Whole Foods grilled over English-only policy
The grocer denies a report that 2 workers claim they were suspended for speaking Spanish.
Whole Foods (WFM) claims something got lost in translation.
Two workers at a New Mexico store say that they were suspended for speaking Spanish and that a manager told them only English is allowed during work hours, The Associated Press reports.
That has led to outrage from some Twitter users. One wrote, "Hey @WholeFoods we are good enough to slave in the fields to get your food, but can't speak Spanish during work?"
Some consumers are threatening to boycott the grocery chain, known for organic produce and free-range eggs.
Now Whole Foods says the incident was a misunderstanding and the company doesn't have a policy against speaking foreign languages. Nevertheless, the high-end grocer said it does have a policy that English is its default language for "consistent communication, inclusion, and especially for safety and emergency situations." The company issued the statement in both English and Spanish.
The issue is a touchy one in the workplace. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission sued the Salvation Army in 2007 over its requirement that workers in a Massachusetts office speak only English. Such conflicts may be more common as more people speak languages other than English at home. The nation gained 24.4 million Spanish speakers from 1980 to 2009.
The EEOC says English-only policies "will rarely be justified," although there are circumstances in which a rule may be necessary, such as to communicate emergencies or other situations in which safety is at risk.
Worker Bryan Baldizan told the AP that he and a female worker were suspended for a day after they wrote a complaint letter after a meeting in which they were told Spanish wasn't allowed during work hours.
"I couldn't believe it," he said. "All we did was say we didn't believe the policy was fair. We only talk Spanish to each other about personal stuff, not work."
As outrage mounts over the report, it has sent Whole Foods deep into crisis mode. The grocery chain said the workers were suspended for "rude and disrespectful behavior." Whatever happened, one thing seems certain: Whole Foods has a big mess on its hands.
Follow Aimee Picchi on Twitter at @aimeepicchi.
There's more to this story than the employees just speaking Spanish. My guess is they were talking smack about the customers and someone who speaks Spanish knew what they were saying.
The only reason to change languages around people is to say something you don't want them to "hear". Based on the quote from one of the suspended worker's, his English is excellent. This isn't about some kind of language barrier or lack of fairness.
Okay, I've heard two versions on this story in articles (this one and an NBC News one). The other version said they got suspended for a written (or emailed) complaint about the language policy. If that is true, I don't think that's fair. If in fact they were penalized for speaking Spanish on the job (and not for the purpose of aiding a Spanish-speaking customer which is allowed in Whole Foods' policy, evidently), well that is an internal policy matter.
I am not a fan of Whole Foods. I think they are over-priced and elitist (I never feel comfortable in there and I make enough money that I could shop there if I wanted to), but I don't oppose this policy or think it is racist. It's not "oppressing someone's culture" to ask them to speak in a language that their co-workers, management, and customers can all understand. Why is it so outrageous to expect people to speak or understand English in an American workplace?
Lots of people are knee-jerking to "Whole Foods hates Mexicans" which is BS in my opinion. Whole Foods loves money. They don't care whose money it is as long as they get it.
They want all their staff to speak a common language while on the job so everybody knows what is being said. What if staff members are speaking another language and they say something insulting or inappropriate that is overheard by a customer? That's what this policy is really about.
If we moved to another country to live and work, we would be expected to learn their language to communicate effectively and be a functioning part of their society. So why does everyone throw a fit when we expect people to use English in America? It is our primarily language, so learn it and use it when in a professional setting. I'm not saying you need to banish your other language and assimilate yourself to the point of losing your heritage, but learn and use the primary language of country in which you live. I think everyone just likes to piss and moan and complain about things.
Why are people stereotyped as immigrants for speaking Spanish?
For us New Mexicans it is a local courtesy to speak Spanish in New Mexico because it’s part of our tradition and cultural identity. We have been speaking Spanish here for generations.
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
The good news: Bad weather means fewer drivers on the road, and they're going slower than usual. The bad news: It's still dangerous.
- 8 questions to ask before Mom and Dad move in
- High deductibles fuel new worries of Obamacare sticker shock
- How to use your credit card to donate to charity
- Try this instead of raising the minimum wage
- People left $500,000 in coins at airports last year
- How your driving can affect your credit
- Obamacare projected to cost hundreds of billions less
- November jobs report: Winners and losers
- Student loan debt climbs for 5th year in a row
More Market News
The photo-sharing site only has 10 employees, and it may be up for grabs.