Using Craigslist to make a living

Some people snap up the free or cheap good stuff and resell it at a profit. You have to understand the system to make it work.

By MSN Money Partner Aug 22, 2011 8:59AM

This post comes from J.D. Roth at partner blog Get Rich Slowly.


I recently drove from Portland, Ore.,  to Eugene to meet Jacob from Early Retirement Extreme. He was on a mini road trip from the Bay Area, scouting Oregon for a place to live. Along with a few other ERE readers, I joined Jacob for a meet-up.


For those who don't recall, Jacob is a theoretical physicist who applied his analytical mind to the problem of retirement. He realized that if he saved 75% of his net income for just five years, he could actually retire at age 30. Like the couple Robert Brokamp interviewed for Get Rich Slowly recently, Jacob set this as a goal and made it happen. (To learn more about Jacob and his philosophy, check out my review of his book.)


Two paths to the same destination
It was fun to chat with Jacob in person. I feel like he and I are taking two paths to the same destination. We both want financial independence, but we're using different methods to achieve it. Jacob focuses on cutting costs, and I focus on making money. To be fair, he's well aware that increased income can accelerate savings, and I'm a vocal advocate of thrift. But when it comes down to it, Jacob's focus is frugality and mine is increased earning. (Are you saving enough for retirement? Try MSN Money's calculator.)


Naturally, the conversation centered on how Jacob and his readers keep costs low. We talked about building things, about repairing things, and about making things last. We talked about buying used things at thrift stores and off the Internet. Eventually the conversation turned to the wonders of Craigslist. "You can find anything there," Jacob said. We shared our best finds.


It was here that the discussion took an interesting twist. "You know," said a fellow named Ryan, "I make my living on Craigslist now."


"What do you mean?" Jacob asked.


"Well, I buy things on Craigslist, then I sell them for a profit."


"You sell them on Craigslist?" I asked.


"Sure," he said.


"Craigslist arbitrage?" I asked. I hadn't heard the details, and already I was in awe. I knew I had to hear more about how Ryan makes money.


You see, one of the seeds for this very site was my own experience with arbitrage, the art of taking advantage of price anomalies to make a profit. If you pick up some old books for five bucks on eBay and then resell them on eBay for 50, you're practicing arbitrage. Clear as mud? Let met explain how I learned about arbitrage.


Playing games
Back in 2005, I wasted much of my time playing World of Warcraft, an online role-playing game. I liked to slay dragons and fight zombies as much as the next guy, but what I really enjoyed was shopping at the in-game auction house. When you had stuff you didn't want, you could sell it to other players through auctions.


Because the game world was large enough, a stable economy developed. Certain items generally sold for certain prices.


For instance, you might be able to buy a stack of medium leather for 10 silver pieces. (I can't recall exactly how much anything cost, so my examples use arbitrary numbers.) But sometimes, somebody would sell medium leather for five silver pieces. It was simple enough to buy the leather and then relist it at the auction hall immediately, netting a profit of five silver pieces.


But buying and selling stacks of leather (which could be used in-game to make pouches, bags and armor) was small potatoes. Eventually I started buying weapons and magic items. The Sword of Ultimate Slaying might normally sell for 100 gold pieces, but sometimes you might spot it selling for 50. I'd snap it up and then resell it for more. Even if it sold for 70 gold, I'd have made a big profit for very little effort.


I was practicing arbitrage. And soon my lowly little wizard had a fortune of hundreds of gold pieces.


"Man," I thought. "Too bad I can't do this in real life."


It turns out you can do this in real life. That's what Ryan was describing at Jacob's meet-up.


Trivia: No joke -- my experience with buying and selling stuff was one of the prime reasons I decided to start Get Rich Slowly. The connection isn't obvious (not even to me), but it's there.


Buy low, sell high
Ryan explained that he's a licensed general contractor, and has done plenty of construction work. But somewhere along the way he discovered he could make a living through buying and selling on Craigslist. I asked him to give me more details.


"You have to know how the system works," Ryan said. "The good stuff sells instantly. Craigslist updates the listings every 10 minutes. You have seconds to reply to get the good stuff, the stuff that's cheap. If a listing is more than a few minutes old, it's not a bargain." It might be fairly priced, but it's not worth buying to resell.


"But how do you respond quickly?" I asked. "By phone?"


"I have automatic scripts set up on my computer," he explained. "When I see a listing I want, I click a button in my browser. This automatically creates an email, and I add just a few new notes and send it. It takes very little time." Plus, he admits that he's handy with his telephone.


"I'm not the only one doing this. If I were, it'd be easy. There are others out there snapping up the bargains too."


"What do you buy and sell?" someone asked.


"I'll buy anything if it's a bargain. Appliances are awesome," he told us. "A used washer or dryer is easily worth $50. Often $100. If I can get it for free -- and often I can -- that's pure profit." It helps that Ryan has connections in the construction industry. When he finds something, he knows who to call. Post continues after video.

"But it doesn't really matter," he said. "I buy what I know and sell what I know. If you wanted to do this, that's what you'd do too." In other words, if I wanted to do Craigslist arbitrage, I'd try to buy and sell comic books or computers.


"And you really make a living at this?" I asked.


"Yep," he said. I suspect it doesn't hurt that he's bought into Jacob's early retirement philosophy; I'll bet Ryan keeps his costs low, which would allow him to sustain his family on a lower income than he might otherwise need.


Ryan's story is great. I love finding folks who've developed creative ways to earn money, and this one was new to me. For me, the best parts of his story were the individual anecdotes he told about great deals he'd made. (Or, in one case, failed to make.) I'd actually like to hear more about how he does it. (If you want to know more, let me know; I'll bet we could get him to write a guest post!)


You can read more about Craigslist arbitrage at Dane Jensen's blog.


More on Get Rich Slowly and MSN Money:


Aug 24, 2011 10:56AM

I've seen these folks on Craigslist. They are actually now dealers and advertise on owners for sale sites. This is annoying and fraud if you ask me. There are specific places for dealers, services, etc however, they ignore the rules and post in for sale by owner. Car dealers, furniture dealers, repair places they are all doing it and it is pathetic that they have to muck up the site with all their crap and over posting on the sites by owner. Craigslist is only policed by users and unless the users wise up and correct the post it will only get worse by the day.

Aug 24, 2011 4:26PM
I can't believe people are actually against this.

If it works for him, that's great. Fraud? Your kidding right? You don't have to buy it. This is called making money. I know its a large concept for some people, and it can be very complicated. But its not like he's ruining peoples lives by taking washing machines that are free and selling them for 50-100$. 

And yes boater, there is time involved. Hence that's HOW HE MAKES HIS LIVING. 40, 50, 60, maybe even more hours a week. I'm sure it takes a lot of time. But whatever works for him is great. 

Aug 23, 2011 4:06PM
Kind of lame story....  20 paragraphs of text to get to the bottom line which is buy low - sell high.   Using one example in the story but scale it to be enough to make a very modest living, one would have to get 4 free washing machines every single day and sell every one for $50... not including any costs such as delivery or sales that are a bust, or taxes, etc.   And of  course most people want to  come see that washer before they pony up their half C note so there is lots of  time involved as well as unsavory people coming over to your  house to check out the merchandise.
Aug 26, 2011 1:19PM

Let's take it one step further, In Portland, OR there is a website called Freecycle where you give away things you don't need for free and get things you need for free.  I have seen some people take things on Freecycle and then sell things on Craigs list.

Again this takes time and effort and maybe a small investment but it recycles many things that might otherwise get dumped into our landfills.

Nov 18, 2013 4:36PM
It is very possible to make a living from Craigslist
I am currently doing it and have documented my experience and techniques in my Ebook available at

Aug 24, 2011 12:02PM

These people are lowlifes making money off of others' plight; no better than the 'house flipper' crowd IMO.


Yeah, the washer and dryer might be worth $50, but somebody was giving it away for free, because they don't need it and there is somebody out there who can't afford $50 but needs to wash clothes.  Middle-men effectively ruined the housing market, then ebay, now they've done the same to CL.

Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.