5/16/2012 3:10 PM ET|
What I don't 'like' about Facebook
The IPO will be huge; the company has an impressive reach. But what does it say when our hottest business wins because young adults are stuck on couches?
People around the world, not just stock market junkies, have been whipped into a rare frenzy this week by the oversubscribed, eagerly anticipated Facebook initial public offering.
The initial public offering, scheduled for Friday (read "What to know about Facebook's IPO"), could very well serve as the crescendo for the social media, Web 2.0 phenomenon that has been one of the few bright spots of the recovery.
That recovery is now in its fourth calendar year. It is a recovery that, by just about every metric you'd care to use, has been a massive disappointment, despite unprecedented stimulus support.
But who wants to talk about things like persistent joblessness, stagnant wages or depressed home prices? I'd rather see what my old college buddies are up to or post a snarky status update.
I poke fun, but Facebook really has captured the popular zeitgeist in the way all great business cycle leaders do before they overreach. It was the big transcontinental railroads in the late 1800s, big steel in the early 1900s, then radio, aerospace, materials, IT and housing. The Facebook IPO will be a wild success, no doubt.
Still, I can't help but be a little disappointed. I don't like what the rise of Facebook says about our economic vitality, about what we're using our energies to achieve. We're not dreaming big dreams or building big things. We're not finding intensive uses of labor and capital. But we do know the moment friends we haven't seen since high school change their relationship status.
We, as a country, can't even send anyone into space anymore. Our astronauts hitchhike on Russian rockets to the International Space Station. But we can follow their journeys on Facebook.
An Angry Birds nation
The rise of Facebook reflects the reality of our debt-deleveraging malaise -- a malaise we share with the rest of the rich world, especially Europe. It's all about austerity as we try to cut personal debt. This latest wave of IPOs has been all about free or cheap entertainment, shopping discounts or networking for new jobs. I'm sorry, but you just can't put millions to work with sepia-hued snapshots and Angry Birds. We're not going to restore the American middle class with 99-cent apps.
Not when the most recent business cycle was fueled by people indulging in McMansions and HDTVs. Not when the cycle before that brought about one of the greatest revolutions in labor productivity and information accessibility in human history. Those are high standards to meet for Facebook, a platform that achieved success by being a no-cost way to indulge some of the basest desires of the human psyche: self-promotion and voyeurism.
I've written more than once about how this economic recovery is falling short based on a lack of job growth and stagnant wages. (For one example, read "Are American workers getting lazy?") It's the same story with spending.
You can see this in the data. We're driving less. We're spending less. Really, we're living less, according to the research of Philippa Dunne at The Liscio Report. Consumption dropped hard across all spending categories during the recession and has yet to bounce back, for a variety of reasons. Thus, there is interest in companies, such as Facebook, that can benefit from this dynamic. That isn't bull market behavior in any traditional sense.
Ten quarters into a typical recovery, inflation-adjusted consumption is about 12% higher than the previous peak.
Ten quarters into this one, which is where we were at the end of 2011, we were less than 2% above the old peak, leaving a gap of 10%. Consumption of durable goods -- things like appliances and automobiles -- is almost 12% behind the average. Nondurables are 6% back. And consumption of services, which normally doesn't fall during a recession (since it's hard to cut back on haircuts and doctor visits) is more than 11% behind where it should be, with transportation, recreation and finance particularly weak.
What's worse is that even this middling pace is unsustainable, supported by temporary tail winds like a decline in the personal-savings rate and a renewed interest in credit card debt as real wages stall. You can see this in the following chart:
The savings rate dropped from 4.7% in December to 3.8% in March. Revolving consumer credit hit $790 billion in April 2011. Now, it's pushing toward $804 billion as shoppers turn to plastic.
According to Standard Chartered economists, unless there is an improvement in wealth or wages soon, consumption will fall back and drop further behind the historic averages. That might be good news for Facebook's unique-visitor and page-view metrics, since people will have to stay home as they rebuild bombed-out savings. But it's bad news for the rest of us.
The economic generation gap
Of course, there is a demographic story to the Facebook economy, since it trends young. The dynamics that are limiting the overall economy -- a lousy job market, high debt and stalled wages -- are hitting young adults hard. They've dealt with surging tuition costs: Since 1980, while the overall Consumer Price Index is up 194%, the college tuition component is up 829%. College students have turned to debt. The student debt clock run by the website FinAid recently topped $1 trillion.
Dunne paints an uncomfortable picture for the millennials. Mired in student debt and competing with people about their parents' age who are staying in the workforce, many young adults are taking menial jobs just to stay afloat, according to the Heldrich Center for Workforce Development at Rutgers. That's pinching their spending: 40% have delayed the purchase of a house or a car, 28% have put off more education, 27% have moved back in with their parents, and 14% have delayed marriage.
Remember that demographics play a critical role in the two most important asset markets for the U.S. economy: housing and the stock market. If young adults can't establish homesteads and build nest eggs, baby boomers looking to cash out will find a dearth of buyers willing to transform their homes and stocks into the cash they need to fund retirement.
That's why the housing market is still in the tank and why, based on funds-flow data, over the past three years private investors have been net redeemers of equities two-thirds of the time as they sell into rallies and rebalance into bonds and more-conservative assets. The boomers' increasing orientation toward capital preservation and risk aversion isn't being offset by risk-taking youngsters. It's no surprise, then, that the Standard & Poor's 500 Index ($INX) has yet to retake its 2000 or 2007 highs despite corporate profits running at record highs.
Not to be a party pooper, but until we get college grads off Facebook, off their parents' couches and out of their Gap hoodies, the economy doesn't really deserve a thumbs-up, if you know what I mean.
Be sure to check out Anthony's new money management service, Mirhaydari Capital Management, and his investment newsletter, the Edge. A free, two-week trial subscription to the newsletter has been extended to MSN Money readers. Click here to sign up. Mirhaydari can be contacted at email@example.com and followed on Twitter at @EdgeLetter. You can view his current stock picks here. Feel free to comment below.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
i do not understand what everyone is so enamored about.
EVERYDAY is ANOTHER story about how someone got royally screwed by using facebook.
yet the lemmings keep lining up.
why not look up what a loser mark zuckerberg thinks YOU are and then tell me what a great deal facebook is
facebook is driven by each of our own egos...
"look what i'm doing"
and little more.
the pictures of your friends are the only cool thing, but that has never been enough to get me to sign up.
I know what you mean, baby.
Here’s what I don’t like about Facebook. How they see me. They think I am nothing but a page of information in a data base that appears on a computer screen. That’s the only vision of me that they think has any value. That’s how they define me and all they want to allow me to be. That’s how they plan to analyze me, categorize me, sell me to others, and control me. Sorry Facebook, I am so much more than that. Perhaps if you could see that, I would see some value in you.
Facebook is one massive TIMESUCK!
It is for "needy" chicks, and guys who never could gete any girls in high school!
NEWSFLASH...nobody cares that you just did a 3.1 mile run (and you feel great!). I mean really...were you being chased by a dog or something?
Piss poor writing trying to say facebook is to blame and not congress or politicians in general.
Piss poor reading comprehension doesn't see the intent of this article. Anthony is saying that facebook is a symptom not the cause.
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Quotes are real-time for NASDAQ, NYSE and AMEX. See delay times for other exchanges.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Thomson Reuters (click for restrictions). Real-time quotes provided by BATS Exchange. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Interactive Data Real-Time Services. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by SIX Financial Information.
[BRIEFING.COM] The major averages ended modestly lower with the S&P 500 shedding 0.3%.
The benchmark average saw an opening loss of 1.2% after Japan's Nikkei tumbled 7.3%. Japanese stocks sold off amid continued volatility in Japanese Government Bond futures as the 10-yr yield spiked almost 16 basis points to 1.002 before the Bank of Japan's JPY2 trillion liquidity injection caused yields to retrace their gains.
Adding insult to injury was news out of China where the HSBC ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|