8/16/2012 8:03 PM ET|
Should you buy a house now?
Many say this is a perfect moment to buy. But that doesn't mean it's easy. Or risk-free.
The housing market was merely confusing a year ago. Now it's downright maddening. Prices are low. In some cities they're rising. Which makes this a great time to buy. Potentially.
"Heck, yes," says Rick Borges, the president-elect of the Appraisal Institute. "You can't get any lower rates or any lower prices. The combination is unbelievable." Experts expect rates to remain low at least through 2013.
But if this is a great time to buy a home, it's not an easy time. From the trenches come tales of hope, frustration, waiting and lost opportunities.
It can be a wild ride. Rachel Wolfinbarger, 24, recently bought a home in Rancho Cucamonga, Calif., with her boyfriend. Four or five of their friends in their 20s also purchased homes in the past 12 months. She found the experience confusing but ultimately worthwhile.
"When we first started looking, I kept hearing that it was a 'buyers' market.' I thought that meant the buyer gets the upper hand. But our agent explained that, because it's a buyers' market, there are a lot of buyers," Wolfinbarger says.
While in recent years, sellers have outnumbered buyers, low interest rates and attractive prices have begun luring a growing number of potential homebuyers to test the market.
They initially looked at condos, then realized they could own a house. "We had good credit, we had a lot saved, and if you are just renting, you are never going to see that money again," she reasoned. They toured about 20 properties to get a good idea of what was available.
One home they loved seemed within their budget. But it needed costly work. When they added in the other expenses -- not just mortgage principal and interest payments but also taxes, private mortgage insurance, homeowners association dues and special assessments -- they were crushed to realize it was beyond their price range.
"That was an eye-opener," Wolfinbarger says.
The next home they liked was a "short sale." That's when the seller's lender agrees to take a loss and let the home sell for less than the seller owes. Since a bank's bureaucracy has to approve the sale price, these can be drawn-out, complex transactions.
Daren Blomquist, the vice president at RealtyTrac, a foreclosure information company, says 12% of all homes sold in the first quarter this year were in "pre-foreclosure," meaning that the foreclosure process had begun but was not complete. Most of those were short sales. An additional 14% of properties sold had been repossessed and were bank-owned.
Wolfinbarger and her boyfriend did the math on the house they liked. The price seemed right. But another buyer beat them to this bargain.
Often, homebuyers find they're competing with investors who have cash to spend, which is a big enticement to sellers. Cash sales make up about a third of transactions today, says the National Association of Realtors.
Finally, the couple hit upon a strategy that worked: shopping at a lower initial price point, so they could offer more if necessary. They found another attractive short sale, an older home in a good neighborhood with no homeowners' fees. It had been remodeled and looked new. The price was low for the area, $239,900.
But there was a huge downside: They couldn't tour the inside of the house.
It's not uncommon these days to find distressed properties for sale "subject to interior inspection," says Los Angeles real estate agent Chantay Bridges. A seller may be unable to get inside for a variety of reasons -- a hostile tenant, for example, who won't show the home and who must be evicted after the sale.
"But you have a loophole to get out of the contract if you do view it or have it inspected and decide 'this is not the one for me,'" Bridges points out.
Wolfinbarger and her boyfriend based their decision on the home's exterior appearance, square footage, legal description, location and the cost of surrounding homes. They decided to take a chance.
They offered the seller $250,000. Another buyer jumped in and matched it. They raised their offer by $5,000.
"And we got it!" Wolfinbarger says, still exultant. "Fortunately, what we saw inside was better than what we saw in the pictures."
Lots of ifs
Wolfinbarger's experience underscores how buying today can be complicated but rewarding. You may find this a good moment to buy if:
- Your job is secure. Don't get into a tight or unmanageable mortgage payment. Keep a savings cushion to fall back on in case the economy turns bad and you become unemployed.
- You qualify for a mortgage. Lenders are extremely careful; be prepared to produce lots and lots of documents and to give an excruciatingly detailed accounting of the sources of your money.
- You can stay put. You'll need to be able to stay in your new home at least five years to recoup the costs of purchasing and reselling it.
- You're prepared for competition. Many regions are seeing a shortage of desirable homes for sale, and bidding wars are cropping up.
- You've got time. With short sales particularly, and also with bank-owned properties, buyers must sometimes wait many months for the seller's mortgage lender to act. The lender might decline the offer or even raise the asking price.
- The home appraisal matches your price. Banks won't lend you more than a home is worth, so you may find yourself praying that the appraiser finds the home's value equal to the price you have agreed to pay.
The problem of value
Not all real estate markets are like Rancho Cucamonga, where bargain hunters are starting to feel pressure to act in the face of rising prices. Each city and neighborhood is recovering from the bust at its own pace.
"In most parts of the country, I think prices have bottomed out, but there are exceptions," says economist Dean Baker, co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research.
How to tell if you're paying too much for a home? Baker recommends a rule of thumb called a price-to-rent ratio: "If the price of a house is less than 15 times what a comparable place might rent for over the course of a year, then odds are, you will do OK by buying it.
"If the ratio is more than 20-to-1, then you would probably be better off renting. Between 15 and 20, I would encourage people to be cautious, but if you find a place you like and expect to live there a long time, it probably makes sense," he says.
Some experts, though, fear that today's rising prices are mini-bubbles created by local shortages of good homes for sale. If true, these rising values may not be sustainable. Bear in mind, too, that RealtyTrac estimates at least 2 million more foreclosures will come onto the market in the next few years. That should help keep prices low.
Crazy, but worth it
Despite all the ifs, Bridges urges clients to jump into the market and start looking for good deals. But she prepares them by listing the frustrations they'll encounter:
"You will find a house you like at an amazing price. But then a half-dozen other buyers pile in, making higher and higher offers until this cheap, little short-sale house is suddenly out of your price range. Or you can't get into the game at all because investors with pockets full of cash get there first and elbow the regular homebuyers out of the way.
"You've finally got your down payment, you're ready to buy, but the bank keeps you going for months, asking for one more document, one more crazy piece of proof that you really are a worthy human being."
But, she adds, "if you wait until it's perfect, you may not be able to take advantage of this disadvantaged market. There are people who have always dreamed of getting into certain neighborhoods. You can get into those places now at prices you can afford."
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Hate to be bitter here, but all these low housing prices and rates come at the expense of millions who were victims of the mortgage crisis and housing breakdown...and say all the nasty comments that you will, but there are still plenty of us who were innocent of not having bought more then we could afford, or fell for outrageous loan offers....there are the ones who have lost there jobs, or had other money-draining life circumstances occur. If these things happened in the good old days, either a new job would soon be found, or one could sell their house, and move on to more affordable housing or another area to find or accept a job. Now, with property values so decimated in thousands of areas, and millions of mortgages more or less under water, it is a choice of worse or the worst- stay and hope for a miracle, or face foreclosure and all the crap that comes with it. Most are forced into foreclosure- forget short sales, banks for the most part don't want to work with them, and deed-in-lieus are for only the most well-kept, valuble and attractive of properties.
The mortgage and banks created this devestation, and now are little to no help assisting with the cleanup. They will just continue to pound away at the unfortunate, charge them more fees, and watch their profits grow. And, as far as the lucky few who can take advantage of this "great" buyers market, it is mostly the 20-somethings, first time buyers- all because of the millions who have seen their credit and homes taken away from them. If you're older, lost your home, forget about it- you will not live to see your credit repaired enough to buy a new home, and even if you do, you will be too old to care. The tide has greatly turned, and there are many future problems that will happen because of this mess, and the ignorance and unwillingness of the government and banks to do little more then put a bandaid on the situation. Gotta love America.
real estate is an asset, like a stock or a bond or any other assets. How do we make money on assets, buy low and sell high. Because of this we all have to ask ourselves the same question before you buy a home. Do I believe the price will go up over the number of years I will live in the home (assuming you can really afford the home). This is a complicated question it means you have to estimate the economic growth in the region and the country as a whole, It means you have to estimate inflation and how the factors into any gain you might make (ie 3% inflation and 2% gain in home price is a net loss). It means you have to believe your job/income is safe. It means you have to understand the real price, including taxes, mortguage costs,repairs,insurance, and the new counter tops you'll just have to have. In the end if you believe it is a good deal and you have really done your homework pull the trigger and buy the house. Real adults know life involves risk we just try and stack the odds carefully on our side. Does this seem like to much to figure out. Then I have a suggestion, read the books used to get a real estate license it will answer some of these questions
The banking industry was given billions over 4 years ago by the former administration; and ultimately the money
was released "after the new administration was installed" as a political move to throw blame on the other guy and
let the guilty escape the anger if American home owners and potential re-financers.
The banks have been hoarding their billions in their coffers and refusing to loan anything out because they want
to remain in control of any and all cash and let the people "eat cake".
Yes, a restructuring of the bankruptcy laws needs to happen and quick to save more bankruptcies from happening.
After all, who gets the land? The banks. I say "land" because their is only so much of it and no more. It is land
with improvements. So the banks now have the land and cash and getting more of it every day and the people
are not getting anything, including cake.
America, wake up!
A house is a nice place to raise a family. Most are money pits that will make you house poor. Except in rare instances houses are not good investments. I have owned three houses. I barely made money selling the last one. I lost money on the other two. Yes I missed the housing bubble, fueled by $8 an hour Walmart employees buying $200K homes, but that is just the luck of the draw.
When I consider the opportunity cost of putting the extra that the house cost over renting in a money makret I lost a ton of money. I would be many times better off to have done nothing but rent.
Were do you all leave real estate agents and brokers that is another rip-off.
They want to make more then the house owner.
Sooo last year I borrowed againt my house in Maine and went to Florida with cash. I was able to buy a fabulous Villa and closed in just 30 days.The house history was this..6 years ago it was valued @ $175,000..I paid $39,500..I love it. 1 year later it is now $66,000. I plan on buying another one & renting it out this year before the market up swings and they are no longer as affordable. You can only make money. Remember. If you do nothing..than you get nothing...and I'll be hearing from my friends..I wish I had
Don't go knocking on other people door, the truth is that most of these people that lost their homes were high med-class making annual income of 100K and out of the blue they became unemployed
So! do NOT assume what you hear go directly to the root and get FACTS.
There is always someone that will twist words and make it sound wrong.
I say blue, you say green (BEWARE OF WHO IS WHO)
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
MSN REAL ESTATE
They are expected to take in a record $2.25 billion in fees and surcharges this year.