Smart SpendingSmart Spending

The wrong ways to get rid of your student loans

For many grads, finding out how deep in student loan debt they are is the first introduction to the real world. Don't let the figure floor you -- and don't use these questionable strategies.

By May 16, 2014 11:50AM
This post comes from Adam Levin at partner site on MSN MoneyClass of 2014, the time has come to find a job and start paying down your student loans. Like many young graduates, you probably don’t feel like embracing this particular change. If that’s the case, I’d like to suggest you at least consider shaking its hand.

Graduation cap and cash © Stockdisc/SuperStockCommencement season is here, which means a torrent of speeches about risk-taking and being bold on life’s journey -- with a laugh line here and there about the student loans new graduates will have to start paying down. However, given today’s job market, most folks wearing caps and gowns will fail to see the humor.

Almost universally, commencement speakers tell the newly graduated not to worry too much about being perfect, but to always do your best as you wend your way through the vales of Not Failing toward Success. That said, one of the first places many graduates will encounter failure in 2014 is in the job market.

recent Slate article joined the murmuring throng of pieces about the job prospects for new graduates:

“It used to be that more than half of these overeducated young workers would find themselves in 'good' jobs -- meaning that they'd pay at least $45,000 in today's market. Today, less than 40 percent do. Meanwhile, more than a fifth of this group were in low-wage jobs, meaning they paid $25,000 a year or less.”

For many graduates, the first dose of reality hits when they discover that the amount of money they actually make is radically different than that which they estimated would be their likely starting salary when they originally took on the burden of those student loans.

The big problem here is that there is rarely an elegant exit from most student loan debt (for example, if you become totally and permanently disabled, or if you die -- to name a couple possibilities -- your debt might be discharged). Otherwise, for the most part, the only way to get out from under that dark mountain is to pay your way out. That said, there are always people who think they can game the system and avoid paying.

Here are three ways student loan borrowers try to escape their fate and why they won’t work.

1. Not paying

Difficult as it may be to fathom, many people have tried this tactic. It seems simple enough. “I mean hey, what can a lender really do to me if I don’t pay?” How about plenty -- and none of it is good.

When you don’t pay, the debt hangs around like a really bad canker sore in a mouth full of hot sauce. Unlike credit card debt, there is no real bankruptcy option on the horizon for student loan debt. With penalties and interest accruing, the obligation keeps growing and there’s no escape. It’s a modern day version of owing your life to the company store.

Additionally, this approach will prove to be an albatross around your neck when you try to get a mortgage (or even rent) down the line. That’s because student loan payments tend to be some of the first credit accounts new graduates have to their name. If you miss payments, it will hammer your credit score -- one of the first things lenders (and landlords) look at when determining whether to lend or rent to you. If you want to see where your credit currently stands and how your student loans are impacting your scores, you can see two of your credit scores for free every month on

2. Paying with credit cards then declaring bankruptcy

Here’s another misconception that will cost you -- big time. The rates on your credit cards are much higher than those on student loans. So unless you have an unquenchable thirst to waste your money on unnecessary interest payments, the only reason to pay your student loan debt with credit cards would be a feeble and misguided attempt to change the character of the obligation and discharge the debt in bankruptcy.

Make no mistake, the bankruptcy court will see right through this scheme. The student loan debt will still be due, and you will have 7 years of ugly credit.

3. Using your home equity to pay off the loans

For some borrowers who have returned to school later in life, they may think that using equity in their home will help them consolidate their student loans and lower their monthly payments. While this option may work, it’s most likely not a good one, and actually could have disastrous consequences.

The hitch here is that most student loans have comparable interest rates to what banks are charging homebuyers right now. You’re not paying off debt, just trading it in for some new debt tied to your home.

Another consideration is that by encumbering real estate with further debt, you could be putting your house (perhaps your only asset) on the line. Missing a student loan payment is bad enough, but if you miss mortgage payments you put yourself at risk for foreclosure.

If you're having trouble meeting your obligations on federal student loan debt there are options out there ranging from Income-Based Repayment and Pay as You Earn plans to Income-Contingent Repayment. There are ways to legitimately satisfy student loan debt. After making income-contingent payments for a long period of time you can qualify for relief. If you work for a qualified employer -- the government or a tax-exempt nonprofit -- you may qualify for public service forgiveness after 120 qualifying payments.

The bottom line when it comes to paying down student loans in an anemic job market: You are not alone -- tens of thousands of new graduates are in the same boat. You are going to have trouble meeting obligations that you made long before  you even decided upon your major. While the seas will be rough, you don’t have to feel like you bought a ticket on the Titanic.  If graduates face repayment in an open way, communicating regularly with lenders, there are solutions -- although none of them get you a Get Out of Debt Free card.

More from

May 20, 2014 9:56AM
I went to college and have student loans that I have been paying on for the last 7 years and I still have 4 more years to go. There are people I know that didn't go to college and they make more money than I do. I have learned more at my current job than at the college I attended, and basically feel like I bought a very expensive fancy looking piece of paper that says i'm qualified.
May 16, 2014 4:21PM
The problem with these articles is that they do not address those student's who have several or multiple loans from different sources.  Which one do you address first, assuming each loan is substantial?  Creditiors of course want the student to repay thier loan first and jockey to get in front of the line if the student is unable to make payments on all his/her loans.  Consolidation can be an option but it doesn't work if the student has loans from public, private, State and Federal sources.

May 20, 2014 7:11AM

So don't try to cheat the system, check.

Don't just ignore it, check.

Don't consolidate, check.

Can't use bankruptcy, check.

Answers (given by article)

1. Keep paying (if they could wouldn't be a problem right?)

2. Income based Repayment (so not even making interest payments for 20+ years till they forgive it)

3. Work for the government and hope you can cut it down to 10 years.

Is it me, or is it a joke that the only idea that they provide that is any real help is to work for the government?

May 20, 2014 9:15AM
What about Private Loans??? Everyone seems to forget about those and how those really awesome repayment options do not apply to private loans.
May 20, 2014 8:26AM
COMMUNICATING with their lender? From experience, I know that's a one-way street. I contact them to get silence as a reply. I'm pretty much on my own to figure out what to do. They will NEVER reply to me no matter what method of communication I try. The system is complicated, options confusing and help nonexistent.
May 19, 2014 8:35PM
For those of you who didn't see the news on student loans last month, there is another important point that needs to be made. If the co-signor dies, the loan becomes in default.  This ruins the credit for the student, even if they have been making payments perfectly on time.  

Lucky for students, the solution is actually pretty easy, and only costs a little bit.  I signed on a student loan for my niece and to protect her (shes a great girl) I got a $12 a month student loan policy from Life Ant.  If anything happens to me, the proceeds from the life insurance will just pay off the loan for her.  

I really debated whether or not to make her pay, but ultimately I decided to be the good uncle and just pay myself.  Its cheap enough and she doesn't need any more bills, though I'm sure she can handle it if she had to.  She's going to have enough to worry about in this economy anyway and it is cheap enough.
May 20, 2014 4:01PM

Look at your individual loans and pick one to pay off first (usually the lowest value/highest interest one). With these 10 year notes, you have excellent leverage if you just pay a little extra each month towards the principle. Once one loan is paid off, your monthly payments will be lower and you can either live with them, or move on to the next lower loan. Just don't fall for that hardship, extended loan payment offer - that is actually extended interest payments.

May 20, 2014 12:24PM

Recent studies and articles show that student loan debt in the US has recently exceeded one trillion dollars with most of those loans in default. As a certified counselor for student loan debt relief I can agree that dealing with mounting student loan debt is not easy is sometimes very stressful. Paying your loans back is really the best option however with multiple repayment, and forgiveness programs available it is possible. Another option is also consolidation of loans especially if you have multiple loans with multiple lenders, this gives you the opportunity to have all your loans with 1 lender, 1 payment and 1 fixed rate. While dealing with student loans is a struggle there are options and assistance available. The only snag is with private loans as those do not have alternatives to paying back student loans. - 247 Student Loan Help 

Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.


Smart Spending brings you the best money-saving tips from MSN Money and the rest of the Web. Join the conversation on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.