Why is Google hoarding cash?
Both Apple and Microsoft are returning buckets of money to investors via their dividend programs.
Compared to the panoply of problems companies could face, stockpiling too much cash is perhaps the least troublesome. But it is trouble, nevertheless.
Don't get us wrong, corporations are designed to make money, and when a company spews giant plumes of cash -- like Apple (AAPL) has over the last few years -- it's usually a much better indicator that things are going well than many of the mushy metrics in a quarterly financial statement.
The problems start when managers decide to keep that money in the corporate coffers and not return it to the people it belongs to: the shareholders.
That's been the consensus for decades among scholars of agency theory, a branch of economics that studies the relationship between corporations and the managers that run them. In theory, corporations exist to enrich shareholders. But in practice, managers are subject to incentives that don't necessarily align with those of shareholders.
Cash piles are a textbook example. CEOs tend to want to keep cash under their control -- it gives them flexibility and puts them in a strong position to make growth-based investments. Often this doesn't really work out well for shareholders. As the Wall Street Journal's Jason Zweig wrote a while back:
Excess cash can goad chief executives into making impulsive acquisitions at high prices, splurging on palatial headquarters or overfunding underwhelming projects. In fact, academic research shows that companies with the highest levels of cash go on to become less profitable in the long term; one recent study found that high-cash firms earn future profit margins 1.5 percentage points lower than those that carry the least cash.
So, the question is: What companies could be at risk of such dynamics? Not too long ago, Moody's cobbled together a list of the largest cash holdings among U.S. nonfinancial companies at the end of 2012. (See full list at Quartz, which shows Apple, Microsoft and Google in the top three spots. Microsoft owns and publishes Top Stocks, an MSN Money site.)
Both Apple and Microsoft (MSFT) are handing buckets of money back to investors via their dividend programs (SeekingAlpha). That leaves Google (GOOG) as the outlier. The search giant hasn't paid a dividend since its 2004 IPO. Now, don't get us wrong. Google is a tremendous company. Earnings have been good. Shares are up 25% so far this year (BGR). But in the context of agency theory, Google's forays into wearable computing, driverless cars and efforts to wire all of Kansas City, Mo. (SeekingAlpha) look somewhat scattered.
And if Google skirts dividends for too long, activist investors are sure to start agitating for shareholder payouts. Just look at what David Einhorn did to push Apple to create a new class of preferred stock.
Click here to sign up for the Quartz Daily Brief and start your day with the latest intelligence on the new global economy.
More from Quartz
- Bad omen: Harvard graduates are going back into finance
- Under austerity Italians are scrapping cars for bike
- Jack Kerouac inspired the new blogging platform Ghost, but will it inspire you?
MSN Money on Twitter and Facebook
MORE ON MSN MONEY
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.