Smart SpendingSmart Spending

Will a smart thermostat pay for itself?

In theory, a programmable thermostat can help counteract high energy bills, but the savings generated by a Wi-Fi-connected smart thermostat often aren't enough to justify a $250 price.

By Cheapism.com Nov 1, 2013 4:45PM
This post comes from Elizabeth Sheer at partner site Cheapism.com.

Most Americans are likely to pay more to heat their homes this year than they did last winter because of an expected rise in fuel costs, according to a recent Energy Department report. Common theory says that a programmable thermostat can help counteract those high utility bills.
 
But what about the relatively new breed of smart thermostats, including the much-buzzed-about Nest? Do their additional features deliver enough additional energy savings to justify a price tag of $250 or more? The answer may depend more on you than on them.

flickr.com/ryannicholasjonesAccording to the Department of Energy, consumers can knock as much as 1 percent off their heating bill for every degree they turn back the thermostat when they're not at home for eight hours at a stretch.
 
This sounds great, but most people don't diligently turn the temperature up and down during their comings and goings during the day. That's where a programmable thermostat comes in. Instead of having to physically move a dial or slider to change the temperature, you can set it to lower automatically at the times of day when family members either go to sleep or leave the house. You can customize this by days of the week, as well -- for instance, by setting the thermostat to save energy during the workweek but keep the heat on when you're home over the weekend.

If your work schedule is erratic, perhaps because you do shift work or travel frequently, reprogramming the device every time your schedule changes can be a real pain. Top-end thermostats such as the Honeywell Wi-Fi Smart Thermostat are Wi-Fi-connected, so you can contact them remotely if you're going to alter your routine, even just for a last-minute dinner or late meeting.
 
The Honeywell learns how long it takes to get the temperature back up and kicks on in time to make the house comfortable when you walk in, removing the temptation to crank up the heat. The Nest learns your habits and adjusts the heat based on your usage patterns. It also has a sensor that automatically triggers a drop in temperature when you're out of the house. It may seem like such features would idiot-proof the process and save a lot of money (not to mention energy) in the long run -- certainly that's the claim of the manufacturers. But would you really make back the cost of one of these devices, which both carry a sticker price of $249?
It's hard to talk concrete numbers, because the amount it costs to heat (and cool) a home depends on many factors, including the type, age, and efficiency of the heating system; how well the walls, doors, windows and ductwork are sealed; and the thermostat's location in the house, among other things. If you have an old, inadequate heating system or your house isn't well-insulated, for example, you probably need a more expensive fix than a $250 thermostat to start seeing significant energy savings. What's more, utility costs fluctuate, and if prices go up significantly this year, you may spend the same amount of money even if you use less energy. Climate also makes a difference. The Energy Department advises that consumers in regions with mild weather will see the most savings.

Real usage studies of smart thermostats are still in their early days. Pacific Gas and Electric Company in California has partnered with Honeywell to do a trial of smart thermostats but hasn't reported final results yet. The Honeywell Wi-Fi Smart Thermostat just entered the market in September, so it hasn't been through a heating season. In a discussion thread on the Nest website, the comments run about 2-to-1 in favor of savings. But some customers not only didn't save money; they actually spent more on energy than they had in prior years. One personal study of the Nest, by a self-described tech, data, and design enthusiast blogging at GetGrok, measured his energy use over the course of two summers. Controlling for differences in outside temperature, he found that his energy consumption dropped enough in the year he used the Nest to recoup the cost of the thermostat, and then some.

The users who seem to benefit most from a smart thermostat are those who used to have a manual thermostat or never properly programmed a previous thermostat. The Environmental Protection Agency's Energy Star program and a research team at Lawrence Berkeley National Lab assert that many Americans with programmable thermostats set them incorrectly -- in some cases just by leaving the clock set to the wrong time -- or don't program them at all, leaving potential energy savings on the table. Using a regular programmable thermostat judiciously can save about $180 a year on household energy bills, according to an Energy Star estimate -- no smart features necessary.

By far the most important piece of the equation is you. An expensive smart thermostat can make the programming process easier, or at least more appealing, and easily adjust to schedule changes. But if you have a relatively consistent routine and the discipline to effectively program a cheap thermostat (Cheapism.com recommends easy-to-use thermostats under $40), you may be able to realize similar savings without spending over $200 more.

More from Cheapism.com:

 
5Comments
Nov 2, 2013 3:37PM
avatar

THIS IS SOMEWHAT STUPID.....

 

GO TO; Home Depot, Lowes or Menards..

 

GET a "electronic programmable thermostat" for about $25-50 dollars...Install yourself or have kids or friend do it....It's fairly simple...Set it and Forget it...Unless you go away or on vacation for days.

 

it WILL SAVE you between $200-300 per year on heating/cooling bills, maybe more?

Think they use 2-AA batteries about once a year. 

Nov 2, 2013 6:14PM
avatar
I brought a Filtrete CT50 programable thermostat at Home Depot 2 years ago. It connects to my WiFi and has an app for my iPhone and my wife's Android. It has a 7-day programmable schedule, an Away feature, and we can turn off the Away mode remotely on our phone. I paid $99, and LOVE it! Works like a charm. 
Nov 4, 2013 1:29AM
avatar

It's amazing that so many people promote and declare that you can save money by turning down your thermostat at night and while your at work.  What people need to realize is when you cool you house down you not only cool the air but you also cool the furniture, the walls, every surface and item in your house.  So when you raise the temperature on the thermostat back up you will have to re heat those items and they are not considered when they make their calculations.  They only calculate the changes in air temperature. 

 

If you are going to be gone for several days or longer it may make sense, otherwise, stick to the basic thermostat and don't make yourself uncomfortable by constantly raising and lowering the thermostat. 

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

DATA PROVIDERS

Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.

ABOUT SMART SPENDING

Smart Spending brings you the best money-saving tips from MSN Money and the rest of the Web. Join the conversation on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

VIDEO ON MSN MONEY

TOOLS

More