8/28/2012 8:21 PM ET|
The monster stalking Facebook stock
The social-networking giant and a long list of other young names in the sector could get bitten in coming months as new shares hit the market. Here's how to play the pain.
Facebook, LinkedIn and Angie's List are all so-called Web 2.0 stocks. But they're vulnerable to the same hazard that took down a lot of Web 1.0 stocks the last time around.
That's the dreaded stock-killing monster known as a "lockup release."
Fortunately, there are ways to avoid this risk and even use it to your advantage to make money. I'll explain how in a moment, then take a look at upcoming hurdles facing some hot Web stocks. But first, what's a lockup release?
To ward off heavy selling by early investors and insiders right out of the gate on an initial public offering, investment banks and companies order these folks not to sell right away -- to "lock up" their stock.
Typically these lockups -- which are disclosed in filings -- last for 90 or 180 days.
After that, all heck can break loose. Insiders -- hungry for profits, or worse, gloomy about the outlook for their companies -- can rush for the exits. Predictably, their stocks tank under heavy selling. Consider the damage done by lockup releases at three of the social-networking, Web 2.0 companies the market was hot on not long ago:
● When a Facebook (FB) lockup expired Aug. 16, selling spiked, and the already-disappointing stock tanked. Volume jumped to 100 million to 150 million shares a day for three days, compared with an average of about 30 million before that. Facebook stock fell 13% by Aug. 20 to under $19, from above $22 on Aug. 13, a few days before the lockup release. Typically, lockup-related weakness kicks in several days early, as investors see it coming and sell beforehand.
● At Angie's List (ANGI), the popular online consumer-review site, things got even uglier. Its lockup expired Aug. 14. Volume spiked to 3 million shares, compared with daily volume of around 400,000 before. The stock fell to about $11 from a close of $13.29 the day before. And it just kept falling to around $9, for a tumble of more than 25%.
● LinkedIn (LNKD) fell from $80 a week before its Nov. 21, 2011, lockup release to $56 a week after, for a 30% decline.
Though lockups are back in the news now, they are really old hat. I remember tracking them during the tech bubble, before that broke a decade ago, for potential buys on the pullbacks. The declines tied to lockup releases were potential moneymakers. You could, for example, buy when stocks dipped and sell when they'd bounced back.
Is it different now?
But there's a troubling new twist these days. Many Web 2.0 stocks are falling harder on the lockups, and they are not getting up again. At least not right away. Why the more extreme reaction this time around? Experts cite these reasons:
- Low floats at high prices. A lot of social media companies are issuing just 5% to 10% of their available stock in the initial public offering, creating a small stock float, with relatively few shares on the market. They've also been coming out at high valuations relative to measures such as cash flow, sales and profits, points out David Rudow, a tech sector analyst for Thrivent Financial for Lutherans. That's a recipe for a selloff on a lockup release, since putting more shares out creates selling pressure. "When the unlock happens, there is just a flood of shares," he says.
- Bad memories. "A lot of the venture capitalists behind the social media companies worked during the 1990s," says Tom Taulli of IPO Playbook. "So from prior experience, they realize that wealth can evaporate quickly in new technologies." If there are some gains on the table, they are more inclined to take them by selling.
- Bad news. Many Web 2.0 companies have run into trouble, and this casts a pall on the sector. This makes insiders and early investors eager to cash out as soon as their lockups expire -- which means more shares for sale and lower prices. Groupon (GRPN), the online coupon company, fell hard on Aug. 14 on bad earnings news and a weak outlook. Zynga (ZNGA), the company behind Facebook games such as "FarmVille," and "CityVille," did the same in late July. "There are no positives," Stifel Nicolaus analyst Jordan Rohan said of Zynga's second-quarter results, just after they were announced. "Annual guidance was simply gutted. The competitive advantage Zynga enjoyed appears to have dissipated." Likewise, Facebook failed to post the upbeat sales outlook many had been looking for when it announced second-quarter results, and many wonder how it can make money in the mobile space.
- Privileged exits. There's another troubling new twist on the lockup release at Web 2.0 companies, namely special early releases for a privileged few insiders. This makes outside investors, and insiders without the privilege, even more antsy.
Need an example? At Zynga, CEO Mark Pincus and some other execs wrangled a waiver from bankers that let them sell in early April, about two months ahead of the scheduled lockup release. This allowed them to sell at just under $12, while others at Zynga had to wait for an early June release. By then, the stock was at $6.
Pincus alone dumped 16.5 million shares at $11.64, grossing $192 million, according to Thomson Reuters. Thus, he dodged a $93 million loss. By August, Pincus had purchased a $16 million house in the posh Pacific Heights section of San Francisco, home of tech billionaires. Does this seem fair? Zynga declined to respond, but during a conference call, investors were told that the business was in better shape when the exceptions were made, and then things deteriorated quickly.
To many, though, Pincus' pounding at the door to get out was a troubling sign. "How badly do you want to tell me that you don't want to co-invest with me?" asks Fabio Savoldelli, who teaches hedge fund investing at Columbia Business School.
Indeed, professional investors regularly watch lockups, and you should, too. "It's one of the many bits of information that a hedge fund will absolutely look at to see how much overhang there is in a stock," says Savoldelli. "Overhang" means share supply likely to hit the market -- in this case because of a lockup release.
How to invest in lockups
I'll assume most of my readers are looking at lockups as investors, not insiders. There are two basic ways to deal with lockups:
- Use them for better entry points. "Do your research in advance and wait for the lockup to buy," says Rudow, at Thrivent. "Lockups are just another tool to buy something that you want to own for the long term." Anyone who waited for the LinkedIn lockup release in November could have gotten the stock in the $50 range instead of above $80 just a week before. With the stock at more than $100 a share now, you'd be up in either case, but you'd be happier if you bought at $50.
- Bet against companies just ahead of lockup expirations. The results can be great. Keep in mind that stocks often start declining days before the lockup expiration, as investors anticipate it. The shares of Bazaarvoice (BV), which helps companies analyze online commentary about their products, fell from $16 on Aug. 14, to $13.75 the day before its Aug. 22 lockup, which then took it as low as $13 that day. As I noted above, Angie's List and LinkedIn fell 25% to 30% around their respective lockups in August and November. You can bet against stocks by shorting them, or borrowing them to sell now, assuming you can replace return them later at a lower price. Or you can buy put options, which give you the right to sell someone a stock at a prearranged price. The value of puts goes up when stocks decline.
Of course, keep in mind that betting against stocks ahead of a lockup can be risky, because there's no guarantee a lockup will cause a stock to tank. These are relatively adventurous trading moves.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
After all the shenanigans we’ve seen in the market since Facebook’s IPO, I think the only sensible play for small investors is not to play at all. The only uncertainty of what happens to this stock from here on is whether more fools and suckers are willing to try and get in on it. Most of those who try will lose. If only you could convince your pension fund managers of this, you would probably be better off too.
I say let the insiders, Wall Street dealers, and market makers play with themselves on this Facebook fiasco. That’s mostly what’s happening now anyway. Admittedly, that’s not very fun to watch either.
"A MONSTER IS STALKING FACEBOOk"....................
Well there is much worse than that...............
Obama is Stalking America...........................
the are not trusty for one penny!!never will
It's also known as the "I'm so sick of **** posts from fake friends and bots that I'm quitting this website" syndrome. It also does business as the "This website is so full of time wasters and games that my work life and social life suffer, so I'm switching back to real life and networking with real people" disorder.
It's business associates are the "website membership lacks or fails security so bad that strangers are calling my real-life friends and asking about me" disease, the "my boss is viewing all my posts to find a reason to fire me" syndrome, the "my family members are complaining about my posting high score results on games and asking them to join me, that the only thing they say to me anymore is a request to stop posting to them at all" syncope, and the "I've wasted valuable time on social networks that could be better spent in personal contact with live people, or better yet, hitting the pavement and looking for a job with live people" form of pleurisy.
People are leaving "social networks" on the internet because they are NOT SOCIALLY NETWORKING for anything gainful! Except for the career-oriented LinkedIn.com, social networks are a complete waste of time! MySpace became nothing more than a venue for alternative rock artists. Google+ is just an adjunct to their GMail site. Angie's List is one of the best sites on here because of consumer reviews from disinterested third parties and people who have complaints or compliments about regional service providers. Forget about Facebook, the "Walmart" of the social networks.
Frankly, I'm sticking with LinkedIn. You can only officially allow persons with whom you have worked or are working, and their direct work-oriented connections, into your network. You have the right to deny contact with anyone whom is not in your direct line of career influence or who does not directly influence your job. There are also no games on LinkedIn. I wish only the best for LinkedIn partners and hope to God they get more pro-active on their policy of "zero tolerance" for crap.
Richard C. August
I have had ENOUGH! The top 10% owns over 90% of all wealth. WHY? Well, take a look at this and you will see. Do a gooogle search of ' FAST_SLICK_RICH ' and go to the first site. Click on one of the insurance pages to see how they are getting tax free cash and how you can too. It is a must see if you want to get out of working the 9-5 life.
scam and corruption and lies from facebook he sold over 1 billion shares to friends and private bankers before it was on the real share market other people go to jail for it the keep there fig and like up with bots and still in court for it !! and many more the hide for the law and government
the are not trusty for one penny!!never
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
[BRIEFING.COM] The stock market finished the Tuesday session on the defensive after spending the entire day in a steady retreat. The S&P 500 (-0.6%) posted its third consecutive decline, while the small-cap Russell 2000 (-0.9%) slipped behind the broader market during afternoon action.
Equity indices were pressured from the start following some overnight developments that weighed on sentiment. The market tried to overcome the early weakness, but could not stage a sustained rebound, ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'