3/9/2011 2:57 PM ET|
A deal that could save your parents
Reverse mortgages have had a shady reputation, but they can keep some aging homeowners out of the poorhouse. Take a look at what these loans are like now.
Reverse mortgages are kind of like your black-sheep uncle. No matter how much he's cleaned up his act in recent years, people are still going to be suspicious.
And reverse mortgages have certainly had their problems. These loans -- which allow people 62 and over to tap their home equity without having to pay back the money until they die or move -- can be expensive, with fat upfront fees on top of continuing insurance costs.
Reverse mortgages also can be weapons in the hands of unscrupulous salespeople who persuade vulnerable seniors to take out loans on their properties so they can invest in overpriced annuities and other unsuitable products.
Jerry Vincent of San Diego remembers trying to convince his parents several years ago that they should get a reverse mortgage so they could have more money for living expenses. The elderly couple was on the verge of signing up when a friend mentioned he'd heard something negative about these loans, although he couldn't say exactly what. That was enough to scare them, and they never went through with the deal.
"I said, 'What is the point of living a long life if every day you are stressed about where the money will come from for the next routine maintenance of the house or car? Or denying yourself health care because some costs might be out of pocket?'" Vincent remembers telling them.
"Both of my parents ended up living hand to mouth until they died. I just wish I could have eased some of that stress for them."
Tougher regulation, new restrictions on fees and a brand-new type of federally backed reverse mortgage that's substantially cheaper have made these loans better deals for more seniors. There's anecdotal evidence that reverse mortgages may be helping some older people avoid foreclosure, replacing unaffordable payments with a no-payment loan, said real estate columnist Tom Kelly, the author of "The New Reverse Mortgage Formula."
"They can get a reverse mortgage and not have to worry about (mortgage) payments for the rest of their lives," Kelly said. "If they have enough equity and the loan balance is low enough, they can take out a reverse to simply stop the payments, plus have the possibility of pulling more cash out."
Paul Lints, 45, is helping his 85-year-old father set up a reverse mortgage on the dad's St. Louis home. The proceeds will be enough to pay off the $113,000 balance on the first mortgage, a $100,000 home equity loan balance plus $85,000 in credit card debt.
"My dad's been so strapped . . . and this will free up $3,000 to $4,000 a month for him, easy," said Lints, a private banker with PNC. "I'm not looking at it like, 'There goes my inheritance.' I told him, 'You worked your whole life. You've done everything a parent's supposed to do. . . . This is your money and your house.'"
All this still doesn't make a reverse mortgage a slam-dunk move, however, so if you're considering one or want to help your parents decide whether one makes sense, you'll need to do your research. Here's what you need to know:
How they work
A reverse mortgage is a loan against a home's equity, but no monthly payments are due, and the loan doesn't have to be paid back until the borrower dies or moves out. Seniors can get the money as a lump sum, a stream of monthly checks or a line of credit they can tap at will.
How much they can borrow depends mostly on their age, prevailing interest rates, the value of their homes and the caps of the lending program they choose. (AARP has a calculator that can give you a rough idea of how much can be borrowed.)
Seniors don't have to own their homes free and clear to get a reverse mortgage. If they have enough equity built up, they can get a reverse mortgage to pay off their current mortgage. ("Enough" is a relative term -- again, check the AARP calculator to see how much can be borrowed in each homeowner's situation.) This won't help homeowners who are "underwater" or anywhere close to it, since reverse mortgages typically max out at less than 60% of a home's value.
And a reverse mortgage doesn't wipe away other home-related bills. Reverse mortgage borrowers still need to keep current on homeowners insurance, property taxes and homeowners association fees. Otherwise, the loan would be considered in default. Technically, that could result in foreclosure, although the Federal Housing Administration has never thrown a reverse mortgage borrower out of a home and is unlikely to do so, said Peter Bell, the president of the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association. The FHA is pressuring lenders to take action on defaulted mortgages, but it wants action that's aimed at counseling borrowers and creating plans to help them get current on their obligations, Bell said.
Who makes them
These days, the vast majority of reverse mortgages are made under the FHA's federally backed Home Equity Conversion Mortgage, or HECM, program. Before the financial crisis, some private loans were available that allowed homeowners to tap more of their equity than was allowed by the FHA, but that market has all but disappeared, Bell said.
The amount that you can borrow is based on either your home's appraised value or the HECM limit of $625,500, whichever is lower.
FHA loans come in two basic flavors:
- The standard option allows you to borrow somewhat more but comes with a higher upfront insurance premium, which equals 2% of your home's value (or $6,000 on a home worth $300,000).
- The recently introduced HECM Saver allows you to borrow 10% to 18% less than the standard option, but the upfront insurance premium is just 0.01% (or $30 on a $300,000 home).
In addition to the upfront premium, there's a continuing annual insurance premium that equals 1.25% of the outstanding loan balance. If you borrowed a lump sum of $150,000 against that $300,000 home, the annual insurance premium would equal $1,875 the first year and would rise as your debt rose.
There is also now an HECM for Purchase Program, which allows older homeowners to make large down payments on new homes and then use reverse mortgages to finance the rest of the costs. This program was created after FHA officials noticed some seniors were downsizing and then getting a reverse mortgage on their new property, paying closing costs twice -- first on the real estate closing and then on the reverse mortgage. The HECM for Purchase has just one set of fees, although as with other reverse mortgages, the homeowner must have substantial equity in his or her current home.
What they cost
In addition to the insurance premiums, you'll face lender fees: an origination fee of up to $6,000 plus closing costs. Some lenders are waiving or reducing these fees, but combined with the insurance costs they can add $15,000 or more to the cost of the loan.
It's important to understand that you don't typically pay these fees out of pocket. They're deducted from your loan amount, so interest accrues on these costs as well as on the money you actually get to use. Since you don't make payments on this loan, your debt grows over time.
It's the traditionally high cost of reverse mortgages that made them a "last resort" option for so many years -- to be considered only after you've exhausted all your other assets. Even downsizing -- selling your home and moving, despite the considerable expenses involved -- was often recommended as a better option, when such a move was feasible and the senior was willing to consider it.
The reduced costs of the HECM Saver have changed the math, however. Now a senior might consider a reverse mortgage instead of tapping other assets, or even if she didn't plan to be in the home for years to come. In fact, Kelly said, it might be an option to go for an HECM Saver while waiting a few years for the housing market to recover, so she could sell it at a higher price.
What the dangers are
There are a number of drawbacks to consider, some obvious, some less so. Here are some of them:
- Because the accumulated debt grows over time, there may be little or no equity left in the home after the borrower dies or moves out and the loan has to be paid off. That's one of the concerns that Vincent's parents had. "As their only major asset, they felt that their home was supposed to be left for the children," he said. "As virtuous as that was, I tried to convey to them to take care of themselves first and that it was a quality-of-life issue."
- Complications can ensue if a borrower's spouse or significant other is not on the loan but wants to continue living in the home after the borrower dies or moves out permanently, such as to a nursing home. A change in HUD rules made during the last Bush administration requires the spouse or significant other to pay off the entire loan, even if the balance exceeds the home's value. (See "HUD sued over reverse-mortgage rules.")
- Homeowners may pull the trigger too soon. If you tap your home equity and run through the money, you won't have that resource to draw on if you later encounter big expenses such as long-term care bills or home repairs. That's why experts recommend putting off a reverse mortgage as long as possible rather than applying for one in your 60s or early 70s and then having to be careful not to squander the cash. If the borrower is in a jam because of overspending, a reverse mortgage won't fix the problem -- it will only postpone the day he or she runs out of cash.
- Reverse mortgages are complex. They're quite different from conventional mortgages, and there are a lot of moving parts, from the various fees charged to the payout options (there are five) to the interest rates (typically variable, but fixed for the lump-sum payout option). It can be tough for borrowers to wrap their heads around all these details.
- There may be better options. Some consumer advocates are concerned that lenders eager to make these loans may railroad seniors into deals when the borrowers might be better off refinancing, downsizing, using other assets or arranging a loan from a family member. Here's what Consumers Union said in a recent report: "While the reverse mortgage market continues to grow, there are deep concerns about the suitability of the products for some borrowers, the aggressive marketing and misleading advertising of reverse mortgages to seniors, the susceptibility of vulnerable borrowers to deceptive marketing involving complicated financial products, and the inadequacy of consumer protections to prevent loan abuses that can hurt eligible borrowers."
- The default issue is something to consider as well. If the house is too expensive to maintain and insure, or if the borrower can't handle the property taxes, the loan would be considered in default and the borrower would be cut off from any remaining funds. He or she could no longer tap the line of credit or receive monthly checks.
Anyone considering a reverse mortgage should review the information on the Department of Housing and Urban Development's website, including a link to a pamphlet about the loans prepared by AARP (.pdf file).
If a reverse mortgage still looks like a good option, take the following steps:
- Shop like crazy. Just because HECM loans are federally backed doesn't mean they're all the same. They're made through private lenders, which compete with each other on fees and other costs. Get several offers before deciding.
- Get help evaluating the deal. The FHA requires borrowers to get counseling from a HUD-approved counselor before a reverse mortgage can be approved, but some -- including the Government Accountability Office (.pdf file) -- feel the counseling may be inadequate. Lenders don't have a fiduciary duty to borrowers, so anyone considering a reverse mortgage would be smart to get a second opinion from a knowledgeable, objective professional -- such as a CPA or fee-only financial planner familiar with reverse mortgages or a lawyer who specializes in elder law. (Referrals can be found from the National Association of Elder Law Attorneys.)
- Don't use the money to invest or to buy insurance. Reverse mortgages aren't a speculative play. They're meant to be used by seniors who need more money on which to live and who have few other options. An investment salesperson may make gambling with home equity sound like a smart deal, but it's not -- the only person sure to benefit is the person earning the commission on the product being sold.
- Create a budget. If the borrower is broke because of overspending, the reverse mortgage won't really fix the problem. Set up a consultation with a fee-only financial planner or a legitimate credit counselor (get referrals from the National Foundation for Credit Counseling) to create a spending plan the senior can live with.
Liz Weston is the Web's most-read personal-finance writer. She is the author of several books, most recently "The 10 Commandments of Money: Survive and Thrive in the New Economy" (find it on Bing). Weston's award-winning columns appear every Monday and Thursday, exclusively on MSN Money. Join the conversation and send in your financial questions on Liz Weston's Facebook fan page.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Reverse mortgages are a no win. You are far better off to sell your home and take the equity and reduce your standard of living. Come on Liz, old people are getting ripped off enough by ben berstanky. how much did the banking and mortgage industry pay you to write this article?
Not all reverse mortgages are scams. My mother's largest investment was her house, and she couldn't use the money any other way. My mother took a reverse mortgage out several years ago, she has used part of her money to fix the house, the roof and buy some things she needed. I went with her to sign the papers and every fee was listed clearly, every rule was explained to us at that time. She was able to borrow 2/3 of the appraised value if she wanted it. She still has about 1/3 of her available balance she can use. She is almost 84 years old and this is working perfectly for her because she wanted to stay in her home. When she dies, we family members have one year to sell the house to pay back what she borrowed, and we keep the rest. But I hope she spends and enjoys every cent that she can, I never expected an "inheritance" anyway.
In the current real estate market, she would have never been able to sell her house for what it is worth. If she dies any time soon, we probably won't be able to sell it and the bank can have it then for all I care. The main thing is she got to live where she wanted to and spend her money the way she wanted to do it.
VERY SCARY ; 2 EXAMPLES, NEPHEW(OVER65) TOOK ADVANTAGE OF TTHE REVERSE MORTGAGE, HIS WIFE NOT ELIGIBLE , BECAUSE OF AGE. SAHE SIGNED OFF , HE DIED LESS THAN A YEAR LATER, SHE OUT OF A HOME ,
DEAR FRIENDS TOOK ADVANTAGE OF THIS OFFER, , SHE DIED, , LOST HER SS INCOME , HE ILL & STRUGLING TO MAKE THE FEES , HE SOON TO BE IN NURSING HOME , BOTH THESE COUPLES WERE SEEMING TO MANAGE WITHOUT THIS MONEY THEY GOT. IT IS VERY SAD TO SEE THEM IN THIS SITUATION. i BELIEVE THEY DID NOY FULLY UNDERSTAND THE IMPLICATIONS OF THIS TYPE LOAN .
Paul Lints, the private banker, is probably writing the reverse mortgage for his dad to get all the fees for PNC. There are so many better ways for a private banker to handle this transaction, helping his father, that this almost comes under the heading of elder abuse.
What is a guy 85 years old riding with that much debt anyhow? He should have taken care of that situation years ago.
That was great information but if any of you have any doubt on how reverse mortgage works you should contact a lender! What you need to do is to locate a local mortgage professional to help with the process and get rid of your doubts. Basic and simple information on reverse mortgage is what you are looking for? Find yourself a honest lender with a nation-wide cover! I spoke to Mike through the phone, he is from reverse mortgage lenders direct and I recommend you call him - 877-700-0534 Super-friendly and very knowledgeable guy!
They say your children can pay off what you owe on the reverse mortgage after you die, but can you imagine what would be owed, if you lived ten years after taking out the reverse mortgage? Think how much you would owe, if you didn't make your house payment for ten years.
They never loan you the full amount, usually they loan you about half of the value of the home. Sometimes there are a lot of hidden fees that add up, too.
Until they could sell, they could take a loan out for enough to pay the house payments for a few years until they sell the home, plus make payments on the loan they are taking out. But there are pot holes doing that too. Sometimes they charge a lot for a loan plus demand too much collateral.
Staying where they were probably was the smartest way to go. Taking out any type of loan would probably worry the elderly a lot.
A lot of what the young call 'hand to mouth' is only the elderly being frugal. They don't have to have the latest car or travel the world. Many are happy puttering around the house and taking their afternoon nap.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
MSN REAL ESTATE
Shopping at Costco saves money, even after paying the $55 membership fee, but comes at the price of buying in bulk and limited selection.