Shopper files suit over 'stealing' free samples
A Minnesota man says Supervalu violated his civil rights when he was forcibly arrested for taking more than a pound of complimentary deli meat.
The first dictionary definition of "sample" is "a small part of anything or one of a number, intended to show the quality, style, or nature of the whole; specimen." Boulder, Colo., jam-rock band The Samples took their name from the free bites they subsisted on at a nearby King Soopers grocery store.
Minnesota shopper Erwin Lingitz feels his interpretation of "sample" falls somewhere between the two. It's the crux of a lawsuit he has filed against supermarket chain Supervalu (SVU) alleging that it violated his civil rights by using force to arrest him on grounds he was stealing deli meat samples.
Lingitz, a retiree, has sued the chain and several individuals in a claim filed last month, alleging store security and, later, sheriff's officers had no right to forcibly eject him in 2010, given the nature of the food he was consuming. As Lingitz's wife Frankie told The Pioneer Press, "You can't arrest someone for thievery if it is free."
Point made, but Supervalu counters that the more than a pound of meat Lingitz took from Cub Foods, a Supervalu subsidiary, is tough to construe as a "sample" under all but the most literal senses of the word.
"A reasonable person would not fill two produce bags with 1.4 pounds of deli meat samples to take out of the store," Supervalu spokesman Mike Siemienas told the Pioneer Press. "The plaintiff violated societal norms and common customer understanding regarding free sample practices."
It's that "societal norms" bit that's causing Supervalu and the other plaintiffs no shortage of grief as this case unfolds. Supervalu says store managers had warned Lingitz earlier that he was taking too many samples, alleging in their reply to the lawsuit that Lingitz had filled produce bags with up to 20 cookies from the "kids cookie club tray."
After Lingitz was kicked out of the store and handcuffed during the meat sample incident, Supervalu attorney Robyn Johnson says, Lingitz's pockets were stuffed with "14-16 packets of soy sauce along with one plastic produce bag containing 0.61 pounds for (sic) summer sausage and another plastic produce bag containing 0.85 pounds of beef stick."
Does all of that fall beyond "societal norms"? Perhaps. But Lingitz's attorney, Robert Gardner, says the force that the security guard and deputies allegedly used to subdue 68-year-old Lingitz wasn't quite normal either. Photos included with the lawsuit, taken at a hospital before Lingitz was booked into jail, show him with two black eyes, a slash across the bridge of his nose and cuts and bruises.
Lingitz was charged with shoplifting, disorderly conduct and interfering with a peace officer. The charges were all misdemeanors, and he pleaded not guilty. Lingitz completed a year's unsupervised probation, and a judge dismissed the charges last March.
The only way a person like this will learn is if you make an example out of them. We would all be better off if frivolous law suites like this were punishable… jail or the nuthouse.
We had a guy like this who'd come in every day and ASK clerks for samples (was store policy to give samples off the self) He'd basicly get a meal everytime he came, whole oranges, cup of hot soup and slice of cheese cake.
Out in the parking lot was a brand new Honda Accord. He was a cheap A** thief nothing more.
The Store Director told employees to avoid him or hide in the back to keep him from asking.
Since Robert Gardner (Lingitz's lawyer) is imbecile loser who cant make any money as a attorney taking on reasonable litigation cases, he decided to ambulance chase Lingitz, offering to sue SuperValu so Gardner can get a retainer on any settlement money.
He gets some great publicity as a nincompoop lawyer who will take any case available because he is way too stupid to have a productive job.
well Erwin Lingitz feels like since he is complete idiot and a moron that he should try to find a lawyer who is an imbecile so the two of them can get some money from Supervalu.
Erwin Lingitz is an idiot nincompoop and does not have as much money as he desires. so he wants some money from Supervalu,
what kind of a story is this ????
When I worked in grocery store you would see shoppers get a bag of grapes eat half of them while shopping. when they were weighed he did not have much left cause he ate half of them.
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
Sales of collectible automobiles hit an all-time record this year, leading some to speculate that soaring prices could lead to a huge deal.
- Bah, humbug! New Christmas tree tax proposed
- Should you get a store credit card?
- The best credit cards of 2013
- Can a new chief exec keep GM on course?
- 'Tips for Jesus' big spender unmasked?
- Chinese investors are buying up Detroit
- Mega Millions jackpot hits $344 million
- 5 reasons to think twice about a balance transfer card
- Will I have to pay taxes because of a foreclosed home?
[BRIEFING.COM] S&P futures vs fair value: -3.60. Nasdaq futures vs fair value: -1.00. The S&P 500 futures trade lower by 0.1%.
The latest weekly initial jobless claims count totaled 368,000, which was higher than the 315,000 that had been expected by the Briefing.com consensus. Today's tally was above the revised prior week count of 300,000. As for continuing claims, they rose to 2.791 million from 2.751 million.
November retail sales ticked up 0.7% while the ... More
More Market News
The stock fell Wednesday with the news that the company missed on both earnings and revenue in its most recent quarter.