Car insurers overcharge poor, group says
Your education level, employment status and ZIP code could mean higher rates, even with a spotless driving record. Is that fair?
This post comes from Des Toups at partner site CarInsurance.com.
A new Consumer Federation of America report accuses auto insurance companies of unfairly penalizing low-income drivers.
By law, insurers aren't allowed to ask about income. The CFA report says insurers are using a number of other factors -- such as ZIP code and education -- as proxies for income, and charging poor drivers much more as a result.
The report drew a sharp response from the auto insurance industry.
"As anyone who watches television commercials knows, auto insurance coverage is widely available in every U.S. state," says Robert Hartwig, the Insurance Information Institute's president. "Drivers should shop around if they feel as though their current auto insurer is not meeting their needs, or charging too high a price."
In fact, the CFA analysis comes right on the heels of a report from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners trumpeting another year of decline in overall auto insurance expenditures. (See "The cheapest states for car insurance rates.")
So is insurance getting cheaper or more expensive? Post continues below.
The company you keep
Our gilded age of computing offers companies the ability to slice and dice data to predict behaviors.
Amazon.com uses it to show you music you might like, and car insurers use it to set your rates. If drivers like you -- sharing your occupation, ZIP code, credit history or dozens of other rating factors -- file more claims, you will pay more for car insurance.
So, assuming you live in the right ZIP code and fall into the right buckets, you're probably paying less than someone who doesn't. (We strongly suggest everyone shop around, of course.)
The wide-ranging CFA report cites as an example a single man with a spotless record, age 30, driving a Ford Taurus 20 miles each way to work. With an M.B.A. and an address in an affluent St. Louis suburb, his rate was $558 a year. The CFA then changed his rating profile to find the effect of:
- Less education, a $71 increase.
- Unemployment, an $84 increase.
- Moving to an urban ZIP code, a $347 increase (see "How your ZIP code drives up your car insurance").
- A gap in coverage, a $638 increase.
- Installment payments, $60 (see "Payment plans can increase the cost of your insurance").
None of those factors means the Taurus owner is a worse driver.
Where the money is
Every insurance company sets its own rates, deciding how much each factor raises the risk of a claim being filed. But by law, each insurer must apply that rating formula to every driver equally within that state. For example, insurers can't levy a surcharge for speeding tickets on drivers in some ZIP codes but not in others.
The nonprofit CFA says insurance companies get around the rules by charging more for rating factors and coverages likely to be shared by low-income drivers. Its analysis found some insurers charged more for bare-minimum policies than for those with more coverage.
In some cases, insurers grossly overpriced coverage for drivers carrying minimum levels of coverage by many thousands of dollars, the CFA says. In states where credit is a legally allowed rating factor, drivers with poor credit histories pay as much as 25% more, the CFA says. (Estimate your credit score for free.)
Insurers argue that factors such as occupation and credit are clearly correlated to the risk of a claim. The CFA says that kind of thinking leaves good drivers unfairly paying rates they don't deserve and can't afford.
"It is difficult to avoid the conclusion," the CFA report says, "that major insurers are far more interested in selling auto insurance to higher-income families."
Is pay-per-mile the answer?
The CFA suggests several possible remedies:
- Lowered mandatory liability limits in some states.
- More state-run insurance programs for drivers below an income threshold.
- More aggressive examination of rating factors by state regulators, who must approve each company's formula for calculating rates.
- Development of pay-per-mile programs.
Every state except New Hampshire requires some minimum level of liability coverage, but those levels change from state to state. Even that limited coverage can be very expensive. Our own CarInsurance.com survey of bare-minimum rates found annual premiums ranging from $342 in Wisconsin to $1,422 in Washington, D.C. About 14% of drivers go without any coverage at all, according to the Insurance Research Council.
The CFA points out that technology developed to provide usage-based insurance -- that is, insurance rates based on the driver's recorded mileage and driving habits, pioneered by companies such as Progressive and State Farm -- could serve well in implementing pay-per-mile systems. Low-income families drive only about half as many miles as those in the highest brackets, the CFA notes.
More on CarInsurance.com and MSN Money:
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
ABOUT SMART SPENDING
LATEST BLOG POSTS
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
BLOGS WE LIKE
MUST-SEE ON MSN
- Video: Easy DIY smoked meats at home
A charcuterie master shares his process for cold-smoking meat at home.
- Jetpacks about to go mainstream
- Weird things covered by home insurance
- Bing: 70 percent of adults report 'digital eye strain'