3/6/2013 5:45 PM ET|
America's austerity madness
With the budget sequester and recent tax hikes kicking in, Americans are starting to feel a pinch that will only get worse. But sadly, what's been done so far won't fix the country's finances.
It just got real.
After years of political posturing, false alarms, kicked cans and a general postponement of responsibility, Washington has finally begun the task of closing our out-of-control budget deficit.
With higher payroll taxes, higher investment taxes, higher income taxes, Obamacare surcharges, and now the furloughs and docked aircraft carriers of the budget sequester, Americans are beginning to feel the sting. (The stock market, for now, seems oblivious to what's coming.)
It will hurt. It will hurt because the economy still stinks for most people, with stagnant wages, higher costs of living and the percentage of the population actually working down to early 1980s levels. And it will keep hurting because, despite the budget progress that's been made, much more must be done to put the Treasury on a sustainable fiscal footing.
Given the current state of our political leadership, this nightmare is set to get worse before it gets better. Here's why, along with a few thoughts on how we can awaken from this bad dream and what investors should do in the meantime.
Just getting started
As I discussed in last week's column ("Why there's no way Obama can win"), we're only about halfway toward stabilizing the government's finances over the near term, given the 2011 debt-ceiling deal, the fiscal cliff deal with its tax hikes, and now the spending cuts of the sequester. According to the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, we need at least $2.4 trillion or so in deficit reduction over the next 10 years to keep debt levels stable.
What's more, this assumes there are no recessions, natural disasters, wars or other drains on the Treasury's finances during that time. If there are, we'll need to tighten more to stay on track.
Already, the tax hikes and spending cuts that have been done are set to chop at least 1.5% off of growth of gross domestic product this year. It could turn out to be more than 2%, since research from the International Monetary Fund shows that, in situations like the one we're in now, deficit tightening hits growth harder than normal. The total drag could easily top 3% if the upcoming fights over a new budget and the debt ceiling result in fresh taxes and new cuts, as expected.
With the U.S. economy essentially flat-lining, and with Japan and much of Europe falling into a new recession, it wouldn't take much of a shove to start a self-perpetuating downturn. (Again, the stock market is marching to its own beat right now due to stimulus from central banks. But, as I discussed in "Gas below $4 or Dow 14,000?", the risks of this strategy are rising while the benefits to consumers are diminishing. And a new recession clearly isn't priced into the market yet.)
If our fiscal chase feels a bit like a dog trying to catch its tail, well, that's because it is.
Following Europe into austerity
You can see this downward spiral playing out in real time across the Atlantic. Europe started its austerity efforts in 2010 after the Greek debt crisis focused everyone's attention on the unsustainable borrowing of many developed-economy governments. The results are plain to see: Government deficits show a modest decline, yes, but at a cost of persistent joblessness, ongoing economic stalling, restless populations, political turmoil and backsliding on austerity commitments.
In other words, austerity has been a failure. The more deeply you cut, the worse your economy gets, which lowers tax revenue, increases benefit spending and widens your deficit whilst irritating constituents. It's a toxic downward spiral.
Fringe, anti-austerity parties are resurgent in Athens and Rome. Hundreds of thousands of protesters have taken to the streets in Portugal, with banners proclaiming "Austerity Kills," demanding the resignation of the current conservative government and an end to the tax hikes and benefit cuts. And Spain and France are asking eurozone leadership for more time to meet the 3% deficit-to-GDP targets Germany has pushed so hard for.
Admittedly, I find European politics as exciting as the average American does. Which is to say, not very.
But just a cursory peek at what's happening there presages where the United States is headed. It's not pretty. And it risks a repeat of the mistakes of the 1937 double-dip recession -- sparked by the misguided belief of President Franklin D. Roosevelt and his conservative Treasury secretary, Henry Morgenthau, that austerity was required to boost the economy. The result was an extension of the Great Depression that didn't end until America's factories ramped up to support the fight against the Empire of Japan and Nazi Germany.
In 1937 and 1938, the budget deficit was closed by a total of 5.4% of GDP. Outside of the drawdown after World War II, a tightening of this scale hasn't happened. Until now: Over the next two years, based on President Barack Obama's 2013 budget proposal, we're on track for a tightening of 4.6%, mainly via tax hikes.
Yet doing nothing, or not doing enough to stabilize the debt load, risks a Japanese-style decline into extreme indebtedness. And that, according the academics, carries risks of a period of stagnant growth, a fragile susceptibility to financial crises and a dangerous temptation to simply monetize the debt via dollar debasement by the Federal Reserve.
Currently, Washington's debt load totals $16.7 trillion, which is now nearly $1 trillion more than the economy's total output in one year. The debt-to-GDP ratio works out to about 105%. In Japan, where debt has been accumulated with aplomb, the debt-to-GDP ratio is expected to hit 230% next year -- creating a reality where economists don't know how the Land of the Rising Sun can reverse its long decline.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
After looking at the figures it appears 345 federal workers could avoid furloughs with every cancelled weekend presidential golf outing. This means tours of the capitol could resume and many more planned cuts could be avoided if the elitist would cut his personal extravagant lifestyle. Maybe we could feel less of an impact if the many Whitehouse staffers that dress the first lady were laid off and she could dress herself. I'm sure she could manage to find something she could wear. And the kids can watch TV so the Whitehouse personal movie theater staffed around the clock with fresh popcorn would also be subject to sequestration. It only seems fair to me and lots of other tax payers that the royal family should feel the impact. After all, it was his idea!!
Anthony! There no spending "cuts." These are reductions in the percentage of growth. The government is still growing and spending more each year. I have to balance my check book or either go to jail for file bankruptcy. Why is the federal government better than my family? A "CUT" to the federal budget wouldn't affect me negatively at all. I get nothing from the crooks.
New Highs, New Highs, do you see any connect between the global economic status of 2007 when the last high was established and the global economic status of today?
This is going to be such a mess from this insanity.
How can we put the private sector to work, unless we put big tax and spend, and big mandates government (think small business killing Obamacare) out of a job?
What you think is a easy fix will likely make the problem worse. Corporate taxes are pushing all time lows yet where are the jobs. The more crude we tap into, the more they export it elsewhere. Another fact people don't seem to get, government spending is why the economy expands. We have being doing it for decades. Any system will run it's course and ours is far from perfect.
It's so easy to run around like a chicken with your head cut off screaming this or that. Fact of the matter is corporate profits are at all times high during most of Obama's term. Corporate taxes as a percent of GDP are at all time lows. No wonder seeing how both Facebook(2012) and GE(2010) made huge profits yet paid ZERO in taxes.
Regular people are the ones who are going to pay for this circus .The government does not care.They just want to act like grade school kids.The blame game is not going to fix anything.Why are these people running this country into the ground.I heard a commercial on the radio yesterday that puts this into perspective.Some wall street idiot was telling people to put their money in the stock market because BEN was throwing all that printed money at the problem and it was the only game in town.Tony you keep writing your articles of truth and maybe someone in the white house will take notice and look themselves in the mirror.I have been around small business my whole life.I would like to sit down with the president,congress and friends and show them what a balance sheet can do.If i spend more money than i make i will go bankrupt but i can not raise taxes or get someone to fire up the printing press.
Austerity should start with Policymaker in both house and senete.There job and benefits shouldn't
be lifetime. There all benefits and retiremens are entitlement.They should be handled first before
touching medicare,mediaid and social security.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
[BRIEFING.COM] The stock market finished a down week on a cautious note with small caps leading the retreat. The Russell 2000 lost 0.5%, widening its weekly decline to 2.6%, while the S&P 500 shed 0.3%. The benchmark index ended the week lower by 2.7%.
This morning, the market was provided a basis to rebound with the July employment report, which was just right for the policy doves (209K versus Briefing.com consensus 220K). It showed payroll growth that was weaker than expected, ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'