10/3/2012 5:12 PM ET|
Did the economy kill saving?
Americans have started putting away a tad more money, but we're not doing nearly enough to build wealth and fund retirement.
Americans have never had much love for fiscal puritanism. We're a nation of risk takers and consumers. We want it all. We want to hit it big. We don't want to sacrifice the pleasures of today by saving for tomorrow.
Yes, I know the economy stinks, and saving isn't easy. Wages have stalled. The unemployment rate is still above 8%. Home prices are off. Stocks have recovered from the recession, but they have merely returned to highs reached years ago. Saving can also seem pointless when returns -- from investments, savings accounts or whatever -- are low. A lack of disposable income makes it even harder.
But the truth is, even in good times, we didn't save. In the 1970s, when the economy's debt-driven growth, high inflation, favorable demographics and steady increase in asset prices meant it wasn't so hard, we didn't save. We consumed.
From 1976, when the oldest baby boomers were hitting their 30s, through the peak in 2007, household net worth grew from $5 trillion to $67 trillion -- mainly because of the rise in home prices. Accounting for inflation, the rise was around $24 trillion in 2012 dollars.
Yet starting that same year, the savings rate fell from around 10% to a low of 1% in early 2005. And household debt rose from 70% of disposable income to a peak of 134% in 2007. Not only were people not saving, they were borrowing against their new wealth to spend even more.
Now, despite an epic housing bubble, retirement portfolios constrained by the fact the Standard & Poor's 500 Index ($INX) is at levels first reached in 1999, and household net worth below its pre-recession peak at $63 trillion, the savings rate has increased to 3.7%. This is an improvement, but it's far from enough. And we've only started to work down our debt, which has fallen to 113% of disposable income, thanks mainly to mortgage defaults. (Because of falling home prices, debt as a percentage of assets has actually increased.)
Moreover, people who are saving are taking fewer risks, selling stocks and piling into bonds and other fixed-income investments, lowering their potential returns in an environment of ultralow interest rates from the Federal Reserve.
The truth is that for most Americans, saving is dead. People are simply not putting away enough to fund a comfortable retirement, rebuild balance sheets damaged by the housing bust or benefit from the Fed's stated goal of boosting the prices of stocks and housing. And they're not taking enough risks with the money they do save to earn decent returns.
Straightening this out isn't easy, but I'll outline the way to do it below. And it has to be done, unless your retirement strategy involves freeloading off your kids, who'll have problems -- like massive student loan debts -- of their own.
Why saving seems so hard
Why does saving seem like an outdated concept?
Well, part of the reason is that Americans don't like to lower their standard of living unless they absolutely have to. Thus, while wages and some assets have bounced back (to a degree) from the recession, the added capital is going into things like the surge in auto sales or smartphones instead of building -- or rebuilding -- wealth.
That leads Morgan Stanley analysts to believe that Americans aren't saving more simply because they don't feel they can, given budget constraints.
Saving is a also a lower priority here than in places like Germany or even China. It's a cultural thing, too.
And Americans are protecting what money they have saved out of fear of recent market volatility, which explains the shift into "safe" assets like bonds.
What Americans have
Let's take a look at where things stand for the average American.
Because the country's wealth and income are concentrated at the top, economywide measures of income and net worth are somewhat misleading. The Fed's 2010 Survey of Consumer Finances, the latest available, gives us a clearer picture. It suggests that even middle-class, well-educated families are under strain:
- Median family income is down 7.7% since 2007 and stands at $45,800. For families whose primary earner has a college degree, it's down nearly 10% (but down only 1% for those whose primary earner lacks a high school diploma).
- Median net worth is down nearly 40%, from $126,400 to just $77,300 -- returning to levels last seen in the early 1990s. For those with a college degree, median net worth fell 34.6% to $195,200.
- The percentage of families that saved fell to 52% from 56.4% in 2007. Compare that percentage to the 62% of families with a college degree. Back in 2001, nearly 60% of all families saved.
While the wealthiest among us are enjoying a rebound, thanks to a resurgent stock market, the wealth of middle-class families depends much more on home prices. While the Dow Jones Industrial Average ($INDU) has been pushing to new post-recession highs, home prices are just now starting to get up off the mat.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
I dont know who or what killed savings but Im on an extended pay freeze. My common charges are going up, gas went up, utilities went up, groceries are up (thank god I have no kids). I definitlely am hurting a bit. Not too much but feeling the pinch. I am considering cutting cable, but for the winter months it wont do...i hate being out in the cold and cable keeps me company. My cell phone I could do without. I need electric (heat) and gas (to cook). I dont shop. I dont drive everywhere so I make gas last....my student loan payments arent going away anytime soon. Not much else to cut back on.
Considering renting my place out next year or selling it and paying off student loans. I hate being a slave to bills...either way I'll need a place to stay..LOL!
We can blame economy, but to me this is due to one person, who has been responsible for Savings Rate and economic growth from Sunny Greece to Good Old USA. He is a student of Depression and believe me, as long as he has a say " we will be in depression". We definately need low rates to spurt some growth in economies worldwide, but it is consumer who make it raging river of GROWTH. To me Zero Rate bring Zero returns..Mr. Bernanke before you get fired, will you please read up on Growth economic book and spare us of DEPRESSION.
so the advisor is reccomending equities and trading which of course the retail investor has
no chance of doing successfully because he or she is up against a computerized trading market
which is a losing situation but still the advisor has his money in cash while telling us that cash
in the bank is not the place to be...
Save what? Nothing is left over. After year and years of Greenspan Economics (Started with Clinton, kept going with Bush and still going) with credit given out to anyone who asked whether they could afford to or not, you have to start paying for it. It took 20 years to get here it will take a long time to recover.
But why are banks getting money for nothing then loaning it out if they do for 6%. That is an easy 6% profit. Why do we get only 0.5% if we try to save? 2-4% profit margin is the historical level. Saving money does not even keep up with inflation. You are losing money saving it. It is time to get someone in the Fed Reserve that knows what they are doing. Someone that know what it takes to earn a living not an idiot sucking on silver spoons.
BO,MO, and Jo need to go. Theyve flipped up everything theyve touched.Youve not done your job, so we MUST let you go.
Let's not forget that.
I get a kick out of the mixed messages we get from government:
spend, it's a consumer-driven economy, do your part.
Save, you're not being responsible if you don't save money.
Ok, I'll be happy to do both when and if I ever get enough to be able to do both. But it won't be happening with the costs of everything going up like they are while income is steadily going down.
Yes the economy killed savings. So did the Federal Reserve, and a lame presidential administration.
But debt is doin alright!
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
[BRIEFING.COM] The headlines generally favored Tuesday being another good day for the stock market. Instead, it was just a mixed day with modest point changes on either side of the unchanged mark for the major indices.
For the most part, the stock market was a sideshow. The main trading events were seen in the commodity and Treasury markets, both of which saw some decent-sized losses within their respective complex.
Dollar strength was at the heart of the weakness in ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'