10/31/2011 4:21 PM ET|
Why retiring in Canada can be better
The US and its northern neighbor offer a similar range of services to retirees, whether it's tax-advantaged investment plans or social insurance programs. But major differences exist.
Planning for retirement involves a wide range of considerations, from determining the ideal types of accounts and investments to be included in a retirement plan to budgeting for future vacation traveling. Another essential consideration is your desired retirement destination. While weather and entertainment facilities are definitely worth considering, the types of financial and health care incentives that governments provide to their retirees also carry significant weight.
American and Canadian governments provide many of the same types of services to those planning for retirement. Yet there are subtle differences between the two countries that are worth noting.
RRSP vs. traditional IRA
The Canadian government offers several unique alternatives that individuals can take advantage of to avoid paying excessive taxes. Registered Retirement Savings Plans allow investors to receive a tax deduction on their yearly contributions, and the tax-efficient income growth raises the benefits of compounded returns. Contributions can be made until the age of 71, and the government sets maximum limits on the amount of funds that can be placed into an RRSP account. Withdrawals can occur at any time but are classified as taxable income, which becomes subject to withholding taxes. In the year in which the taxpayer turns 71, the RRSP must be either cashed out or rolled over into either an annuity or a Registered Retirement Income Fund.
For American taxpayers, a traditional IRA is structured to provide the same sorts of benefits -- contributions are tax-deductible and capital gains are tax-deferred until distributions from the account are made. Age stipulations are similar; investors can contribute to their traditional IRA until they reach 70½, at which point mandatory distributions are required.
In contrast to the rules for an RRSP account, which has a maximum contribution just over $20,000, the Internal Revenue Service states that "the maximum contribution that can be made to a traditional or Roth IRA is the smaller of $5,000 or the amount of your taxable compensation for the taxable year." Although RRSPs allow for greater contributions, wealthy Canadians tend to pay more taxes than their southern neighbors.
TFSA vs. Roth IRA
Canada's Tax-Free Savings Account is fairly similar to Roth IRAs in the U.S. Both of these retirement-focused vehicles are commonly known as tax-exempt accounts, meaning that they are funded with after-tax money and provide tax-free growth, and funds can be withdrawn without taxation. TFSAs allow for long-term retirement planning, as Canadian residents over 18 can contribute $5,000 annually.
On the other hand, almost anyone can contribute to a Roth IRA regardless of age. More important, maximum contributions are also $5,000 ($6,000 for those over 50). Another similarity with these accounts, one that differentiates them from tax-deferred plans, is that there is no limit on when you must stop contributions and begin withdrawing money.
TFSAs offer two significant advantages over the American alternative. Young Canadians saving for retirement are able to carry over their allowed contributions to future years, while such an option is not available with Roth IRAs. For example, if a 35-year-old Canadian taxpayer is unable to contribute $5,000 into his account, next year the total allowable amount accumulates to $10,000.
Secondly, distributions from Roth IRAs must be classified as "qualified" to get the preferential tax treatment. Qualified distributions are those made after the account has been open for five years and the taxpayer is either disabled or is over 59½. Canada's TFSAs offer more flexibility, since the money can be withdrawn at any time without a tax penalty. (Should you convert to a Roth IRA? Check MSN Money's calculator to find out.)
Old Age Security vs. Social Security
America's Social Security system is remarkably different from Canada's Old Age Security programs. (Although Canada also has retirement savings plans, such as the Canadian Pension Plan, they will not be compared with Social Security in this article.) Financed by Canadian tax dollars, OAS provides benefits to eligible citizens 65 and older. There are complex rules to determine the amount of the pension payment, but typically a person who has lived in Canada for 40 years, after turning 18, is qualified to receive the full payment of $533.70 per month at age 65.
Additionally, Guaranteed Income Supplements ($732.65) and Allowances ($1,013.54) are provided annually for pensioners making less than $29,904 and $38,784, respectively. OAS benefits are considered taxable income and carry certain payback provisions for high-income earners.
Social Security, on the other hand, does not focus exclusively on providing retirement benefits and includes additional benefits such as disability income. Social Security income tax issues are slightly more complex and depend on such factors as the recipient's marital status and whether income was generated from other sources. (Information provided in IRS Form SSA-1099 will determine the tax rate for the benefit.) Individuals are eligible to receive partial benefits upon turning 62 and full benefits ($2,346 per month as of 2011) once they are 67.
Eligibility is determined through a credit system whereby qualified recipients must obtain a minimum of 40 credits, and they can earn additional credits to increase their payments by delaying initial benefit payments. Generally, Canada's retirement programs are considered more secure, as there are concerns that the U.S. will eventually deplete its Social Security funds.
Quality of life
Both Canada and America typically rank near the top of the United Nations' Human Development Index, which uses such factors as life expectancy, education and standard of living. However, Canadian retirees find life after work to be much less stressful, as fears about running out of money are not as prevalent. As a result, American retirees more often tend to find alternative sources to supplement their retirement incomes.
The major benefit for Canadian retirees is the publicly funded health care system, which provides essential health services to its residents. America's private health care system, on the other hand, puts a much greater financial burden on retirees. A study by the Employee Benefits Research Institute estimates that a 65-year-old couple without employer health coverage will require approximately $700,000 to comfortably cover out-of-pocket medical expenses not paid by Medicare.
Regardless of the retirement destination, the same basic rules apply to both countries. Do not wait until age 50 to begin planning, focus on safe investments, save a substantial portion of your monthly income, build an emergency fund, and use the financial plans available for tax-efficient retirement investing.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Average wait for an MRI, and thats if its not urgent, is typically a month in most places in Canada. As I said, thats if its not urgent. You get much faster service, if it is urgent. For non-urgent care, there has to be wait lists, thats how we keep it cheap!!!!! We dont have private insurance, because we dont need it. We have government NON-PROFIT insurance. No middle men sucking millions off the sickness of others up here. The supplemental insurance, is to cover the few things the government insurance doesnt cover. Like medications that arent covered, private rooms all to yourself, etc. On the other hand, Canada is listed as one of the best for overall care. Much higher than the U.S.. And as a result, has a higher life expectancy statistic, and lower infant mortality rate than the U.S. does. So they are obviously doing something right. Oh, and nobody goes bankrupt because of a family illness either.
I wouldnt give up our Healthcare system, for the U.S. system, if you paid me. You Americans should thank your lucky stars, if you manage to get a system that's even remotely like what Canada has. And you wont find many Canadians who would disagree with that either.
My wife and I are retired, and have lived in RV parks in Arizona for a number of years. We have had many canadian neighbors down for the winter. We found them to be the very best neighbors and friendliest
people. In discussing the economy, health, and all subjects, they never gave us a negative response. When we asked the proverbial question "Would you want to live in the United States?" They answered with a very polite, "NO THANK YOU" Need I say more????????
All of Canada's major cities are mostly in the south, close to the border. So the weather is the same, for the most part, as the northern U.S., for most Candians. So, unless you choose to live way up north where it is really cold, the weather in Canada isnt much different than the northern U.S. Its barely a 100 miles between Seattle and Vancouver, or Toronto and Buffalo.
Taxes are higher.. But unlike the U.S, the money is actually spent on Canadians. Their safety net is second to very few. I think Sweden is the only one thats better. They have many non-profit government run businesses that give HUGE savings. Especially in the insurance field. No carpet baggers up here!
The best thing about Canada, is the low population. Only 30 million. Theres still room to breath up here.
I am proud to be a Canadian, born and raised! We may have to pay higher taxes but I'm guaranteed all the amenities that come from those taxes. I don't have to worry about dying in a hospital doorway because I don't have insurance. No one has died sitting in a waiting room while the health care professionals kept walking bye them. We don't think ourselves SUPERIOR to the rest of the world or feel a sense of ENTITLEMENT when we are visiting abroad. Canadians are not looked at seethingly because of where we come from. We help those in need when the occassion calls for it. There is something wrong with a country's people when they disrespect their president with name calling and such goings on. Face it Americans.....you have a black president!! Everytime you try something unethical it comes back to bite you all big time in your butts. Unfortunately it is the innocent people who suffer in your country. Why is there OCCUPY this place and that (started in USA) and has gained momentum all over the world? It's because as a nation your people and the rest of the world have had enough of your greed, arrogance and uncaring attituedes. Regardless of how most of you Americans think of Canada; I feel safe, healthy, able to eat fruits and veggies regularly and still able to smile at everyone I meet without judging them on their race, creed or religion! You get back what you put out in the Universe.
Who are you kidding? The prices and taxes will break you in no time, not to mention the weather!
Just the opposite. Because the government gives back far more, even though taxes and prices are higher, you still come up ahead. And fact is, a LOT of that savings is via significantly lower healthcare costs.
What the rest of the world has figured out: Its better to pay slighty higher taxes and get vital services provided at cost, rather then pay lower taxes and pay into a for-profit system.
In the current economic environment, I am not sure why any more of these lame articles about retirement even keep being written and published. You folks and I know that the middle class fools, such as myself, have worked like dogs and saved all their lives and they will still be working till the day they fall over dead at their desks!
If I figure out how to keep a couple dollars, either the taxes go up somehow and I pay it to Uncle Sam, or the Wall Street gang figures out how to suck it out of my 401k.
The "financial crisis" that we are all so eager to forget about took a lot of people's retirement savings back to the level it was 10 years ago (and some farther back than that).
Save your money, learn to grow vegetables, can and freeze food. Most of us lost the skills that our grandparents had to survive during the great depression.
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Quotes are real-time for NASDAQ, NYSE and AMEX. See delay times for other exchanges.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Thomson Reuters (click for restrictions). Real-time quotes provided by BATS Exchange. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Interactive Data Real-Time Services. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by SIX Financial Information.
RECENT ARTICLES ON RETIREMENT
A single mom who says she was forced to accept a fee-heavy 'payroll card' instead of a check or direct deposit is taking a McDonald's franchise to court.