET|
Why teens fail at managing money
Because they often leave high school with no education in personal finance, young people must overcome a steep learning curve when they enter the adult world.
High school students are studying up on calculus, advanced chemistry and world history, but most aren't learning fundamental money lessons to help them navigate the real financial world.
Such is the case with Jessica Pollack's son Adam, an 18-year-old who graduated in May from Los Alamitos High School in Orange County, Calif. Much to Jessica's chagrin, the school doesn't require its students to take a personal-finance class to graduate. "It's a top-rated school, but there is no personal-finance requirement, which is just astonishing to me," Pollack says. "There's a technology requirement that's statewide. As a technology teacher, I appreciate that, but these kids are exposed to computers and technology all the time. Yet when it comes to buying the computer and financing it, they're clueless."
Odds are your children will also graduate from high school without being taught basic money lessons, including how to create a budget or write a check. Though the recession has raised awareness about economic issues, it appears those heightened concerns have prompted few states to require a personal-finance class. Only 13 states currently require high school students to take a personal-finance class to graduate, according a survey released in March by the nonprofit Council for Economic Education (CEE).
Interest is there, opportunity is not
An interest in personal finance among high school students doesn't appear to be the issue. A recent poll by Sallie Mae found that 84% of high school students desire more financial education. Among 16- to 18-year-olds, 86% said they would rather learn about money management in the classroom than make financial mistakes in the real world, according to a 2011 survey by brokerage firm Charles Schwab.
Parents also have expressed concerns over their children's lack of financial knowledge. According to an August survey by MasterCard, 64% of parents of college-bound children are worried about their children's ability to manage money.
Many high schools appear to be doing the bare minimum to educate students about personal finance, says Ted Beck, the chairman of the JumpStart Coalition for Personal Financial Literacy, which trains teachers on how to instruct classes on personal finance. Beck also heads up the National Endowment for Financial Education (NEFE), a nonprofit that provides personal-finance training tools to teachers and financial-education resources to the public on its website. He says many schools bring in guest speakers, but that such efforts aren’t enough. "You can't learn a language in two hours, so having a two-hour visitor coming in to talk about money really doesn't provide the students with what they need," he says.
Nan Morrison, the president and chief executive of the CEE, says state governments are so focused on teaching the core subjects of math and English that personal finance often gets overlooked. "If you can't read and you can't count, all bets are off," she says. She adds that many cash-strapped states lack the funding to institute personal-finance instruction.
Conflicting viewpoints within a state's bureaucracy can also be an obstacle, says Maryland Comptroller Peter Franchot. Franchot was the key proponent behind a petition drive for the Maryland General Assembly to pass a bill in 2012 that would require all Maryland high school students to complete a stand-alone course in financial literacy to graduate. He says the state's current approach, which involves incorporating personal finance into other courses, is ineffective. "Embedding of financial literacy in classes is just a sop to avoid this issue, and it's developed by the education bureaucracy as a way to control their turf. That's why I haven't been able to get it through the legislature," he says. "Ultimately we will have it in Maryland, but you kind of have to drag the bureaucracy into it kicking and screaming."
Beck sees the same tug-of-war in states throughout the country. "You can't wave a wand and say, 'Every school must teach this now,'" he says.
Franchot adds that many state officials who oppose the bill cite funding costs as their biggest concern. However, he points out that Maryland's Carroll County, which chose independently to implement a stand-alone financial literacy course for all eight of its high schools, did so with just $37,700. The only recurring cost is $325 per teacher for a one-time training course, Franchot says. "The idea that you have to hire a bunch of new teachers and incur all sorts of new textbook costs and other sorts of expenses just isn't true," he says.
Discomfort among teachers and parents
Although Carroll County's training course was a minimal expense, Beck says getting teachers to feel comfortable teaching the subject may be a bigger challenge. If teachers provide students with misinformation about personal finance, it can have serious implications. Approximately 64% of Wisconsin teachers surveyed by the University of Wisconsin in Madison said they felt unqualified to address the state's financial literacy standards, and few felt "very competent" lecturing a class on topics such as risk management and debt. But more than 70% of teachers polled in a nationwide NEFE survey said they are willing to receive formal financial-education training to teach a financial literacy class.
Many parents are also uncomfortable with teaching their kids about money management. David Bruzzese, who co-authored the book "The Teen's Guide to Personal Finance: Basic Concepts in Personal Finance that Every Teen Should Know" with Joshua Holmberg, chalks it up to parents lacking confidence in their own financial knowledge. He says many parents haven't learned critical financial values themselves, so teaching their children may do more harm than good. "Parents may be passing along bad financial habits to their kids because that's all they know," Bruzzese says.
Morrison of the CEE agrees: "To say it's a parent's responsibility seems unfair -- unfair to the parents and unfair to the kids. You can't ask people to be responsible for teaching something if they haven't received the education themselves."
Consequently, money is among the lowest priorities in conversations between parents and their children; it ranks below talks about the importance of good manners and the benefits of good eating habits, according to a survey by Harris Interactive released in August.
So what role should parents play in teaching their children about money? Bruzzese says parents don't necessarily need to impart financial lessons to their children, but they should encourage discussions about the topic. Beck of NEFE agrees: "This should be a discussion, not a lecture," he says. "You want to make sure it's a comfortable thing to talk about around the dinner table."
While parents may not need to teach their children about advanced subjects such as 401k's and mutual funds, they can teach the basics, such as the difference between wants and needs. Another important concept is learning how to apply the time value of money. "Not spending $1.50 a day on a soda can have a big impact on a person's financial future, and that's something that young kids need to understand," Bruzzese says.
Tamsen Butler, the author of "The Complete Guide to Personal Finance For Teenagers & College Students," says parents need to be financial role models. "If you're buying a luxury car when you can't even afford to buy groceries without a credit card, you're setting a bad example for your kids," she says.
More from U.S. News and World Report:
- Basic money lessons you (probably) missed in high school
- 6 fun ways to teach kids about money
- How to teach your kids financial independence
A look inside one personal-finance classroom
Some parents avoid the subject of money altogether. "My parents don't talk about finances whatsoever. The stock market comes up a lot, but that's pretty much the extent of what we talk about," says Jake Gallagher, a junior at Rock Bridge High School in Columbia, Mo.
Instead, Gallagher learns about money management in a personal-finance course -- required by the state of Missouri for graduation -- taught by Susan Lidholm. Lidholm's class is a one-semester course, but the school also offers an accelerated version online in the summer. It covers topics such as budgeting, banking, using credit wisely and investing in human capital. "We all make mistakes in the finance world, but our class can help them avoid some of those catastrophes," Lidholm says.
As part of its consumer skills unit, Lidholm's class provides students with a real-world simulation that teaches them how to make practical decisions with their money. The students go to a car dealership, choose a vehicle and then research what would be a fair price, as well as calculate the estimated personal-property and sales taxes.
Curriculum material is a minimal expense, Lidholm says. In lieu of a textbook, the Missouri Council on Economic Education provides support to teachers, supplying them with lesson plans and other materials. "We don't use a textbook because the economy changes so quickly that textbooks would become outdated fast," Lidholm says. She adds that there is a lot of free material available to teachers, so educators can create a tailored curriculum that meets their state's requirements.
Perhaps a testament to the importance of making the class a requirement is that several students in Lidholm's class say they wouldn't have taken the course if it were optional, but they're glad they did. "I probably wouldn't have taken this by choice, but if I had the chance to do it over again, I would take it because we've learned so much about finances and how they apply to our future," says Joshua Baumer, a junior at Rock Bridge High School.
Personal-finance competitions are another way for teachers to foster student interest in the subject. Lidholm served as the coach to a Missouri team that included students from Rock Bridge in last year's National Personal Finance Challenge. To prepare, the students met twice a week to go over an expansive list of possible questions, chiseling down to specifics such as what age you can cash in your IRA without incurring a penalty (it's 59 1/2). After winning regionals, the team went on to claim the national championship title. Lidholm says it's gratifying to watch her students take such an interest in personal finance that they spend time outside the class learning about it.
Timing and empowerment
Is high school the right time for students to take a personal-finance class? Or should it be taught earlier, in middle school or even elementary school? The Maryland State Board of Education's president and vice president, along with the state's interim superintendent, wrote a column published in The Washington Post in February arguing that financial education can't wait until high school, citing experts who say children begin to develop their understanding of money much younger.
Yet Lidholm says she thinks teaching the class to high school juniors syncs well with what's going on in their lives: They're getting driver's licenses and figuring out how to finance their first car, becoming more aware of gas prices and starting to earn money from part-time jobs. And as juniors, they can learn about the implications of taking on student-loan debt while they're considering what college to attend. It's also worth learning how credit works before they go off to college and have to make their daily money decisions on their own.
Proponents of financial literacy say getting high school students to feel in control of their own financial lives is a matter of finding the right teacher, the right curriculum and enough governmental support.
More from U.S. News and World Report:
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Although it would be nice if the schools' provided this, but the primary responsibility should be the parents'. Introduce the children to a household budget, show them the how a mortgage works, what is financing, savings and checking accounts etc. The parents' provide the foundation regardless whether the schools' provide a home economics. There are so many books available for the parents to utilize in aiding this process. Managing money starts at home.
"Among 16- to 18-year-olds, 86% said they would rather learn about money management in the classroom than make financial mistakes in the real world, according to a 2011 survey by brokerage firm Charles Schwab."
This is a good example of assuming real world data from a designed survey. Consider it for a minute... you ask a question on a survey, "Would you rather learn about money management in the classroom than make financial mistakes in the real world?" What's the kid going to say - "no?"
How about asking the real question, "Do you want to add a required course in financial literacy to your junior year curriculum?" Think that will come up to 86%?
I don't think financial literacy is a bad idea, just making a comment on how one can make surveys say anything to give the desired result.
Not only are they not getting personal financial training, they are not getting enough education about government! Jay Leno has interviewed college students around campuses, and it is appaling about their lack of knowledge about Congress, etc. They know more about celebrities and sports figures than things that affect their future and that of the country. This lack of knowledge (maybe mostly interest) is apparent during elections of people to Congress. Many surveys indicate that the approval rating of Congress is quite low, and yet most of the representatives and senators are re-elected. Are voters too lazy to examine and pick some one else?
"If you mind your pennies, the dollars will take care of them selves" Ben Franklin
There is a major problem among teens/young adults with the "it's only a dollar, hit send" mentality. They down load isong for a buck by the hundreds if not thousands, and phone apps by the dozen, over the course of a year with out thinking. It's so easy to do. This develops terrible money management habits. Ask them how many of those songs they had to have, they actually listen to after a couple of months. I think the best thing for a parent to do is not pamper them and make them pay for their phones, cars, insurance and things that they want, but don't need. Have them get a job and send in their phone bill every month.
Know a 55 year step-daughter. No job, smokes like a chimmey, does not help mom with work, guess
what happens when mom goes on to heaven.
If there is a funding problem, get rid of some of the USELESS classes such as English Literature (Grammar class still important), World History, Art, even Calculus (Math was by far my most favorite class in high school). Replace those four classes with Personal Finance, Add an extra hour of Gym class, A Computer / Technology Literacy class, and Sex Education. Probably should start all of these classes in 7th grade, and again each year until graduation.
The States want kids to be financial 'dummies' so the banks, insurance companies, credit card companies, can take all of their money!
Not enough 'funding' is the biggest crock of you-know-what out there.
One of the most important things you can teach your children is how to handle money. We established credit union accounts for ours as minors. When they received money as gifts at holidays or birthdays, they had to put some portion into their long term savings, and start thinging in terms of a budget so they have been in training for about 10 years now.
During their senior year in high school we got a credit card for each of them that draws from this account and had them begin using it to fill the car up with gas, and nothing else but emergencies. We reimburse any gas expenses, so they have learned to not buy frivolous things just because they have money in the bank and realized it would be wasting their own money.
End result has been that both now know how to handle money and make decisions of needs vs. wants. Each year as they have more experience we add more cash to their accounts to pay for their college. They each now have control over ~ 80k in their accounts and are more careful not to waste any money in college because we have told them they get to keep whatever is left.
We will continue to give them money annually per the max allowed by tax laws to transfer some of their inheritance to them now, since my fear is that the govt. will just take more later if we wait. This strategy wouldn't work if they weren;t financially responsible, but we thought it better to risk that than trust the govt. wouldn't take more later in any estate we have left. Hope to beat the system and keep the money in our family and not our for govt. waste/the takers.
They learn from their parents.Most people don`t plan for their retirements and fall
hook, line and sinker to the advertisers.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
RECENT ARTICLES ON FAMILY & MONEY
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'