Is Target's '5% off with card' a good deal?
At 25% interest, a store card doesn't compute if you don't pay it off every month. A check card might be a better choice.
As store credit cards go, the Target card sounds better than many. You'll get your discount immediately, rather than be rewarded with coupons that require you to come in later and buy something else. But if you don't pay your bill on time every month, the card could cost you more in fees and interest than you save.
The 5% discount is generous, but it’s only worthwhile for consumers who already regularly shop at Target. ... And it's not a good deal for consumers who won't pay off the bill in full every month, because the APR, at 25.24%, is comparable to that of other store cards, but nearly twice the national average for all cards.
Store credit cards in general are not a good deal for most people. The correct answer to those pushy salespeople who ask you at the register if you want to save 10% by applying for a card today is "no" unless you are making a really big purchase.
- Bing: Target vs. Wal-Mart
Farnoosh Torabi at CBS MoneyWatch's You're So Money couldn't get a Victoria's Secret clerk to quit pushing the store card until she said: "For what it's worth -- I'm a personal finance writer and I'm no fan of store credit cards. They're not that great." She explains why here.
Leslie McFadden listed the pros and cons of store cards at Bankrate.com:
- Discount and other perks.
- Helps build credit score (for those who don't have a significant credit record).
- High interest rates.
- Low credit limits.
- Lowers credit score.
- Another spending temptation.
While store credit cards can help young people build credit to the point where they can obtain a better credit card, carrying too many store cards will lower your credit score, McFadden wrote.
Erin Peterson of CreditCards.com lists four situations in which a store credit card can be a good move: building credit, making a major purchase, ability to use the perks, and interest-free financing. Sometimes, she notes, you can get the perks with a regular loyalty card.
- Video: Shopping with caution
If you want to compare the Target card with other store credit cards, CreditCards.com has a chart. A better way to get cash back is to sign up for a card that offers cash back on ALL purchases. Consumer Reports picked out the best rewards cards this month.
The Target card with a 5% discount is not a good deal if you're going to carry a balance, even for a few months. Odysseas Papadimitriou, the CEO of CardHub.com, did the math for SmartMoney:
Every month a consumer fails to pay off the card, he pays 2% of the balance in interest charges, so after three months of a balance, he pays 1% additional instead of getting a 5% discount.
My view of store credit cards is that they're more trouble than they're worth. I put all my purchases on one credit card that provides a cash rebate once a year. That means just one bill and less chance of forgetting to pay on time.
What do you think? Will a 5% discount persuade you to apply for a Target credit card or debit card? What has been your experience with store credit cards?
More from MSN Money:
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
ABOUT SMART SPENDING
LATEST BLOG POSTS
Occupy Wall Street bought and forgave the student loan debt of more than 2,700 Everest College students.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
BLOGS WE LIKE
MUST-SEE ON MSN
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'