Daughters are a bargain? Not necessarily, say parents
A new survey suggests daughters may be a better investment than sons, but parents say there's more to this story.
This post comes from Robert Beaupre at partner site MoneyRates.com.
A study released last month by Yodlee Interactive and Harris Poll found that adult women are 32 percent less likely to need financial support from their parents than adult men are. Shortly after the release, a spate of headlines touting the financial virtues of daughters appeared across the Web.
However, because the study only looked at adult sons and daughters, it did little to answer the question of which sex is less expensive to parent in the long run. A 2010 study from Lovemoney.com found that, between the ages of 5 and 18, boys are actually cheaper to raise than girls, primarily due to the more costly hobbies and activities girls tend to adopt (at least in England, where the study was conducted).
In terms of hard data, the debate over the relative costs of sons and daughters seems muddled at best. But if you turned to parents who have children of both sexes for answers, would a clearer answer emerge?
“This is not a difficult answer”
Given how many costs can arise when raising a child, gauging the overall expense of a son or daughter – even on an approximate level – requires some financial attention-to-detail.
Bradford Pine, a wealth adviser and president of the Bradford Pine Wealth Group in Garden City, New York, makes his living scrutinizing financial details. He also happens to have a son and a daughter who are both in their teens.
When asked which of his children has been more expensive to raise to this point, Pine doesn’t hesitate.
“This is not a difficult answer,” says Pine. “It was my daughter. By a boatload.”
Pine reels off a list of expenses when asked what drove his daughter’s cost higher than his son’s.
“Designer clothes, nails, hair, cosmetics, birthday parties, concert tickets for teenage heartthrobs, prom dresses, weddings,” he says. “(Sons and daughters) both have college, but you usually pay for the wedding with a daughter. My daughter’s not married yet, but I foresee (that expense).
Pine says he thinks this pattern holds up in lots of families – in between recalling the extra expenses his daughter required.
“I don’t know if all kids are that way, but I think it’s common knowledge (that girls are more expensive),” Pine says. “Oh, and American Girl dolls. It just goes on and on.”
“It’s like having another grown woman to pay for”
Kristin Marino has a 14-year-old daughter and a son who is a year away from completing college. Marino, an editor for a website on higher education, says that the extracurricular activities her daughter took on as a teenager sealed her fate as the more expensive of her two children.
“They both have expensive extracurriculars, but dancing really put us over the top for her,” writes Marino in an email interview. “Each style of dance requires its own shoes – four to five pairs per season – and to be en pointe for ballet requires $80 shoes every six months.”
But her daughter’s costs didn’t stop there, says Marino.
“Clothes are more expensive for girls and they need more of them,” Marino says. “Once girls hit puberty they require lots of upkeep, including hair, skin (dermatologist plus skin care), makeup – even their underwear is expensive (a different bra depending on the sport, activity or sort of outfit she’s wearing, just as one example). It’s like having another grown woman to pay for once they hit 8th grade or so.”
And her son?
“My son is good with a couple of pairs of shorts, a few T-shirts, face wash and a package of underwear from Walmart,” says Marino.
Still, should the results of the Yodlee/Harris poll give parents of soon-to-be-adult sons pause? Will they soon see their sons make up for their frugal childhoods by leaning on their parents for financial support as adults?
Pine isn’t especially worried about his son – or his daughter, for that matter.
“They’re both on good settings,” Pine says. “They’re both very smart and motivated. But we’ll see.”
The greater truth
Regardless of which sex your children are, it’s likely they will cost you a staggering amount over the years. The USDA estimates that it will cost parents $241,080 to raise a child born in 2012 through age 18.
That figure doesn’t include college. According to The College Board, the average annual cost for that now is $17,860 (for a public school) or $39,518 (for a private school).
Pine, whose daughter is now in college, says that 529 plans – tax-advantaged accounts that are designed for educational savings – are something that all parents should begin using as soon as they can.
“Use them systematically and don’t stop,” Pine says of these savings accounts. “Do it every month and it’s no big deal. Her school is $48,000 per year. Don’t procrastinate. It’s the best advice I can give you.”
More from MoneyRates.com
But in the future, it will most likely be the daughter who cares for her aging parents and helps her parents with their bills when their pensions aren't enough. Daughters drive their parents to the doctor, clean the house for them, buy the groceries, and listen to their daily complaints... believe me, I know.
And besides, parents really do not "have to" buy all that designer crap, or pay for hair, nails, etc. When I was a kid I was not into that expensive junk. I just wore jeans and sneakers, and that's what little girls should wear. No little girl needs designer dresses or hair or nails. Parents need to raise their kids to value real things, not just beauty and self image. If a daughter is costing "too much money," it's the parents' fault for encouraging that. Parents raise their kids to be shallow, no kid is born selfish or vain like that.
I've said this countless times .. kids are as expensive as you let them be.....
will my daughter get expensive clothes, salon cuts, dept store makeup, couture prom gowns, pro mani-peds, a skin care regime as outlined by her dermatologist ... ha ! and NO !
If you buy your kids designer clothes it's on you 100%. That's not a necessary expense.
The author is lying if they say the have kids, it's not about the $$ idiots!
Stupidest article ever. Coming from MSN that is a HUGE statement.
Meanwhile, my brother 'needs' designer clothes, new phones, tickets, haircuts, etc.
The only way boys cost more is in third world countries where most of the money is spend on the son's education, and the daughter is left home doing chores.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
ABOUT SMART SPENDING
LATEST BLOG POSTS
Occupy Wall Street bought and forgave the student loan debt of more than 2,700 Everest College students.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
BLOGS WE LIKE
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'