Smart SpendingSmart Spending

Where the car insurance cheaters live

Rate evasion raises car insurance rates for everyone. And soon, in at least one state, it may be against the law.

By MSN Money Partner Jul 16, 2013 4:45PM
This post comes from Susan Ladika at partner site

MSN Money partnerRegistering and insuring your vehicle using your sister's address in the next state or your parents' house in a neighboring county might seem a clever way to save money on your car insurance rates.

Car wrecked on road guardrail © NULL, OJO Images, Getty ImagesIn some cases, doing so might save you hundreds or even thousands of dollars a year. In Bullhead City, Ariz., for example, a 40-year-old man driving a 2012 Honda Accord would pay about $729 a year. But across the Colorado River in Laughlin, Nev., the same driver would pay about $1,580.

Compare what drivers pay in these neighboring ZIP codes:
  • Attleboro, Mass.: $977; Pawtucket, R.I.: $1,860.
  • Fort Smith, Ark.: $1,075; Roland, Okla.: $2,116.
  • Hazel Park, Mich.: $2,485; Detroit, Mich.: $4,314

You can check out the differences in your city with's Nosy Neighbor tool.

The temptation is clear enough. But if you're caught with your car registered at the wrong location, you could see your auto insurance claim invalidated or a bill for unpaid premiums in your mailbox.

And if you live in New Jersey, you might soon face criminal charges.

So what's the harm in cheating?
While fudging on your address might seem harmless enough, it's a practice known as rate evasion, and it's considered a form of insurance fraud. A 2010 report by Quality Planning, an industry analyst, put the cost to insurers at more than $1 billion a year.

"It's one of those issues that cause consternation," says Howard Goldblatt, director of government affairs with the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud in Washington, D.C. The nonprofit's membership is made up dozens of insurance companies, consumer groups and government organizations.

With rate evasion, people claim to live in another state or that their car is garaged there, in order to pay lower insurance rates. They might also say they live in another, less costly county in the same state.

If you say you live in Pennsylvania and you actually live in New Jersey, "you're posing a risk here but you're not paying for that risk," says Chuck Leitgeb, vice president of the Insurance Council of New Jersey. The insurance advocacy and research group comprises 20 companies that together underwrite two-thirds of the state's auto policies.

Residents of your home state whose vehicles are registered in the right location end up covering your share of the costs by paying higher auto insurance rates, Leitgeb says.

And drivers of the state you falsely claim as your own face higher premiums if you have an accident -- because your wreck makes their statistics look worse than they actually are.

Rate evasion can have unexpected consequences. The Michigan news site found that a large number of Detroit residents had registered their vehicles in other, less expensive parts of the state, depressing the number of registered voters in the city.

By at least one estimate, some 60% of Detroit residents don't even bother with buying car insurance.

Where the cheaters live -- and don't live

Rate evasion is particularly common in states such as New Jersey, New York and Florida - all states with sky-high auto insurance rates in some of their metro areas. Residents will use an address or a P.O. box in another location to register their vehicles.

In certain areas of New Jersey, especially northern, urban areas, and the southern part of the state bordering Pennsylvania, it's not uncommon to see plenty of cars with out-of-state license plates regularly parked in people's driveways and on residential streets, Leitgeb says.

It's a similar situation in New York, where cars from North Carolina and Pennsylvania can be found parked in the middle of the week on Brooklyn streets, Goldblatt says. Prosecutors report dozens of vehicles registered at some Pennsylvania addresses.

Many people get away with evading rates. Others don't.

Their fraud may be discovered once a claim is filed. If insurance companies suspect you're a rate evader, they can pay a company such as Lexis-Nexis to do a public records search. If your car is insured in North Carolina but your phone bills go to New York, you may have a problem.

Or their neighbors may turn them in. "It drives people crazy," New York state Sen. Diane Savino told the New York Post. "Constituents are calling my office to report motorists who have out-of-state license plates."

New York legislators have even proposed a reward for doing so. Some states already have online systems to report cheaters like this one run by the California Highway Patrol.

The worst that can happen? Prison
Some states are moving to crack down on the practice of rate evasion. North Carolina and Idaho, which have some of the lowest auto insurance rates, have made it tougher to register vehicles there.

In Pennsylvania, the Attorney General's Office has stepped up rate evasion prosecution. Last year, for example, a New Jersey man and 11 co-conspirators were charged with illegally providing Pennsylvania vehicle registrations and insurance to people who lived in other states.

Now New Jersey has the practice in its sights. Under current state law, New Jersey's Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor can't prosecute such cases because they're not considered a form of insurance fraud.

Smart Spending on the go: Get our app for Android or iPhone

But that soon could change. A bill working its way through the state's Legislature would classify rate evasion as insurance fraud, with varying levels of criminal penalties if someone is convicted, including up to 18 months in jail.

More from

Jul 17, 2013 5:39PM
Bunk!  Jersey will find ANY opportunity to fleece it's citizens (cattle?) more efficiently.  Do you know they wanted to require paid registration of BICYCLES!?!?  Any wonder so many jobs and resourceful people are leaving?  I consider it my wisest choice.
Jan 5, 2014 1:17AM
this is a sad article... i dont know why insurance is so high some places.  here's a tip - if you live anywhere that 4autoinsurancequote does business, you can get a really cheap quote from them without having to cheat on your insurance.  $33/month is what i was quoted.
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.


Smart Spending brings you the best money-saving tips from MSN Money and the rest of the Web. Join the conversation on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.