Smart SpendingSmart Spending

A college degree with no money down?

Oregon recently approved a plan to waive tuition in favor of future payback. That doesn't mean a 'free' education, though -- and is it the right way to pay?

By Donna_Freedman Jul 10, 2013 10:03AM

Logo: Graduation cap (Brand X Pictures/Photolibrary/PHOTOLIBRARY GROUP LTD)On July 1, the Oregon legislature passed HB 3472, aka "Pay It Forward, Pay It Back." The bill proposes that students be allowed to attend state schools without paying upfront. Instead, they'd promise to pay 3% of their annual salaries for 24 years.

Headlines trumpeted "free" tuition and "free higher education." A few things to keep in mind:

First, this is by no means a done deal. Even if Gov. John Kitzhaber signs the bill, that merely signals the state's Higher Education Coordinating Commission to create a pilot program by 2015.

Second: Tuition represents only about 40% of the total cost of a college degree.

Third: One expert predicts that need-based grants will likely disappear under such a system. Without grants, poorer students may wind up borrowing more than they do now to cover other costs.

Fourth, and most important: This is not a "free" education. The students have to pay the money back -- and some will pay considerably more than others. 

In theory, Pay It Forward sounds better than the current system, which requires immediate loan payments even if students can't find jobs. Proponents say the new plan will let young adults build lives and participate in the economy, versus moving in with their parents and spending much of their salaries on debt service.

Critics want to know where the initial funds (a projected $9 billion) will come from, and exactly how the payback could be enforced. Some say that the plan doesn't address the underlying problem of bloated education costs -- it just changes the time frame for paying them.

Others naysayers believe the plan would drive medical and law students away from public institutions due to the disproportionate nature of the payback. For example, if during that 24-year period one student earned $800,000 and another $2 million, the first would repay $24,000 and the second $80,000.

Economic and civic benefits

Some education experts have issues with Pay It Forward. In a 2012 paper, the American Federation of Teachers stated that postsecondary ed is everyone's business. Just as we pay for fire protection even if our own homes never burn, it's in our best interests as a society to have a well-educated population.

According to the AFT, income-based repayment plans are part of the tendency to see higher education as "a private transaction that accrues benefits to the individual rather than a public good that brings economic and civic benefits to communities."

Sara Goldrick-Rab, a professor of higher education policy at the University of Wisconsin at Madison, questions how Pay It Forward could be funded and how those 3% payments would be enforced. In fact, she says, students might choose to leave school "with skills but before graduation" in order to avoid paying at all.

In her post on the Education Optimists blog, Goldrick-Rab suggests that that costs are high because colleges cater to those who desire "an elite experience" and because state governments have decreased funding and done little to keep costs down at public schools.

"Today the costs of attendance borne by students and their families have never been higher," she says, and that situation has been exacerbated by the recession and a weak job market.

A way around loans?

A dozen institutions of higher learning do waive tuition or allow students to work it off,  according to the FinAid website. But even at these schools students usually have to pay for dorms, meal plans, books and the various fees that keep universities running (and parents griping).

In some cases loans can be erased. The Teacher Loan Forgiveness Program allows for up to $17,500 to be forgiven for teachers in low-income communities. The Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program makes those who work in a number of public service jobs eligible for forgiveness once they've made 120 payments.

AmeriCorps offers awards and loan forbearance to recent grads. The Teach for America program offers the same benefits.


Such opportunities are available to relatively few students, however. For the majority, it's clear that the current system isn't working. The average debt load has gone up 30% in the past five years and delinquencies rose 22% in the same period. Nearly half of all outstanding loans are currently in deferment.

Programs like Pay It Forward address only those symptoms rather than the underlying disease.

Harder to get through

It's tempting to say, "Just go to a cheaper school" or "Work your way through, the way I did." That's not as easy as it sounds, especially since costs have risen exponentially and degrees are taking longer to get.


Associate's degrees take an average of 3.8 to 5 years to complete and bachelor's degrees from 4.7 to 5.6 years, according to a report from Complete College America. Reasons vary: family responsibilities, the need to work, a lack of direction and a lack of academic support. But even the most focused and motivated people on the planet may not catch the right breaks. 

I got my university degree in midlife without paying a dime out of pocket. Scholarships, grants and work-study covered tuition, fees and books. I already had my own apartment, paid for by a couple of part-time jobs, and deeply entrenched frugal habits let me stretch available dollars (especially since I was paying down divorce-related debt at the time).

Sure, I hustled to get those funds and those jobs. Yet personal drive isn't always enough. Another older student I knew earned a couple of scholarships but she barely made it through  despite a full-time job and shared housing. Her grant was delayed during one quarter, so she couldn't buy textbooks.

For a few weeks she spent any free hours waiting for a chance to read the reserved texts at the library. She managed to get through where a lot of others might have given up -- or just taken out more loans.

More on MSN Money:


While this program has a catchy phrase, sounds good and may have a valid basis, it certainly needs a lot of tweeking.... cap the amount borrowed, cap the percentage paid back to a given dollar amount.  And any university that accepts these payments would have to hold their increases to cost of living... also too bad if it only covers tuition... the student is capable of working while being a student, getting grants, scholarships, paid internships etc.. does it take initiative and fortitude - YES!!  That's what is needed today by everyone whether in school, at work, home responsibilities etc... I went to college as an adult... I started at a junior college with a transfer program, which I followed closely to be sure all my credits would transfer... I also worked 3/4 time - 25 hours plus and commuted close to an hour each way to school at least three days a week... at the same time, I had two daughters in two different colleges.. both getting loans, grants, scholarships and Working... we graduated within 6 months of each other and my son graduated from high school a month later.. And yes he went to college, earned his degree and worked too along with commuting.. And yes all four of us have paid back our student loans!!!!    We made sure we didn't take wasted classes that would not count! And yup minimal to NONE partying... made the grade to graduate and kept our funding (all of us) within 5 yrs.. At the time, my husband, their father did work full time but earned under $25,000 a year (the 1990's)... so it wasn't that long ago.. yes costs have gone up, but like the rest of us that nature, the government and big business tycoons throw a wrench in and twist, it can be done.. STOP CODDLING THOSE UNDER THIRTY and teach them to REALLY THINK!


Jul 23, 2013 6:24PM
The biggest problem I see with this is that it punishes those who make a smart choice, which is to say to pursue a degree that is likely to lead to higher earnings. You might then end up with a selection bias, wherein people seeking lower-paying careers opt in to the program, and those seeking higher-spaying careers opt out (going to school in a different state if necessary, for instance). Then the projected paybacks of the program end up lower than expected and money flies out of the pocket of the government (and in the end, the taxpayers).
Jul 10, 2013 2:11PM

I am tired of the phrase I am POOR therefore you need to pay for my college////////// Not my fault and

if you can't swing the payments don't go there. Get a job, any JOB, go to a Jr College and work for

your degree that way, but get off my dime////////////////// Obama has already taken all the dimes I've

saved in my lifetime//////////////////

Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.


Smart Spending brings you the best money-saving tips from MSN Money and the rest of the Web. Join the conversation on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.