10/1/2013 7:30 PM ET|
No Washington, no big deal?
So far, the U.S. government shutdown (and similar political deadlock in Italy) hasn’t rattled the market. Here’s a look at how much calm we can expect before the storm.
So where’s the panic?
The U.S. government has “shut down,” with no formula to end the crisis short of intervention by the ghosts of George Washington and Abe Lincoln.
Next, in two or three weeks, the United States government will hit its debt ceiling limit and nobody is negotiating with anybody to avoid a confrontation with just two likely outcomes:
The first is a default on U.S. government debt that could send global financial markets into chaos;
The second is a U.S. constitutional crisis if President Barack Obama decides to ignore the debt ceiling.
Meanwhile, the Italian coalition government looks likely to fall and the country is likely to, No. 1, violate its promise to reduce its budget deficit this year to 3% or less and, No. 2, continue in a recession that now stretches back to 2011.
And the reaction to this turmoil in the financial markets? On Monday morning, in the first hours of a New York trading session that was the first time that U.S. financial institutions and traders could react to the weekend’s news, the yield on the U.S. 10-year Treasury actually fell -- meaning that the bond rose in price -- by 0.01 percentage point to 2.61% as of 9:30 a.m. New York time.
And while stocks were down 2.06% in Tokyo over night, as the trading day moved towards the source of news in Rome and New York, the damage got progressively smaller. Stocks in Milan were down just 1.33% as the trading day there moved toward a close on Monday. At Monday's close in New York, the Standard & Poor’s 500 was off 0.6%. On Tuesday, the major indexes posted gains.
That’s panic? Nah, that’s ho hum.
So why are the markets acting so blasé? How long might that collective shrug last? And what’s going on under the surface that might suggest a deeper anxiety?
Washington, take some time off
First, the markets don’t think that a shutdown of the U.S. government is a very big deal. Everyone understands that a “shutdown” will leave much of the government operating -- Social Security checks will go out and air traffic controllers will work without pay. As long as the shutdown is of limited duration -- a couple of weeks at the outside -- no big deal.
Second, perverse as it may be, bond traders see a limited shutdown of the U.S. government as a plus for U.S. Treasurys. The theory is that a government shutdown and the resulting reduction in U.S. economic growth pushes off the day when the Federal Reserve will begin to taper off its $85 billion in monthly purchases of Treasurys and mortgage-backed assets. A short shutdown would take the possibility of an October decision to begin a taper off the table and might even push a December taper toward the realm of the unlikely. From this perspective, the recent rally in U.S. Treasurys that has taken the yield on the 10-year Treasury down to 2.59% is a continuation of the post-Sept. 18 rally in Treasurys when the Fed didn’t take action on a taper.
Third, there’s still a large element of denial. More traders seem to believe that whatever bad does happen won’t be in effect for very long. At an extreme, the markets want to deny that the Republican leadership in the House of Representatives won’t decide to let Democrats and a few Republicans pass a clean continuing resolution, or that Italian Prime Minister Enrico Letta won’t be able to put together the votes to win a confidence vote in the next few days or that.
(Some background on this less familiar confrontation: Over the weekend in Italy the government of Prime Minister Letta moved to the edge of collapse after allies of Silvio Berlusconi said they planned to quit the coalition government. Berlusconi’s conviction on a criminal charge of tax fraud leaves him open to expulsion from parliament, and Letta has refused to block those proceedings. So far Italian president Giorgio Napolitano hasn’t dissolved parliament or called for new elections, but that seems just a matter of days with Letta saying he plans a confidence vote in parliament on Oct. 1 or 2. Letta’s government would probably lose that vote without the support of Berlusconi’s People of Liberty party. Yields on Italy’s 10-year bond were up 0.13 percentage point last week to 4.42%.)
And, fourth, institutional investors calculate that as long as the turmoil in Washington and Rome doesn’t get too intense or go on for too long, it’s cheaper to hedge bets with derivatives such as credit default swaps on U.S. or Italian debt than to actually liquidate positions. No need to actually sell Treasurys or U.S. stocks if “insurance” in the derivatives market stays cheap enough.
If those are the reasons for the market’s very muted reaction to the current news coming out of Rome and Washington, D.C., then I get this framework for projecting how markets will react going forward.
'How long?' is the key
The market is currently only pricing in limited damage from a government shutdown in the United States and that some kind of political patch job will emerge in relatively short order in Italy (after considerable pressure from the European Central Bank, the International Monetary Fund and the European Commission.)
Which, of course, means that a U.S. shutdown that goes on for more than a couple of weeks isn’t priced in. Nor is a shutdown that runs into a bloody battle over raising the debt ceiling. I think global markets will show a much bigger reaction if the shutdown battle looks like it is leading to a heightened likelihood of a confrontation over the debt ceiling that might lead to some measure of a U.S. default. (In the case of Italy, if negotiation fails and the country proceeds to a snap election that produces an even less stable coalition or, worse yet from the point of view of the financial markets, a victory for Berlusconi’s People of Liberty Party after a campaign promising no new taxes, then I think you’ll see the price of Italian bonds fall and yields climb significantly.)
Also key: the price of insurance. At the point where it gets too expensive to buy a derivative to insure against a big move downward, the incentives for selling go up dramatically.
The problem in gauging the cost of credit default swaps on U.S. government debt is that the market is relatively thin. After all who would think they need to buy insurance on the debt of the world’s largest economy and instruments that trade in the world’s deepest market?
Still, on Friday, the price of credit default swaps on U.S. Treasurys had climbed to 32 basis points. That’s the highest since May.
Last time the U.S. markets went through this -- back at the time of last debt ceiling battle in the summer of 2011 -- the price of a credit default swap on U.S. Treasurys climbed to 62 basis points. (That was the highest since the global financial crisis. What it means is that an investor would pay 62,000 euros a year to insure 10 million euros of U.S. Treasurys against a default in the next five years. The contract, equal to $13.5 million, is denominated in euros to offset the impact of a default on the U.S. dollar.)
So you can see that we’re still a good way now at 32 basis points from the 62 basis points of the summer of 2011.
But the price is rising. And not just for U.S. debt. The biggest impact of the turmoil in Washington may fall on developing economies such as India or Indonesia with current account deficits and sagging growth rates. Credit default swaps on Asian debt (outside of Japan), as tracked by the Markit iTrax Asian index, had climbed to 155 basis points as of Monday. That’s the highest level since Sept. 4, and at this level insuring this debt costs about five times as much as insuring U.S. Treasurys against default.
The breaking point
So where do markets go from here?
To a large degree that depends on events in Washington and Rome -- and market interpretation of those events. If these two crises stretch out or worsen, then, duh!, markets will get more nervous. Reaction, I think it’s important to point out, will not be linear. Markets are likely to ignore gradually worsening scenarios with just minor declines until -- wham -- the duration gets scary or the price of insurance goes too high.
A rule of thumb might be that risk of something blowing up in the markets goes up at twice (?) or more (squared?) the actual increase in duration.
And while you’re keeping an eye out for a possible big move in the U.S. or European markets, don’t neglect the effect of these two crises on currencies and emerging stock markets.
The Japanese yen has again emerged as the safe haven of choice. That has sent the yen up and Japanese stocks down. Since the Abe government’s program to stimulate the Japanese economy depends on a weak yen, this move upwards isn’t good news for Tokyo equities. I wouldn’t necessarily sell Japanese stocks here since the bounce back when the yen again weakens is likely to be strong and a big new tax credit goes into effect in Japan on Oct. 1 that gives Japanese investors tax-free profit on $10,100 in capital gains a year as long the invest in equities. My strategy here might be to instead buy on weakness sometime in the next week or two.
Emerging stock markets are likely to be very volatile during the U.S. budget and debt ceiling battles. (Remember that rising fear tends to send money into U.S. Treasurys, even when the United States is the source of the fear.) I would frankly stay out of the most exposed emerging stock markets -- India, Turkey and Indonesia, to name three -- until this mess in the United States has subsided.
In Europe, I’d watch for the Italian crisis to reverse the recent optimism about European economic growth.
Interesting times. Which isn’t a good thing in my book.
At the time of publication, Jim Jubak did not own shares of any of the companies mentioned in this column in his personal portfolio. When in 2010 he started the mutual fund he manages, Jubak Global Equity Fund, Jubak liquidated all his individual stock holdings and put the money into the fund. The fund did not own shares of any stock mentioned in this column as of the end of June. For a full list of the stocks in the fund as of the end of June, see the fund’s portfolio at http://jubakfund.com/about-the-fund/holdings/
The last Jubak’s Picks column will run on MSN Money on Nov. 13. His my free web site JubakPicks.com will continue to offer the same mix (frequently with more daily content than MSN Money ran) of big picture posts, stock picks and portfolios. You can find it at http://jubakpicks.com/. You can also find his columns at MoneyShow.com. If that doesn’t fill your Jubak needs, you can get a free 7-day trial and $100 off a yearly subscription to my premium investment letter JAM [by clicking here] or visiting jubakam.com/subscribe/100-off-for-msn-users/
Related at MoneyShow.com:
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Shutting the Washington Government Down is the best thing that could happen to this country !
Government needs to get out of our lives and our business !
It is all about the Debt Ceiling and Treasury Defaults now. 2 weeks and counting.
And the Republicans may just have enough love for this country to bring it all the way to collapse.
This three-headed Obama, Reid and Pelosi monster must be stopped. Socialized medicine is a terrible thing. Don't believe the democrats' lies.
In order to build something better, the old must be torn down first.
My question is WHY do we have non-essential employees in the FIRST place? Get rid of all of them.
You would eliminate all this kind of crap "IF" there was a limit to political terms. All the politicians do is do and say whatever it takes to get reelected.
Since senators terms are 4 years, the limit should be 2 terms.
Since representatives terms are 2 years, the limit should be 3 terms.
The only real problem with this would be, after they retired they would have to go out and get a legitimate respectful job.
And, last but not least, any politician should only be allowed to draw no more than one pension from a political office. And, the retirement should be no more than 50% of their last political wage.
WOW, that was a mouthful!!!!!!!
OK JIM, what do you say?????????????????????
So I guess the answer or solution is to fire all the politicians and we the people can run the country like it is. Must be the system can run itself without Washington DC.
Hmmm.......wonder how low our taxes will be once we dissolve DC?
Fifth: Investors are celebrating the FACT that some positive movement toward ending the drunken sailor spending in DC will have an immeasurable positive effect on the economic health of the nation. Leftist news outlets spew R-E-C-O-V-E-R-Y no matter how many working hours are cut to 29.5, companies drop their employee's healthcare, unemployment [only appears to] decline, the manipulated stock market [appears to] rise, the housing market "improves" [although the majority of houses are being sold to "flippers" not homeowners] etc. The market continued to tank. THEN, this bold, positive move-and - voila - the market turns green. It's magic!
You still have a job with this site, Jim?
Thought they were laying all of you guys off do the booming economy
MSN keeps bragging about.
Guess they need to keep some one around to eventually turn off the lights.
I would like to congratulate the Washington D.C. police officer who pulled the barricades back to let the WWII veterans visit the memorial yesterday. We need more of this type of 'civil disobedience' from the Police officers who are assigned to 'guard' the memorials & monuments.
These belong to the American people Barack Obama- Not the government !
On the MSN homepage, they had a poll question regarding signing up for Obamacare. The choices for answers were:
Yes, and the site worked well for me.
Yes, and the experience was dreadful.
No, but I plan to do it soon.
No, and I won't until I absolutely have to.
I couldn't select any of those because the correct selection for my choice was not available.
My choice is:
NO, AND I'M NOT GOING TO..."EVER"!! THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT CAN PHUCK OFF AND GO TO HELL!!
That's the choice I'm making. I encourage all real Americans who are opposed to tyranny and government force to make the same selection.
Years from now, when our kids in 10, 20 years look back to this government shut down, they will not remember who the speaker of the house was, or the Senate majority leader, or the 21 hour Ted Cruz speech. All they'll remember is that this happened under Obama's tenure and possibly labeled the WORST president in our life time- even worse than Jimmy Carters leadership
(and Jimmy is a wonderful person still serving/helping his fellow man)
This president is the weakest man I've ever seen in the oval office. He says," don't mess with 'my' health care law" (oh - the arrogance), but it's ok when HE strips parts out but no one else can. He does not care about YOU- THE VOTERS WHO PUT HIM THERE ! All he cares for is his pride. He won't even discuss this but has the time to call the Iranian President. The only reason the Iranians are 'making nice' now is the fact that Obama is WEAK ! They know this and want to take advantage of the situation. Do you really think that Obama can effectively deal with them but can not even deal with the American people ?
So nothing will be adversely affected for 4-5 day's. But as we get closer to 10/17, the debt ceiling talks, that's when it's going to get dicey.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
[BRIEFING.COM] The stock market ended the Wednesday session on a mixed note with small caps displaying relative strength. The Nasdaq Composite (+0.5%) and Russell 2000 (+0.4%) registered modest gains, while the Dow Jones Industrial Average (-0.2%) and S&P 500 (+0.01%) underperformed.
Despite the mixed finish, the key indices traded higher across the board at the start of the session after the advance reading of second quarter GDP surpassed estimates (4.0% versus Briefing.com ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'