Smart SpendingSmart Spending

3 tough holiday money questions from kids

What should you tell your children when they ask why they're not getting the gifts they want? 'I'm unemployed' isn't enough.

By MSN Money Partner Dec 7, 2011 7:48PM

This post comes from Susan Johnston at partner site U.S. News & World Report.


U.S. News on MSN MoneyAs kids write their wish lists for Santa and parents open their wallets, the holidays can highlight some not-so-nice financial realities, especially with many families struggling. Answering kids' questions about money and gifts isn't easy, so U.S. News talked to several experts about how to handle three possible scenarios.


Question: But why can't Santa bring me an iPad?


Answer: Whether you're strapped for cash or you simply choose to spend money in other ways, Nan J. Morrison, president and CEO of the Council for Economic Education, suggests focusing on choices and tradeoffs rather than "Mommy and Daddy can't afford that." As she explains, "I'm out of work today" is not a lasting lesson, but "the core lessons that you're teaching kids about allocating their resources are applicable throughout their whole lives."


Rather than caving in to kids' demands or internal pressures to put mountains of gifts under the tree, some parents encourage children to save up allowance and birthday money to buy the things they want. Morrison suggests opening the conversation like this: "Sweetie, this is a really expensive game and this way you'll understand that if you're making a choice to keep saving, then you're choosing not to do other things. Why don't you think about what you really want?"


Of course, gifts aren't the only way to celebrate the season, so creating family rituals can help shift the focus away from material goods. "We need to show them that joy is not in things," says Gail Perry Mason, author of "Girl, Make Your Money Grow!" and founder of Money Matters for Youth, a weeklong summer program aimed at teaching kids responsible money management. "The real joy comes in creating great memories. The things become obsolete, the memories don't."


She suggests letting each family member choose a tradition like enjoying homemade pancakes, decorating a gingerbread house, or making ornaments together. In fact, Mason and her kids have a tradition of adopting a family each year, in which they put together a food basket and buy gifts from the family's wish list.


Question: How come I got a bigger gift at Daddy's house?


Answer: The holidays can be a confusing time for kids of divorced parents, especially if one parent is struggling financially. That's why Brette Sember, author of "How to Parent with Your Ex," suggests setting realistic expectations beforehand. "When talking about the holidays, you have to be very clear that things will be different now that you're living in two houses, but try to spin it so that this means there will be twice the celebration," she says. "Emphasize that the holidays are about more than the number of gifts." Post continues below.

Sember adds that one parent should never try to outdo the other or blame the ex for financial hardships. As she puts it, "Your child needs a relationship with that other parent and you must support that. Negative statements undermine that relationship." Instead, it's a good idea to discuss holiday gift-giving with the other parent.


"Some parents agree on a dollar-amount cap that keeps things even at both homes," explains Sember. "Others chip in together for big purchases and may do so in whatever way is equitable for them, so that the child gets the 'big' gift from both parents, without either parent being left out."


Question: Who are those people in the Santa hats and why are they asking for money?


Answer: Between nonprofits ramping up their end-of-the-year fundraising and headlines about the 1% versus the 99%, kids of all ages may ask questions about the haves or have-nots. Laura Vanderkam, mother of three and author of the forthcoming book "All the Money in the World: What the Happiest People Know About Getting and Spending," says these questions could lead to useful discussion.


"Why don't people have homes?" she asks. "Ask your child what she thinks the reasons might be, and then talk about ways you can try to make a difference. Children often have a very strong sense of justice, and like to take action." Vanderkam suggests volunteering as a family or giving away coats and hats the kids have outgrown.


"If you haven't already," she adds, "this is a great time to introduce the concepts of both giving and taxes. Talk about how Mommy and Daddy earn money and give some of it to charity, and pay some of it to the government, which also uses it to pay for homes and meals."


Taking volunteerism a step further, Morrison points to teachers who have helped students raise money for charity instead of holding a coat drive or spending an afternoon at a soup kitchen. For instance, one elementary school class in an economically challenged area made lunches, sold them to teachers, and gave the proceeds to charity.


She adds that even very young children can grasp the concept of helping others. "I think as soon as you start teaching children how to share toys, they're already giving up something they really want for somebody to be happy," she says. "It's helping somebody else instead of doing for yourself."


More on U.S. News & World Report and MSN Money:

Dec 8, 2011 5:41PM

Take your kids to serve food at a homeless shelter/soup kitchen on Christmas day.  It will teach them a valuable lesson about poverty, generosity and how to recognize their own greed.  The iPad will seem less important when they see a child their own age who doesn't have a home or hasn't had a hot meal for a few days.  


This type of service helps the parent too.  It feels terrible to not be able to provide your child with everything they want, but sometimes parents need perspective too.  Things could be much worse, and in the grand scheme, they are likely providing more than enough to raise healthy and productive children.       

Dec 7, 2011 11:55PM
Honey, without a job I only have enough money to cover the house payment, utilties, gas for the car and food. We will have Christmas when things get better. Santa only supports the 'retail season', please boycott the practice!
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.


Smart Spending brings you the best money-saving tips from MSN Money and the rest of the Web. Join the conversation on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.