3/22/2013 4:00 PM ET|
No, inflation is not out of control
The idea that the Consumer Price Index hides inflation, and that prices are rising 6% a year or more, gets a lot of press. Here's a reality check.
Consumer prices are rising at less than 2% a year right now, the government says. The Federal Reserve says inflation is under control, at least for now.
But who are you going to believe? The government or your own eyes?
Based on their personal experiences, lots of people think the government's consumer price index vastly understates the true inflation rate. They know in their gut that inflation is really much higher, maybe even 10% per year.
Recently, for instance, MarketWatch columnist Dennis Miller asked his readers what they thought the true inflation rate was. About 84% of the 3,000 respondents said that inflation is running higher than 6% a year. The average response was 8.1%.
These people are deluded.
Why the CPI deniers are wrong
There's a whole cottage industry of CPI deniers. John Williams of Shadow Government Statistics, the dean of the deniers, says the real inflation rate over the past year would be 9.6% if the Bureau of Labor Statistics didn't manipulate the inflation data.
The BLS says inflation has averaged about 3% per year over the past 30 years, but Williams says it's averaged about 6%. Williams thinks prices in the real world are about twice as high as the BLS thinks they are, or to put it another way, our real standard of living is only half what the government says it is.
In particular, Williams and his ilk say that the BLS can't be trusted because its statistical methods assume that consumers get more for their money when products are improved, or when they buy cheaper versions of products. They say the BLS doesn't pass the smell test.
They maintain the only true measurement of inflation uses a fixed market basket of goods and services, with exactly the same items today as 30 years ago. Never mind that many of the things we buy today weren't on the shelves back then.
The BLS -- backed by most statisticians and economists — argues that its methods are sound and provide an accurate measurement of inflation. And the BLS argues that these methods have very little impact on the CPI as a whole, in the range of a few tenths of a percentage per year
But let's assume for a moment that the deniers are right that we should compare, as much as possible, prices of the same goods and services over time. So why not look at some actual prices and see how much they've risen over time?
If prices were rising 6% at a year, then it would mean most things would cost almost six times as much as they did 30 years ago. Under this scenario, milk would cost $13 a gallon, a family car would cost $38,000, a first-class postage stamp would cost $1.15 and a gallon of gas would cost $7.
Talk about failing the smell test! Maybe some folk pay those prices, but I don't.
I tried to figure out how much prices have actually gone up. I compared the prices paid today with the prices paid in 1983 for 20 common goods and services. I ignored changes in quality, such as much more powerful computers, safer and more efficient cars, or much worse service from airlines.
I don't pretend that my small sample is as accurate as the studies of millions of prices of thousands of products tracked by the BLS over the past 30 years, or PriceStats inflation gauge that tracks prices of thousands of goods and services sold online. It's not scientific or statistically sound, but it has the advantage of simplicity and transparency. There's no way to spin the results.
Annualized rates are much closer to 3%
Some people won't like what I found. For most of the goods and services in my sample, annualized inflation rates are much closer to 3% than to 6%.
The results are what you'd expect if you pay attention when you pay your bills. Prices of some goods and services -- cigarettes, tuition and health care, for example -- have risen at rapid clip. But prices of other goods have fallen (such as computers) or have been essentially unchanged for years (such as clothing or airfares).
Most of the essentials are rising at a 2% to 4% pace, just like the BLS has been saying.
So why do so many people insist that prices are actually growing twice as fast as they really are?
For some, it's a political stance. The government is bad, therefore everything it does or says must be wrong.
For others, it's more a matter of how our brains are wired. We notice when prices go up, but not when they fall. We notice prices that we pay every day but not prices that we pay only infrequently.
And most people don't understand the arithmetic of compounding. It might surprise you to know that prices will double in 30 years with an inflation rate of just 2.3%. It doesn't take 6%.
But, in my view, the real reason so many people think inflation is out of control is that their income isn't keeping up with it. For much of the first 75 years of the 20th century, wages and salaries rose much faster than prices did. It took fewer and fewer hours of work to buy the staples and the luxuries of life. Our living standards improved visibly.
But over the past 30 years or so, average wages have been rising at about the same pace as prices, about 3% a year. And that's the average. Some people's earnings have grown slower than average, which means they have to work more hours to buy the same things that they bought 30 years ago.
No wonder they think prices are too high. Their standard of living has fallen.
But they are wrong. It's not that prices are too high; it's that wages are too low.
More from MarketWatch:
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Remember the CPI in its current form does not include food or gasoline.
5 years ago a gallon of gas was about $1.80. Today it is about $3.80. A rise of approximately 111%/5 years or an average of 22.2%.
Simply Orange juice was $2.99 a half gallon last year. This year it is $3.99 'on sale. This is approximately a 33% increase.
While the rate of inflation over the past 30 years may be in the 3% range, what really counts is what is happening now, not the 30 year time horizon as delineated in the article.
Printing money is one of two ways to cause inflation. You cannot print $85 billion a month in new bills for years and not have inflation.
What happens when the printing press stops? Watch what happens to interest rates. They will have to rise. When they rise watch what happens to the economy. Loans for houses, cars and other big ticket items will rise. Credit card interest rates will rise. People will have no choice but to reduce spending.
The result will be an ever depressed economy. We can't even cut the rate of growth of spending, much less cut spending. Media & politicians say we cut $85 billion via the sequester. In reality, it was actually about $44 billion as we are already half way through the fiscal year.
What a load of bullsh*t!!! Anyone that has to actually pay for their own food instead of eating at the taxpayers expense knows full well that inflation is way higher than the numbers and lies the Obama Administration is spewing.
This guys on drugs. In the 1960's my mother was allowed $40.00 a week to feed a family of 7 She
left the store with a full cart usually 7 to 8 bags of food and other household items. Bleach, soap,
laundry detergent and so on. Today that gets you a bag if your lucky. Why is it they leave food and
fuel out of there computation? Reason, those are the two biggest inflation items.
A personal computer in 2012 for $250? Is that a typo? What kind of piece of crap computer costs $250?
Even if inflation is 2%, wages are falling.....thus buying power is decreasing. It seems to be pretty simple math to everyone but this author.
Productivity gains which lead to lower prices due to advances in manufacturing, etc should be completely factored out of the inflation calculation. What the tricky government inflation calculators do is use lower prices due to productivity gains for say TVs and clothing, to offset higher prices due to inflation such as medical care and gas. They mix it all up together so they can proclaim inflation is lower than it really is.
Sure inflation isn't bad over the past 30 years. Prices have been pretty stable up til about 2008 when oil skyrocketed to $140/bbl, etc. The measure of inflation is supposed to be the year-to-year change in prices and on that it is high. Health insurance premiums have been increasing at double digit rates ever since Obamacare was signed into law. I know people who saw their health insurance premiums go up 40% in the last year and they were told it would double from there by 2014. They will be up 200% from the 2011 level. These are small business owners so who do you think is going to pay for those increases? Their customers. BOOM! More inflation.
Maybe some things cost less since the jobs for these items went to 4th world nations and their children , but items like computers and cell phones aren't something we buy to eat or used to fuel are vehicles . How about the fact that most packaging for food has gotten much smaller as the price continues to rise.
I love how these guys from the east coast have no clue how the rest of have to get by while they live the high life in the media !
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
[BRIEFING.COM] The stock market ended the holiday-shortened week on a mixed note as the Dow Jones Industrial Average shed 0.1%, while the S&P 500 added 0.1% with seven sectors posting gains.
Equity indices faced an uphill climb from the opening bell after disappointing quarterly results from Google (GOOG 536.10, -20.44) and IBM (IBM 190.04, -6.36) weighed on the early sentiment. Google reported earnings $0.15 below the Capital IQ consensus estimate on revenue of $15.42 ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'