Smart SpendingSmart Spending

6 gym membership gotchas

Losing weight is a New Year's resolution staple, but your efforts to get in shape can hurt your wallet if you're not careful about your health club.

By Jan 2, 2014 2:19PM

This post comes from Bob Sullivan at partner site on MSN MoneyGetting in shape can make your bank account unhealthy.

Woman working out in a health club © Kris Hanke/Getty Images
If you are among the millions of people  whose New Year's resolution is think January is the time to commit to an exercise plan, and you are considering joining a health club, know this: Signing up for a gym membership can be just as complicated as buying a car, and it can be just as expensive, too.


Take steps now, before you sign anything, to make sure your exercise routine doesn't also mean routinely fighting over hidden fees and charges.

1. It's all about the exit strategy

It seems wrong to think about the breakup before your first date, but that's exactly what you must do with a gym. While gym membership contracts can be full of booby traps, long-term commitments, nonsensical sign-up fees, and so on, the vast majority of gym complaints come down to one thing: consumers getting charged after they quit.

First: Before you sign, make sure you have the gym’s cancellation policy in writing, and you understand it well. Often, it goes like this: You must give the gym 30 days’ notice, which generally gives the facility one extra month of your money.

That's fine, but often, gyms that are very good at signing you up are terrible at processing cancellation paperwork. So send your cancellation in writing, return receipt request. Also take the paperwork into the gym and get someone to sign it in person, if possible.

But let's take a step backward: You make life much easier on the future you-who-wants-to-cancel if you don't let the gym automatically deduct payments from your checking account, or through your debit card. Use a credit card if you must -- challenging those unauthorized charges is a bit easier than fighting an account debit. But better still: pay the health club with a check every month.  Some health clubs insist on auto-deduction, but many states now mandate that you are allowed to pay them manually. Keeping the club from directly accessing your money is the best way to avoid future breakup overcharges.

2. Assume the sales pitch is a lie

As in dating, so many things that sound good at the beginning turn sour at the end. Health club employees are usually paid on commission and often are perfectly happy to lie to you. Nothing they say matters. Only what you see in writing matters. This includes some things that might not seem obvious, such as the financial health of the club itself. Want a really good reason not to sign a 36-month contract? What if the club goes out of business, or your local club is closed? (The answer is below.)

Among the most common lies? "Treadmills are always free!"  Visit the gym you are considering on the days and times you plan to be there, and see how busy the equipment is. Even still, if the club does a serious membership drive, you might end up with long waits anyway.

Finally, it's not enough to simply get a contract. You must KEEP the contract, and know where to find it when the inevitable dispute occurs.

3. Know your state rights

Health clubs are generally regulated at the state level. If you doubt the mess that is health club memberships, simply search for “health clubs” and “state law.” The sheer volume of regulations gives you a great idea what a hornet's nest this industry is. But others' pain can benefit you. Many state laws now:

  • Create a three-day, no questions asked "regret" policy. If you are bullied into a contract, and you have second thoughts after sleeping on it, you can back out.
  • Ban lifetime contracts. Many are limited to 36 months now.
  • Create exceptions to place contracts on hold, so consumers do not have to pay temporarily. In many states, being disabled allows consumers not to pay, for example.
  • Creates special cancellation rights if the member's local gym closes, or if the member moves.

4. Are there sign-up fees?

Gym memberships are a little like cellphone purchases. They combine an arcane mix of upfront costs and ongoing costs that can really confuse the consumer. What really matters? The total amount of money you will give the club. Don't be seduced by low monthly rates only to find a big sign-up fee slipped in at the last minute. They can turn a good deal into a bad deal very quickly.

5. Don't use financial commitment as your workout buddy

Many people sign a long-term health club contract thinking their obligation will help guilt them into going to the gym more often. That kind of negative incentive is usually pretty ineffective. And it puts you at the mercy of the club. Use workout buddies, or your own self-discipline, or FitBit, or Google reminders, or pictures of yourself looking particularly plump, as inspiration. Don't use an entangling financial contract with a health club as inspiration.

To that end, month-to-month contracts are a great option, even if they cost more. I know, on Jan. 1 you tell yourself you'll go to the club three time a week. But who knows what spring will bring? Keep yourself a club-free agent as best you can. It's worth it.

6. Money well spent

Speaking of spring, calculate the annual cost of a health club, and consider a wide range of alternatives. I once paid $350 to join an adult hardball baseball league, which seemed expensive until the league commissioner smartly compared it to the cost of a gym membership. Lots of things can make you healthier. Maybe you should spend the money on a dream road bike instead, or a dog (walks are VERY healthy).

More from

Jan 2, 2014 3:58PM
I love when you go to cancel and they say the only way to do it is by writing a letter and mailing it to their corporate office. Way to make it as inconvenient and time-consuming as possible jerks. Oh, and by the way, I found out that's a lie too. I told them my auto-withdrawl bank account had been closed and 10 minutes later I walked out the door with a cancellation of membership form signed.
Jan 2, 2014 7:05PM
I have NEVER had a good experience with a gym:
Gold's Gym told me when I signed up that it was good at any of the locations in the US-- LIE#1, each are independently owned so when I moved across the country, my membership that I was paying for in Nebraska, was NO GOOD in California. STILL HAD TO PAY for membership til the length of the contract because I had to be "in person" to sign the termination form LIE#2

A few years ago I went to 24 Hour fitness, because they allow cancellation at any time. When I was moving again, tried to cancel, the staff member was pushy, rude and just an ****, saying that "if I wasn't going to commit to my fitness" I would probably die "fat and alone". After speaking to a manager and I throw down the "I'll have my lawyer review my contract" only then did I get my termination forms approved.  UGH.

Jan 2, 2014 5:12PM
2 year pre paid 24 hour Fitness Membership from Costco, includes everything, sign up, dues, everything.  Comes out to $16 a month.
Jan 2, 2014 3:17PM
I sure wouldn't want to be a personal trainer right now...
Jan 2, 2014 7:57PM
If you have a Medicare Advantage or other Medicare Plus program, see if you have the Silver Sneakers program in your policy. It provides free gym memberships at many gyms.
Jan 2, 2014 4:59PM
I had a guy call and tell me he had a great deal for "someone my age" to go to the gym 3 times a week. I told him call back when he had a deal to help "someone my age" go to the "john" 3 times a week!!!
Jan 3, 2014 10:50AM
Every year we go though this in January.  By March the clubs will be empty and most will be visiting Mcdonalds twice a day.  Quit eating so much and take a walk. There and my advice is free so save yourself the trouble.  Less calories equal less fat and you can do this while driving sitting or sleeping.  Just don't eat so much friggin food.
Jan 2, 2014 3:16PM
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.


Smart Spending brings you the best money-saving tips from MSN Money and the rest of the Web. Join the conversation on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.