Devil’s advocate: Being frugal is foolish
Is your time best spent looking for ways to save a few dimes or dollars here and there?
I bet this Devil’s Advocate post, which is part of a series I do to challenge conventional wisdom, is going to ruffle a lot of feathers.
Frugality is a pretty big topic in the personal-finance blogging community because there are so many things you can do to trim a few cents or dollars here or there. You can buy gadgets like a Kill A Watt to find out how much energy your appliances are using and disconnect them when they’re not in use. You can make your own laundry detergent or buy a rack to line-dry your clothes. There have been books filled to the brim with thousands upon thousands of ways to save a few dollars and cents here or there.
However, they never get to the heart of the issue: Being frugal should be the very last thing you try to be when all other options have been exhausted.
- Bing: Extreme frugality
If you think of yourself as a business, you have two ways of generating a profit. You can increase your income or you can decrease your expenses. When you focus entirely on being frugal, you look at only half of the equation. That’s foolish.
Know the value of your time
It’s very important that you know how much an hour of your time is worth because all of your decisions should start with that number. The point of knowing has less to do with actual dollar amounts; it's more about putting those decisions into context.
- Calculator: How much is your time worth?
Consider this: Let’s say you’ve estimated that one of your hours is worth $100. Would you spent an hour making laundry detergent that you can buy for $10 or would you instead be focusing on finding more ways to earn money? What if your hour is worth $50? Would you rather be spending that hour making detergent or finding more hours to work? While you might not be able to add more hours, I argue that your hour is better spent trying to find more worth instead of making detergent.
The point of my example wasn’t to pick on making detergent, or any household supplies, but the main reason for doing it shouldn’t be financial. We line-dry clothes because it’s more environmentally friendly. We also save money on electricity, but the main reason is environmental.
Frugality offers diminishing returns
The second biggest reason why focusing on frugality is foolish has to do with limitations. There is no limit to how much income you can earn in your lifetime. You may impose limits on yourself, based on your environment and your decisions, but there is no immutable law that says you can earn only a certain amount. There is, however, a limit to how much you can save. If you spend $500 a month on groceries, the most you could ever save per month on groceries, with all the tricks in the world, is $500.
Not only is there a limit with frugality, but the biggest gains are usually discovered in the beginning. When you start making laundry detergent for yourself, the biggest savings will be in making it yourself. As you find cheaper ingredients or buy in bulk, you will continue to increase your savings over the store-bought detergent but each step will be smaller.
The opposite is true when you focus on increasing your income. As you develop your skills, add to your list of certifications or education, you become a more valuable asset and income increases will become larger with each step.
The bottom line is that while frugality can be an excellent exercise in creativity, it’s usually not worth your time.
Related reading at Bargaineering:
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
ABOUT SMART SPENDING
LATEST BLOG POSTS
If you're not the paranoid type, you might be after you read this article. We break down the common holiday scams -- 20 in all.