9/6/2012 6:37 PM ET|
Central bankers can't save us now
Our best chance for economic gains and a market rally is for the Fed and its European counterpart to keep us hoping they do something -- instead of proving they can't do much.
Keep the promise alive. Give me decisive non-action.
That's my hope for central bank decisions in September.
Frankly, it's an attitude founded not so much on optimism that the global financial and economic crisis is about to fix itself as on a cynical calculation that the world's leaders won't do much before the end of the year. And I think the best strategy for getting to that point in the year without the current crisis getting significantly worse is lots of central bank promises coupled with very little action.
That way the Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank keep the hope of powerful central bank intervention alive -- which bolsters the prices of financial assets and optimism about the economy.
So far, so good; for all the attention the market gave the ECB's announcement Thursday, it was only a promise with contingencies. There was no action.
And all promises with no actions doesn't reveal the depressing truth: that central banks have used their powder, emptied their toolbox, burned all their fuel -- and the likelihood that anything they can do will significantly add to economic growth is just about nil.
The bad alternatives
I can think of two possible outcomes if the Federal Reserve and the ECB summon up the last ounces of policy mojo that they have -- and neither is good.
First, at a minimum and in the short term, if the central banks act instead of just promising to act, all those shorts and bears who had moved out of the financial markets in August to avoid getting crushed if the Fed and the ECB did move would now be free to go negative again. That includes not only traders who might short equities but also bears who might want to bet against the bonds of Spain and Italy.
And that freedom to go negative could produce a repeat of the worst of the Spanish and Italian bond crises in relatively short order.
Second, more serious and in the slightly longer term, if the central banks act and demonstrate that they can't fix the European debt crisis or the global economic slowdown with a wave of their balance sheets, then we've taken away an important psychological support for the belief that the crisis and associated slowdown are going to get better soon.
After all, if the Fed does implement a new program of bond buying under the rubric of QE3 and it doesn't work (say, for example, unemployment stays stuck at July's 8.3%), then how do we get out of this slough of slow growth in the United States? If the ECB does start a program of unlimited buying of three-year and shorter Spanish and Italian bonds, and the effort doesn't reduce interest rates enough to get those economies moving again, then tell me why a 35-year-old unemployed Italian or Spaniard should think things will get better soon?
It would be up to global political leaders to act -- and I don't see a window for that until near the end of the year.
Keeping hope alive
Better the illusion of hope than no hope at all? You bet. The hope that the central banks could yet throw out a rescue line would buy governments and the global economy time to eliminate debt, time to regain confidence and time to put policies in place that might actually address issues such as productivity and unemployment. (I'll explain how this might work at the end of this column.)
But first, let's look at the odds for constructive non-action.
So far, the odds are high.
On Aug. 31, at the Kansas City Federal Reserve's Jackson Hole conference, Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke laid out what the Fed could do and the circumstances under which the Fed might act -- but did nothing.
On Wednesday, the day before the meeting of the ECB's board of governors, details of the bank's plan leaked to Bloomberg News. That was in itself brilliant (and I suspect deliberate), because it created the impression that the bank was preparing to act. ECB chief Mario Draghi's news conference after the meeting furthered that impression. He laid out such a clear and reassuring plan for action -- the bank would buy relatively short-term Spanish and Italian debt, it would renounce any claims to seniority for its own bond holdings, and it would take on new regulatory powers -- that no one called out that this plan was nothing but a more detailed version of promises made earlier this summer.
The plan didn't just avoid mentioning concrete actions to put those promises into motion. It also included an absolute barrier to action.
- Yes, the central bank would buy unlimited quantities of Spanish and Italian government bonds, but only after the governments of those countries formally asked for such a rescue. Those governments haven't done that, and have instead made statements ranging from "we see no need to do that" to "we see no need for that at this moment." Both Mariano Rajoy's government in Spain and Mario Monti's government in Italy suspect, rightly I think, that asking for a bond rescue with conditions that smell even faintly of the conditions imposed on Greece would be political suicide.
- Yes, the central bank would buy unlimited quantities of those bonds after the European Financial Stability Facility and the European Stability Mechanism had acted. But the first is supposed to be going out of business, and the second isn't yet in place. In fact, the European Stability Mechanism is in limbo until the German constitutional court rules on Sept. 12 on the constitutionality of the fund. Until then, the Bundestag can't even vote to approve the European Stability Mechanism, and, without the Germans, this fund is going nowhere.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Hopefully Americans will now end their four year vacation from reality and get their heads back into economic reality. Everyone needs to work to survive. Been this way forever and always will. I know politicans like to play this game of convincing folks they can live off anothers sweat the way they do but this unfortunately has come to an end. After seeing the paths these two parties have chosen I conclude neither will offer much relief for the working folks. So lets just all get back to work; discontinue the bashing of business folks, and get back into successful work teams. Lets all praise success in business not demean it. Lets have food on the table as our basic goal as citizens. Remember the chicken in every pot? We have been here before. Our main issue at this time is the corruption in our political system not willing able workers. Yes I know the rich gave the politicans money to change the rules to benefit them. But the politicians not only took it; both sides, but are organized in recruiting it as well. So whomever is President don't expect much to change from that arena. The real culprit called corruption exists in the congress and that is where we need to get to work.
The Fed prints money and the dollar weakens,Europe prints money and the Euro gains WTF. The
only cure is a good round of deflation.More QE means $5-6 gas,$6 loaf of bread,less jobs and
higher stock prices. Supply and demand is no longer a factor in determining prices, only the
Feds destruction of the dollar raises the cost of everything except labor. This will not end well.
Hunger will be the catalyst for the revoloution and its long overdue.
Bill Taren, a retiree near Orlando, Fla., discovered in August that his credit union would pay only 0.4 percent annual interest on his saving account, even though inflation averaged 2.8 percent over the last year. So he and his wife decided to just stuff their money in the mattress, he says, because at least there “we can see the cash when we want.” The FED in causing all intuitions' to pay virtually nothing on saving of all types is just going to make people have less to spend therefore spend less and hurt the economy. Interest rates near zero the cause of many of our problems and a fix for nothing.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
[BRIEFING.COM] The stock market ended the Thursday session on a modestly lower note, but a late-morning rebound lifted the indices off their lows. The S&P 500 shed 0.2% with seven sectors ending in the red.
This morning, European equities and U.S. futures slumped around 6:00 ET after Ukraine's President Petro Poroshenko was quoted as saying Russian forces have invaded an area southeast of Donetsk. The news pressured the markets, but a brief uptick took place after a correction to ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'