Will NRA's call to arms have lasting impact?
The pro-gun lobby suggests placing armed security guards in every American school. The idea was dismissed by many, however, and didn't seem to gain much policital support.
But what will the group's call mean? Will it have any impact beyond a day of heated debate? Is this a fundamental, significant moment in America's complicated relationship with guns or a throwaway grab for headlines?
Investors in gun stocks seemed underwhelmed. The share price for Sturm Ruger (RGR) barely budged and closed Friday down 0.4%. Smith and Wesson (SWHC) shares closed down 1.9%.
The country has seen a week of intense focus on gun control since 20-year-old Adam Lanza walked into a Connecticut elementary school on Dec. 14 and killed 20 children and six educators. America has struggled to understand the attack, to figure out what may have motivated Lanza, who also killed his mother and himself.
The NRA's top lobbyist, Wayne LaPierre, said guns were not to blame. He did blame the media, video games, movies and music videos. He described a "race to the bottom" in which companies compete to be more shocking and offensive. Violent films, he added, were "the filthiest form of pornography."
LaPierre suggested placing armed security guards in every American school. The gun-free zone in place in many schools "tells every killer that schools are the safest place" for mass shootings, he added.
He didn't specify how the program would be paid for, how guards would be trained, what procedures would be in place or how the scenario would be any different from Columbine High School, which had an armed guard when two gunmen killed numerous students in 1999, or Virginia Tech, which had its own armed police force when a student went on a deadly rampage in 2007.
His ideas didn't appear to address whether high-capacity assault weapons should be legal.
LaPierre's suggestions run counter to renewed calls for more gun control and stricter background checks since the shootings. President Obama has appointed Vice President Joe Biden to run a task force on the issue and deliver proposals by next month.
The NRA's highly anticipated announcement was quickly criticized from many sides. New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg said LaPierre's ideas were "a shameful evasion of the crisis facing our country."
There weren't many who vocally supported LaPierre's plan. Even on the conservative website The Corner, run by the National Review, commenters were far more critical of the proposal than they were supportive. "Any sort of policy that's based on extremely rare, isolated incidents is almost guaranteed to do more unintended harm than good, wrote one. "That goes for both the anti-gun and the pro-gun crowd trying to wave the bloody shirt."
More from Money Now
Everyone has there right to their opinion, so, why not have one - three individuals per school that are licensed & trained to carry a firearm with a high enough capacity clip to stop an individual who would think about doing harm to any children. Sometimes, people knowing, that if they try to harm anyone and people are willing to stop them with force, they turn out to be the true cowards they really are and probably may think twice about hurting innocent people. Your politicians can give Billions to foreign goverments that seem to lose most of the money somehow, but, lack the muster to provide phyiscal protection with security at schools and will tell you they can not find the money, passing laws will not protect our children. These cowardly indididuals that do these unspeakable acts only unstand force with force! Hey current administration, put all of are veterans that are trained with firearms and out of work and give them a job protecting our schools. Now that is a common sense approach to a on going problem and not all the hype you politicians and media spin.
Some fail to realize or remember that the gunman took his own life. All the laws in the world against LAW ABIDING CITIZENS will not prevent a PSYCHOPATH from doing what he did or anyone like him doing what they want. Laws were the last thing on his mind. These people exist all over the world and I have RIGHT to be able to defend myself with whatever means are at my disposal.
We send our troops overseas to fight an enemy and expect our soldiers to fight by the rules against people that don't know the meaning of the word. But the GOVERNMENT ties their hands and forces them to get SLAUGHTERED for the sake of doing it by the book.
I will not be defenseless against people who do not care about laws or wether they live or die.
Tie your own hands and leave mine the HELL ALONE. SURVIVAL IS NOT PRETTY SOMETIMES!!!!!!!
I taught for 30 years. I have a concealed carry permit. I never miss the kill zone in practice.
I felt helpless while in the classroom without my pistol, knowing that I would at least have had a decent probability of stopping an attacker.
My husband also taught and felt the same way.
Let well trained teachers carry.
I would be scared to death of missing a perp and killing a bystander in most stress situations.
I'm more afraid of a poorly trained civilian than running into a criminal, especially since I live in Arizona where you must own guns or relinquish your gonads.
The school I went to almost 40 yr ago had an armed policeman on duty in our halls. I think it is a very good idea. I don't think teachers should pack guns. They should teach. I do not think they should have to deal with security. People who commit these unspeakable acts are obviously not mentally right. Most are intelligent enough to know where they will meet the least resistance, soft targets. Stop the foreign aid and keep the money at home to be spent at home.
Violating the constitution is not the answer. Security and Mental health care. That is a real solution.
This reminds me of the idiots that want more prisons but don`t want to pay
Being pro life doesn't mean you love guns (an inanimate object) or war. However it is the supporters of the second amendment that allow the citizens of America to remain free. The people that want to disarm the public are merely pawns of those that want to end our freedom. The democracy cannot be sustained if our citizens cannot defend themselves. Our enemies will not use weapons of mass destruction for fear they will damage the resources they covet.
The only thing that stops a bad person with a gun is a good person with a gun. If all guns are made illegal that will be a little like making methamphetamines and heroin illegal.
Especially since they are the same people who would have DEMANDED the choice to kill every one of them six or seven years ago, in the womb.
What would happen if indeed, as suggested by many, we start arming teachers/school administrators with guns so that they could combat the killers of our innocent. Apparently, as the logic goes, these killers would no longer enter schools where they would be killed before they could do their harm. Success!
But then I suspect that these criminals - whether in touch with reality or not - would look for other sites to make their horrific entrance. They could, for example, look for places where children gather together. Children are always going on field trips, often to museums. So I suspect that the evil ones will eventually show up at such places. So we now arm the museum personnel. Success at last - no more museum shootings.
But then there are the parks with playgrounds. How hard would it be for the evil doer to use his semi-automatic to kill many, and then him/her self. So we arm the playgrounds. Let’s no longer speak of success - not yet.
There are the sports venues where children play hockey, or soccer, or basketball or any myriad of athletic games. Arm the parents, coaches - make the water boy the gun boy.
And of course there are those indoor playgrounds at fast food restaurants. We surely can arm the manager, or a couple of the minimum paid workers.
Have we covered everything? Have we armed everyone yet?
Of course we could regulate the kind of guns our society is allowed to buy. But then,
there goes freedom.
I cherish my freedom, along with the civilian police state I now so comfortably live in.
(Did I mention hospitals? Day care centers? Pediatrician offices? Churches?........)
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
More Market News
The stock rises 9% after the company reveals strong second-quarter results.
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'