These suits have caused courts in some jurisdictions to require that the true owner of the mortgages do the foreclosing, not MERS. In some cases, these suits cause a delay in foreclosure proceedings -- but no one yet has gotten a house back because of a MERS issue.
Class action lawsuits have had little success
While an online search turns up plenty of class action filings, they have mostly been dismissed or are not yet resolved. Experts attribute this overall lack of big class action success in the courts thus far to the fact that the plaintiffs bring rather basic claims, such as "I made my trial payments on time, and I still have not been approved for a loan modification."
Individual cases have had more success
That said, the HAMP and foreclosure lawsuits that have been successful are exactly those kinds of claims -- brought by individual homeowners alleging bad faith by lenders in courts all across the country -- from U.S. Bank National Association v. Alejandra Padilla in New York, to the small claims case in Big Bear City, Calif., in which homeowner Dave Graham successfully sued Bank of America all by himself.
How to win a foreclosure or modification battle in court
Storm Bradford, of Mortgage Fraud Examiners, says if you are trying to get a mortgage modification or avoid foreclosure, you can make your own luck. Before going hat in hand to your lender, he advises, get a high-quality forensic evaluation of your mortgage. Irregularities in the loan-origination process are common, particularly in the appraisal. Discovering these irregularities puts you in a much better position to negotiate out of your mortgage difficulties.
"Nothing works like the lawsuit or the threat of a lawsuit" when dealing with a mortgage lender, he says. Want proof? "Check the language of a modification agreement -- they always put an indemnity clause in there that keeps you from going after them if you discover something illegal or fraudulent -- because there are things that are wrong in there, and they know it."
Beware of class-action scams
The Better Business Bureau is warning homeowners to be aware of the latest scam, designed to get you to pay upfront mortgage assistance costs of as much as $5,000. This foreclosure and modification "help" is masking itself as the nationwide mass joinder lawsuit against mortgage companies.
Homeowners receive letters promising a loan modification, foreclosure stoppage, cash settlement, lien stripping, or even free and clear title. Do not fall for this -- it is merely a way for firms to get around the laws prohibiting the collection of upfront fees for mortgage modification help.
Talk to a lawyer
"I regularly meet clients who have been repeatedly denied mortgage modification requests and are faced with foreclosure lawsuits initiated against them by their mortgage companies," says New Jersey attorney David Giller. "Most of these homeowners don't realize that a qualified attorney can help them in many ways."
Have you considered bankruptcy?
One final available weapon is a bankruptcy filing. "Although most homeowners are afraid of filing for bankruptcy, there are many solutions available through the bankruptcy laws which are not available in foreclosure defense," Giller says. "These solutions help get the clients the mortgage modification they desperately sought from their mortgage company in a far more efficient manner."
This article was reported by Gina Pogol for HSH.com.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Always record conversations with bankers. Always take 5 days to read the contract. Always have the bank pay to have your attorney review there documents. Always have a clause added that will result in fines, legal action, and the bank to liable for these expense in the event of any improper action on part of the bank (default of contract). They do with you.
MY girl friend was 4 payments ahead. Made good money and was frugal with it too. Her mortgage company DIDN'T pay her taxes and insurance from her escrow account, the county put a lein against her home and that's when she found out when she got the letter from the tax collector. It took her 4 months to get it paid, by her lender, and now they say she is $900 behind on her escrow account again....she's not behind and has never been behind. By the way the county sent it in to the credit reporting companies and now her stupid credit scores are in the tank.....Does anyone know of a really good Contract Lawyers? If she don't have a case no one does!!!!!!
My reporting is hardly sloppy. It's a fact that the BBB has issued warnings against mass joinder filings. As has the Federal Trade Commission just last month, but I guess you, jrohner51, don't consider these agencies as reputable as a pack of hard-selling lawyers advertising on TV and hiring call centers to sign more folks up.
The FTC characterizes this activity as a fraud, period, and claims that the firms promise relief, but generally don't deliver, often leaving their clients in worse financial shape than before.
jrohner51, I think you're lawyer, with an axe to grind, and you'd rather run down my professional work than engage in something honorable yourself.
I purchased a home in 1993. The day after closure, the insurance company would not insure it because of a warped piece of plywood on the roof. It took me many months of diligent work, but eventually my mortgage company put a new roof on my house. It was well worth the effort. I'm retired now but my career taught me to document, document, document. If not documented, it didn't happen. That means, the date, time, person you spoke to and a brief summary of the conversation every time. A great thanks goes out to all of my bosses who took the time to teach me what I needed to know. I was a fast learner, went to work on time and was not a social butterfly. Those things got me promoted very quickly. I will never forget what I learned. I was in a position where things weren't so black and white. My decisions had to be made with a possible jury finding in my favor. I did win a few cases for my company and myself too. Law suits are not always the answer but I would like to know why we can no longer sue for product liability, at least in Texas?
What does it take to make companies accountable? The Deceptive and Unfair Trades Act is being ignored to it's fullest these days. I have my own issue on that but can't get any one to listen.
Those of you who don't keep receipts for purchases before the manufacture's warranty runs out, shame on you.
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
MSN REAL ESTATE
Even those who don't like to shop are probably hitting the stores this month. Here's what to be on the lookout for and here's what to avoid.