4/2/2012 7:50 PM ET|
Will rally fall to the fear factor?
At the end of a good first quarter, economically sensitive stocks started to fade. It could be a scary time to invest, but there's a sector that's a big exception.
A funny thing happened on the way to the end of the first quarter.
After leading the stock market for most of the quarter, cyclical stocks started to lag the Standard & Poor's 500 Stock Index ($INX).
Is this a sign of what we can expect in the second quarter, as worries about economic growth take the steam out of profits for stocks that follow the economic cycle? I'd say so. I think we're seeing the first signs that the pendulum, which swung to optimism and drove this rally, is swinging in the other direction.
Fading auto sales, steel stocks
Let's start with some numbers. On the performance data, there's little doubt that cyclical stocks -- companies that recover when the economy does and that falter when the economy stumbles -- started to fade in the last month of the quarter.
The S&P 500 returned 12.4% for the quarter and 3.29% for the month of March.
But in the very cyclical auto sector -- what rises and falls with the economic cycle more than car sales? -- General Motors (GM) was up 26.54% for the quarter but down 1.42% for the month. Ford Motor (F) didn't dip into negative territory in the last month of the quarter, but the shares followed a similar pattern, up 16.4% for the quarter but up just 0.77% in March. Auto supplier BorgWarner (BWA) gained 32.32% for the quarter but lagged the S&P 500 in the last month with a 1.81% gain.
And it wasn't just auto stocks that this trend played out.
Steel-maker Nucor (NUE) was up 9.46% for the first quarter but down 0.49% for March. (The steel sector as a whole was up 9.12% for the quarter but down 4.55% for the month.) Construction and mining equipment producer Caterpillar (CAT) was up 18.08% for the quarter but down 6.73% for the month. Diesel engine maker Cummins (CMI) was up 36.83% for the quarter, but down 0.44% in the last month. Titan International (TWI), which makes tires for construction, mining and farm equipment, was up 21.56% for the quarter but down 4% for the month.
I think you get the idea. The Morgan Stanley Cyclical Index ($CYC) was up 15.8% from Dec. 30, 2011, though the close on Feb. 29. But in March, the index managed just a 0.45% gain against the 3.29% gain by the S&P 500. Membership in the Morgan Stanley Cyclical Index includes Alcoa (AA), Caterpillar, Johnson Controls (JCI) and US Steel (X).
Economic doubt takes control
Why the stumble in what had been a great quarter for cyclical stocks? Because cyclical stocks are by definition stocks most sensitive to the ups and downs of the economy. They're the most susceptible to worries that the economy is about to slow. And the end of the quarter saw the return of those worries by the bushel.
The eurozone looks headed for a deeper recession than originally forecast. High oil prices have raised fears that the U.S. economy will slow. Manufacturing and export numbers show that China's economy is slowing, and corporate profits in China are moving lower.
So it's no wonder that cyclicals had a rough time in March. Add in profit-taking after the gains recorded by some of these stocks in the first two-thirds of the quarter and worries about earnings growth in the reporting season (which starts with Alcoa's earnings release, after the New York markets close on April 10). Alcoa can stand as a representative of what investors fear they'll hear from cyclical stocks in the quarter: The Wall Street consensus is looking for Alcoa to report a loss of 3 cents a share for the quarter, compared with earnings of 28 cents a share in the first quarter of 2011.
Waiting for some good news
In general, I don't see much to tempt me to put money into cyclical stocks before earnings season and the macroeconomic news from Europe and China answer a few questions about growth.
In the United States, we get the March jobs numbers on Friday. Right now, economists are looking for the economy to have added 200,000 jobs in the month. While that would keep the economy's string of 200,000 or better months alive, it would also be a decline from the 227,000 added in February.
Near the end of the month, on April 27, investors will get the initial read on first-quarter growth of gross domestic product. The U.S. economy grew at a 3% annual rate in the fourth quarter, up from a 1.8% rate in the third quarter. The fear now is that high oil prices and the impending recession in Europe will cut into that growth rate.
We simply don't know.
Equally, I think we'll have a better understanding of the macroeconomic picture in Europe and China by the end of the second quarter, on June 30. Rising interest rates in Spain took the yield on the 10-year government bond to 5.4% at the close on March 30. That's still well below the 6.5%-plus level that signaled crisis at the beginning of the year, but it is significantly higher than the yield in early March of just below 5%.
The problem for Spain and the eurozone is that every investor who can do basic math knows that the expansion of the euro rescue fund agreed to on Friday isn't enough to meet current commitments and rescue Spain if the country needs a Greek-style restructuring or even an Ireland-style bank rescue. Spain's tough, tough budget for 2012 announced on Friday, with 27 billion euros ($35.9 billion) of additional spending cuts and tax increases, won't deliver the 5.3% of GDP budget deficit for 2012 that Spain has promised if the nation, along with the rest of the eurozone, sinks into recession.
How do we know that? Two "secret" reports by officials in the European Union, leaked to news organizations after being distributed to the finance ministers on Friday, say so. Despite 1 trillion euros ($1.3 trillion) in loans from the European Central Bank to European banks, "contagion may . . . re-emerge at very short notice," says one of the reports. The second report says very bluntly, "The euro crisis is not over."
Some very big money has started to react to that rather pessimistic scenario. Norway's sovereign wealth fund, which owns a whopping 2% of all European stocks, has recommended cutting its exposure to Europe to 40% in bonds (from 60%) and 40% in stocks (from 50%). The move has to be approved by the Norwegian government, probably in early summer, before the fund can lighten up its European positions in favor of increased investment in the United States and emerging markets. (Given increased cash flows into the sovereign wealth fund from higher oil prices, fund managers say they will be able to rebalance the fund without significant selling of existing assets.)
More on MoneyShow.com:
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Well, Willow... the voting public actually needs to do something different - like not vote for candidates of the two major parties.
The two parties are the problem, not any one or any number of the politicians (since they belong to the parties).
The two parties have formed a symbiotic relationship wherein they simply take turns being the parasite.
There is no reason for them to do anything differently as we continue to vote for them.
You want them to change?
Change THEM... and, as I said, that does not mean simply this time vote for the opposite party you did last time (as most people mainly do). This time...
... do something really different... and make a real change!
It's all up to you. If you want something different, YOU do something different.
Otherwise, you're just a part of the problem.
Prediction for the day............
After the phenomenal run-up we've had in the first Quarter, stocks do in fact close lower for the day.....maybe close to triple digits on the DJ.
And then, Anthony Mirhardawi(sp) will come crawling out from under his rock, fully armed with his glorious charts, to inform the great unwashed (us) that this REALLY IS the time when stocks are going to tank out. Anthony, your absence has not gone un-noticed. You lose credibility when you head for the hills every time the market rallies.
Minimum wage earners can take the bus. Oil will continue to rise; Europe will continue to degrade; The USis stll the safest economy in the world.
Jubak, I watched CNBC today and none of this was mentioned. Just positive stock market love with a hint of small correction coming because we are overdue for one. Why do you always reach for a big ol' slice of doom and gloom whenever the market outperforms? I mean you do this every time!! I bet you write something negative on Friday too when the jobs report number is great. Sorry, Jubak, but despite all of this President Obama is still going to win re-election by a landslide and the stock market will be significantly higher by 2013 because of his policy of pulling us back from the brink of a Bush depression.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
[BRIEFING.COM] The major averages continue trading near their flat lines with the S&P 500 up a fraction of a point. Earlier, we speculated that today's session could produce a volume total to rival Monday's lowest total of the year (482 million) and that remains likely considering only 129 million shares have changed hands so far at the NYSE floor.
Although equities have not moved much, there has been some activity in the foreign exchange market. Specifically, the euro/dollar pair ... More
More Market News
|There’s a problem getting this information right now. Please try again later.|
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'