5/22/2013 6:15 PM ET|
Beware: Market insiders are selling
Even as new highs draw mom-and-pop investors back into the market, it looks like the so-called smart money is getting out. Here’s what they see coming.
On the face of it, things couldn't be better in the stock market. And the average American is feeling pretty good about that. It's easier to judge the economy by where the Dow Jones Industrial Average closes than by looking deep into boring economic data.
But to Wall Street's inside operators, the hedge funds and proprietary traders that always seem one step ahead of the masses, things don't look so right. In fact, according to a mix of indicators from mutual fund flows to options activity and futures positioning, insiders are starting to sneak away just as Main Street investors are jumping in.
You can see where this is headed. Emotions run high, greed clouds judgment and the market gets more and more overextended. When this party ends, everyday investors will be left holding the bag.
The professionals have been spooked by something, which is why they're running for the hills. They have good reasons to run. Here's what they see coming, and how I'm investing for that reality.
Running for the exits
Now, I've been skeptical of this rally for months for many reasons. Breadth wasn't there, as many stocks were left out. Leadership wasn't there, as dividend-focused utilities, health-care and consumer staples stocks led the way. The fundamentals weren't there, either, in company numbers or the economy.
But none of that has mattered, because the market will do what it does. If people want to own stocks badly enough, the market could double in the midst of a depression. This rally all comes down to emotion, fueled by cheap money from central banks, and that can keep it running for quite a while. I didn't appreciate that reality enough.
But I'm ready to call this what it is: a market bubble, where euphoria pushes out reason, the hard data are ignored, and the so-called "dumb money" buys from the "smart money" folks at the market top.
Take a look at the chart below, which tracks this phenomenon and which I'll explain. And yes, "dumb money" may be offensive, but it sums up what Wall Street thinks of a lot of its customers.
SentimenTrader's Smart Money/Dumb Money Confidence Index tracks what the insiders are doing versus what average investors are doing. The "smart money" measure includes things such as option put/call ratios, commercial hedge positions in the futures market and the relationship between stocks and bonds -- all keys to figuring out the Wall Street pros' moves. The "dumb money" measure includes things such as fund flows into Rydex mutual funds and activity by small speculators in equity index futures -- indicative of moves by more average investors in 401ks and retirement accounts.
Combine the two and you get the telling indicator shown in the chart above. When the number falls, average investors are acting with far more confidence than the pros on Wall Street. They are buying while those on the inside are selling.
The "smart money" measure has dropped to levels not seen since market tops last September and last April. The "dumb money" confidence measure has soared to levels that were also last seen during that time. What followed those months were multi-month market corrections. Likewise, peaks in the chart -- such as early 2009, mid-2011 and mid-2012 -- were associated with great buying opportunities in the market ahead of long, low-risk uptrends.
In fact, the chart above shows how the combined measure has been a solid indicator of future market performance since the 2009 bear market low.
What's happening now is that Wall Street insiders are bailing out. It remains to be seen if they are moving ahead of a small, 5% correction or something much worse, but they see something bad coming.
Now, this measure could clearly continue to drop deeper into extreme territory while stock prices keep pushing higher. The timing on this is far from clear. But what's changed is that the bubbly nature of this market is being laid bare as prices increasingly disconnect from reality.
Stock gains just aren't enough
I can't say this surprises me. The "wealth effect" of higher stock prices -- the belief that higher portfolio values would boost stagnant consumer spending and revive stalled economic growth -- was always a fantasy of the market bulls.
In other words, the experts in Washington and on Wall Street have believed higher stock prices would create their own fundamentals, lifting the economy with them. They haven't. Corporate profitability is declining as the ratio of negative versus positive Q2 earnings preannouncements increases to levels not seen since 2001. Corporate executives are trying to lower expectations. And various economic indicators are increasingly missing expectations, as illustrated by the chart of the Citigroup Economic Surprise Index below. (The index falls when economic indicators miss expectations, and rise when the numbers are better than expected.)
Why hasn't this strategy worked?
The experts have ignored the fact that fewer and fewer Americans are even participating in the market, despite the 150% bounce in the S&P 500 off of its bear market low. A recent Gallup poll finds that U.S. stock ownership remains at records lows, with just 52% of adults in the market versus 65% at the 2007 high.
They've also ignored this undeniable truth: In inflation-adjusted terms, the stock market is still below its 2007 peak, which in turn was below the 2000 peak. In that perspective, recent gains in real terms don't mean much.
This strategy also only widens the gap between the rich and the poor -- the root cause of the credit bonanza and mortgage-equity withdrawals that fueled the housing bubble -- since the ultra-wealthy own the vast majority of financial assets. According to G. William Domhoff at the University of California at Santa Cruz (read his report here), the bottom 80% of Americans own just 4.7% of all financial wealth; the top 1% control 42%.
Those experts also ignore that, as pointed out by Morgan Stanley's Gregory Peters, the wealth effect only works when it lowers household savings by raising spending. But with the savings rate at just 2.7% as the household debt-to-disposable-income ratio is still north of 120%, people haven't yet rebuilt their balance sheets after the mid-2000s housing bubble/credit explosion. They aren't in a position to spend.
And that the positive economic tailwind from higher stock prices and housing prices has diminished since the 2007-2009 wipeout. Sensitivity to housing wealth -- or how likely it is that an increase in housing wealth will encourage new consumer spending -- has fallen roughly 35%, while sensitivity to stock market wealth, which is much smaller anyway, has fallen 27%.
Not only has this drive to raise stock prices not fixed the overall economy, it's sowing the seeds of the next crisis.
It's happening because Washington wants it, with record highs in the stock market being one of President Barack Obama's only true, unarguable economic accomplishments. (He acknowledged recently that the job market is still "challenging" while housing remains well below peak valuations.) And of course, Wall Street wants it because it means trading revenue, bigger bonuses and increased market liquidity. It's easier to trade in and out of big positions, or milk pennies with predatory computer-trading algorithms, when Main Street investors are throwing in, too.
Thus, dovish leaders are elevated at the Federal Reserve -- with dovish Fed Vice Chairwoman Janet Yellen likely to replace Ben Bernanke next year -- as the central bank pumps trillions into the banking system and effectively finances the federal deficit while Wall Street piles its idle cash into U.S. Treasury bonds instead of investing to grow.
And all the while, regulators and politicians turn a blind eye to the unresolved "too big to fail" problem as the major banks just keep growing, like a cancer. Just look at the total assets at Bank of America (BAC); they've swelled from $1.5 trillion in 2007 to $2.1 trillion now. Wells Fargo (WFC) assets have gone from $550 billion to $1.4 trillion.
No one wants to shake the boat. Wall Street is actively fighting any effort in Congress to rein in the big banks, and the rising market is giving lawmakers an excuse for inaction.
The bankers know the bigger they get during the bull market, the safer they'll be in the next downturn since taxpayers will have no choice but to support them. No need to worry about the sting of failure and bankruptcy.
And according to comments from Attorney General Eric Holder back in March -- comments he's since tried to walk back -- the CEOs leading these monstrosities have become too big to jail for fear of damaging sentiment and shaking markets. Both would be bad for politics heading into the 2014 midterm elections.
It won't work in the end, but. . .
Despite the hard reality of all this, herd mentality and a lack of attractive alternatives has everyday investors piling into stocks at a dangerous time. And, as I've said, this could keep pushing the market up for a while.
You don't want to be left out if the market insists on going up. But as I told investors at the Las Vegas Money Show last week, this is no time for buy-and-hold complacency, because change is coming.
So here's what I'm doing.
With the market going into full bubble mode over the past few weeks, I've tightened my focus to short-term breakout stocks like AMD (AMD), LDK Solar (LDK), Mechel (MTL), James River Coal (JRCC) and Nokia (NOK) to participate to the upside in a way that controls risk. Get in, hold for a week or two, and then get out.
Coal stocks, which I wrote about a few weeks ago, continue to break out, with the Market Vectors Coal ETF (KOL), Talisman Energy (TLM) and Peabody Energy (BTU) all looking good. I've highlighted this in the Peabody chart below. And I've added all three to my Edge Letter Sample Portfolio this week; you can view it here.
Short opportunities are also popping up, a consequence of the selling pressure beginning to enter back into the picture. Just look at the way Fed-dependent stocks like mortgage REITs Annaly Capital (NLY), Anworth Asset Management (ANH) and Armour Residential (ARR) are rolling over. Someone obviously believes the Fed will pull back from its purchases of mortgage-backed securities, that mortgage rates are about to increase or that the housing market is about to weaken. All three would be negatives. I've added NLY and ANH short to my holdings as well.
No matter how you come down on the bull versus bear debate, just keep in mind the genesis of what we're witnessing, the changes that are happening under the surface, and manage the risk in your portfolio accordingly. Don't be complacent. And don't believe for a minute that this is a rally built on true fundamentals.
It is, like the housing bubble, supported by easy-money Fed policy, lax regulatory oversight, raw excitement and the implicit backing of the powerful in Washington and on Wall Street. And as its true nature is revealed, insiders are growing increasingly nervous.
At the time of publication, Anthony Mirhaydari did not hold positions in any equity mentioned in this column. He has recommended NLY and ANH short and KOL, TLM and BTU long to his clients.
Be sure to check out Anthony's new money management service, Mirhaydari Capital Management, and his investment newsletter, the Edge. A free, two-week trial subscription to the newsletter has been extended to MSN Money readers. Click here to sign up. Mirhaydari can be contacted at firstname.lastname@example.org and followed on Twitter at @EdgeLetter. You can view his current stock picks here. Feel free to comment below.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Who in the hell has extra money to invest in the stock market. 49 million americans on food stamps, millions at minimum wage and millions more barely above minimum wage.
our corporations outsourced this nations industry. They did so to maximize profits. This worked as corporations have never had as much cash on hand as they do now. The problem is the people that they laid off can no longer afford their products. Their new employees in third world countries cant afford them either.sales decline.profits evaporate,stock market takes a nose dive. There are consequences to free trade.the only thing that has kept us from feeling the full effect is central bankers have kept pumping more fresh money in to replace that which has been horded by the rich and sent to third world countries. Did you really think we could trade our paper dollars for their manufactured things indefinately.Eventually they're going to want something substantial in return
There are simply too many wheeler-dealer types on Wall Street that are manipulating the markets for their own selfish gain. These parasites add no true value to any company or business other that the moving of money back and forth while they enrich themselves in the process. The more they buy and sell the richer they get. And this guy Anthony is just one more of them.
Too many parasites, not enough high quality management.
The dow dropped 80 points today... If "all" the inside traders were selling, I'm pretty sure it would have dropped like 500 or more. So, tommorrow morning when I wake up, and the dow maybe goes down another 50-100, I'll be confident in knowing this guy is making crap up.
"The professionals have been spooked by something"... ??? lol that is the most vague non-factual statement I have heard in a while, and he based his entire article on it. hmmmm
How did I know this article was going to written by Tony fulla-baloney just by reading the title?
MSN: He makes you look bad. Fire him.
When I see sales and earnings whiff convincingly for 2 quarters, than I'll worry. Corporate America has pressures, including a work force that is tired of being overworked & underpaid, having few employment alternatives during the recession for leverage. I have a feeling if the recovery stalls out, which means more of the same - meager or no raises and not much hiring...well, there's gonna be some very grumpy voters come next election....
It's going to be a down day today. 'Uncle Ben' is starting to put out those comments of easing the stimulus & guess what ? The markets DO LISTEN. We've have said this all year long that when the unemloyment rate starts to get close to that 6.5%, you'll see the Fed to start suggesting to make changes in their bond buying. We told you that when investors get even a 'wiff' of this they'll start to sell. Yesterday was just the start & today we have a few well placed shorts to take in the profits.
(A-sharp wants a bigger boat)
So get ready, 'wax up those boards', SURFS UP!!!
Anthony, I agree with you. Just do not forget that the market can be wrong for a long time, far longer than you can afford to be right. That said, keep up the good work. This is a fat pig of a market, ripe for a pullback. No one should be plunking down their life savings to make a killing right now. That time was 2008, after complete market capitulation, not now.
Key is not to get greedy when everyone else does, taking some money off the table for your winners. It is not really your money until you sell...
And let's not forget dollar cost averaging. In the end, I will side w/ user903960. :-) At least my money is where my mouth is. Hooray for DCA!
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
[BRIEFING.COM] The stock market ended the holiday-shortened week on a mixed note as the Dow Jones Industrial Average shed 0.1%, while the S&P 500 added 0.1% with seven sectors posting gains.
Equity indices faced an uphill climb from the opening bell after disappointing quarterly results from Google (GOOG 536.10, -20.44) and IBM (IBM 190.04, -6.36) weighed on the early sentiment. Google reported earnings $0.15 below the Capital IQ consensus estimate on revenue of $15.42 ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'