12/16/2011 8:38 PM ET|
D's for Obama (and Congress, too)
TheStreet asked economists, money pros and consumer advocates to grade the economic players' performance in 2011. A bunch of rabble-rousers scored best, but that's not saying much.
You may think the Occupy movement failed. In fact, it gets the highest marks from a range of experts comparing its performance this year with others of the nation's top economic players: President Barack Obama, the GOP candidates raring to face him in a general election, Congress and the Tea Party.
Of course, that may not be saying much. Suffice to say, if this were school, the other players might have to repeat 2011.
America understands letter grades; most of its citizens have gone through a dozen or more years of being ranked on their work from A to F. So that's what we used when we set out to understand how economists, investment managers and consumer advocates saw the work of the people whose ideas are shaping our futures and filling -- or emptying -- our wallets.
Read on for a further breakdown of how our experts felt about the Class of 2011. Some experts wanted very much to talk about our players but not give letter grades at all, giving them "incomplete" reports instead. We aggregated the results and left their individual calls ultimately anonymous. (Their comments are not.)
Economists: Ellen Frank, economics professor at the University of Massachusetts at Boston and senior economist at the Poverty Institute; Stephen M. Miller, chairman of the economics department at the Lee Business School at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas; Jonathan A. Parker, the Donald C. Clark/HSBC professor of consumer finance at Northwestern University's Kellogg School of Management; Benjamin Powell, economics professor at Suffolk University in Boston and senior fellow with the Independent Institute; and L. Randall Wray, professor of economics at the University of Missouri-Kansas City and senior scholar at the Levy Economics Institute of Bard College.
Investment managers: Jeff Auxier, the president of Auxier Asset Management in Lake Oswego, Ore.; James Dailey, a portfolio manager at TEAM Asset Managers in Harrisburg, Pa.; Craig Hodges, the president of Hodges Capital Management in Dallas; Paul Nolte, managing director at Dearborn Partners in Chicago; Robert Pavlik, the New York-based chief investment officer with Banyan Partners.
Consumer advocates: David Arkush, the director of Public Citizen's Congress Watch; Christopher Elliott, the author of "Scammed: How to Save Your Money and Find Better Service in a World of Schemes, Swindles, and Shady Deals;" Chris Morran, senior editor of The Consumerist; Wes Moss of Capital Investment Advisors and host of the Atlanta radio show "Money Matters;" and Tracy Van Slyke, co-director of The New Bottom Line.
And now, the grades:
President Barack Obama
Obama's supporters argue that House of Representatives, under Republicans control since the 2010 midterm elections, is holding up his American Jobs Act. The bill would cut payroll taxes for employers and medium- to low-income employees, extend unemployment benefits, add infrastructure, modernize schools and upgrade foreclosed homes. The president's opponents say he's unwilling to hold the line on spending.
That particular bill seems headed toward a compromise agreement, but it's been as slow a slog to its signing as it's been for just about any economic legislation the president has supported this year. The White House took an active role in crafting the Budget Control Act and raising the debt ceiling, but it also shouldered some of the blame when Standard & Poor's downgraded the nation's credit rating.
The economists' grade: D+ (four gave grades)
Why: Wray is "glad to see that many of his economic advisers (all of them terrible) have jumped the sinking ship, but will the president replace them with anyone good? Not likely, given the way he treated Elizabeth Warren. By forcing her out, he showed us that he is not serious about reform." Miller agrees, saying it's a "big mistake to let others do the work on the group project."
The managers' grade: D+ (five gave grades)
Why: After some early pro-business efforts and because of bad advice, Hodges says of Obama, "He's now the anti-business president." Auxier agrees, saying Obama "doesn't understand what it takes to promote innovation and jobs."
The advocates' grade: C+ (five gave grades)
Why: Obama frustrates consumer advocates with his failure to deliver on everything from a powerful health care bill to implementation of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which some say could have been done through a recess appointment of a leader. "He reminds me of the kid in high school who promises he'll have fireworks and a light show for an oral report and stands up with just a wrinkled piece of paper," Morran says.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
NOVEMBER 6th, 2012 is almost here...then, I plan to vote out ALL D.C. incumbent politicians. Heck, I can balance my budget, so maybe I should run for office!
Seriously, the folks in D.C. DO NOT know which way is up!
Yeah... 'F's all the way around... corruption (Solyndra, Fast & Furious), Healthcare disaster, Libya invasion, Egypt screw up, proIslam dermolition of NASA, economic ruin, death to the US currency supply, multiple million dollar vacations, continued secrecy on his background as he out everyone else. The worst president in history. Out with the facist, marxist, redistributionist. The class warfare was started BY Obama, and HE IS one of the 1%ers.
Before we can blame or hold accountable anyone we need to look at ourselves first. By all means I am in agreement we need a change with the politicians...
Spending money we do not have, not their problem.
Buying a house you can not afford, not their problem.
Driving expensive cars you can not afford, not their problem.
Living above your income, not their problem.
Why not put an effort into buying your own products....(made in USA).
We all need to wake up and quit blaming everyone else for our problems, we have the ability to make changes, so let's start now......Hold everyone accountable.
Our government makes it way to easy.....Let's fix welfare abuse......why are our tax dollars supporting people that do not help themselves? Get something in return like working for it!!!!! Fix our social security, how in the heck can someone collect without contributing???? Fix unemployment, there are jobs out there just check monster, career builder and others. Use the money to make up the difference if you are taking a lower paying job than previous for the 26 weeks or so, use the rest to train for people new positions. Let's all look in the mirror and start holding ourselves accountable for our actions. We are always wanting someone to bail us out of our poor choices. Yes people will always need help, help the ones that need it and deserve it like our veterans and elderly as an example.....it is sad to know we have these individuals living in poor conditions while we keep giving to others to do nothing....
Then we need to look hard at our present leaders an start holding them accountable for their actions......we all would get fired if we did not do our jobs...why should they keep theirs for not doing theirs...take the open check book off of them.
Having obama for president is like having a premed student perform open heart surgery.
(black Alfred E. Newman (Mad Magazine) or black Howdy Doody) LOL Doesn't look like one of 'em?
it's sink or swim time when half of this country just fell below the poverty line...is it necessary for both parents to work 2 or maybe even 3 jobs each to survive?...we used to be a country that worked to live, we are now a country that lives to work, no time to enjoy our "freedom", we work for the government and insurance companies now, plain and simple (look at your paycheck, how much is social security? taxes state and federal? and the rest is insurance, it's at least 1/3 if not more) ...so far the riots have been peaceful, if they keep failing to act and keep spending, History shows us the people will push back
A poor excuss for human flesh.
Obama is not a leader, he is a bleeder of this economy!
Congress is not helping out by trying to control Obama, but someone needs to do it so he will not
any more screw ups and dig this country into a deeper hole.
We need to freeze his assets and put him up for trial of treason!
Fix our social security, how in the heck can someone collect without contributing????
....well Steelerguy, I don't know, everything I've read says you must work and contribute for a minimum for 40 calendar quarters (that's 10 years) in order to collect SS benefits, and that's right in the SSA website. Perhaps you can explain to us how you can get SS benefits without earning them.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
[BRIEFING.COM] The stock market finished the Tuesday session on the defensive after spending the entire day in a steady retreat. The S&P 500 (-0.6%) posted its third consecutive decline, while the small-cap Russell 2000 (-0.9%) slipped behind the broader market during afternoon action.
Equity indices were pressured from the start following some overnight developments that weighed on sentiment. The market tried to overcome the early weakness, but could not stage a sustained rebound, ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'