Smart SpendingSmart Spending

Don't waste money on a warranty for those new tires

Chances are good your money will be benefitting the dealer more than helping you keep your tires in good shape.

By MSN Money Partner Jun 19, 2013 4:14PM
This post comes from Len Penzo at partner site Len Penzo dot Com.

LenPenzo logoA while back I bought four new tires for my 1997 Honda Civic. The tires came with a pro-rated 65,000-mile guarantee and were $74 each, or just under $300 for the entire set.
Man checking car tire pressure © Tetra Images/Tetra images/Getty ImagesAs the salesman was tallying up the bill he asked me if I would like to purchase the extended warranty for my brand new tires.

“And how much is that?” I sheepishly asked.

“It’s only $9.95,” came the salesman’s immediate reply.

“Is that per tire?”

“Well, yes.”

“So it’s not really $9.95, right? What you should have said is that it’s going to cost me an extra $40.”

I think I caught the salesman off-guard because he immediately tried to assure me that he wasn’t trying to pull a fast one. I nodded my head, but my raised eyebrows belied my true feelings.

That’s when the guy looked me straight in the eye and insisted that the extended warranty was “a really good deal that most people take advantage of.”

I passed on the warranty but, if what that salesman told me is true, it troubles me that there are a lot folks out there who insist on wasting their money for dubious services.

Prorated tire warranties
Almost all tires come with a pro-rated warranty from the manufacturer that typically cover only workmanship defects. Reimbursement is prorated, depending on how much tread is remaining when you make the claim. The rest comes out of your pocket.

Of course, new tires are rarely defective, but when they are, a defect usually becomes apparent soon after the tire has been purchased.

Extended tire warranties
Extended tire warranty plans are meant to cover what prorated manufacturer warranties usually don’t: replacement or repair of damaged tires and rims from road hazards like nails, pot holes, sharp debris, and other hazards. They don’t usually cover alignments, however, which are may be required if your car hits a curb, pothole or other hazard hard enough. Even so, that sounds like a pretty good idea, right?

Not really.

Here are a few reasons why you may be better off taking your chances by not paying for an extended tire warranty:

Some tires may come with free road hazard warranties. Although uncommon, some manufacturers and dealers actually offer free road hazard warranties. Ask your tire salesman to double-check and see if your tires already come with one. After all, why pay for something if it’s being offered for free?

The odds favor the dealer. If extended warranties weren’t to the dealer’s benefit, they wouldn’t be offering them. I’ve driven more than 500,000 miles in my lifetime. Over that time, I’ve driven over a nail or some other debris that has punctured my tire and caused a flat on just two occasions; that’s an incident rate of less than once every 250,000 miles. In my case, considering the new tires I bought are only expected to last 65,000 miles, it made little sense to insure them.

The cost-risk ratio is too high. Despite the low risk of tire damage due to road hazards, let’s say I did run over a nail that damaged my tire. The cost of replacing the tire is $74. Considering that I would have to pay $40 for the extended warranty, my ultimate savings would be $34. It makes little sense to spend $40 in the off-chance that I might save $34.

Smart Spending on the go: Get our app for Android or iPhone

Remember, insurance and extended warranties are supposed to protect us from high risk events and losses that we can’t afford to replace. For most car owners, a flat tire is a low-risk low-cost affair that can be easily offset by scrounging up loose change hiding under the sofa cushions.

OK, OK. You’ll probably have to raid your change jar too. But you get the drift.

More from Len Penzo dot Com:

Jun 21, 2013 9:16AM
On top of that what tires cost $70?  My dirtbike tires are more than that.  The OEM tire for my Trans Am are $300 each.  The tire for my parents HHR was $170.
Jun 21, 2013 9:14AM

So when you asked the salesman how much are the tires and he said $70 did you ASSume that was for 1 or all of them?  You knew it was for each tire. So when he said the warranty is $9.95 if you had any common sense you would have known it was for EACH TIRE!



Jun 21, 2013 10:46AM

i agree that you always have to look at the risk versus the premium paid for any kind of "insurance".  Although the cost of the warranty is only a fraction of the total cost of the 4 tires, the likelihood is that if you do have a road hazard, it will be to only 1 tire.  Therefore it does not make sense to me to pay $40 to offset a potential $70 risk.  Even if it were 2 or 3 tires that would not be too expensive to replace. 


Most of the problems I have ever had with tires is running over a nail and having a flat.  Usually a flat likely that can be patched, good as new.  My shop does that for free.


Save your money and put it in your IRA.

Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.


Smart Spending brings you the best money-saving tips from MSN Money and the rest of the Web. Join the conversation on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.