Smart SpendingSmart Spending

Carnival games you should play (or skip)

If you're intent on winning a stuffed animal, play games that pit you against a lot of other players.

By MSN Money Partner Mar 15, 2011 9:35AM

This post comes from Jim Wang at partner blog Bargaineering.


My favorite part about spring, besides the good weather, is the arrival of carnivals.


Carnivals are little bastions of legalized gambling wrapped up in funnel cake, sometimes less-than-safe rides and bright flashing lights. I love carnivals because you can walk around for free, listen to the cheer of the crowd as someone wins an oversized stuffed animal, and enjoy the outdoors while sampling a bit of capitalism here or there.


The cornerstone of every carnival is the game area. I say it's legalized gambling because otherwise rational people hand over real money to play fake games and win stuffed prizes.


When you go to a casino, you know all the games have a house edge. When you go to a carnival, you know all the games are rigged. If you insist on playing, as I do, it's important to maximize your fun. If maximizing your fun involves winning a prize, then we have a rule you must follow if you want to get the most for your money. If you are just playing to have fun and couldn't care less about winning a prize, play whatever makes you happy.

Games to play

The carnival game rule: Play games in which you compete against other players.


In these types of games, much like casino poker rooms, the carnival is just taking a little off the top by paying out prizes worth slightly less than the aggregate entry fee. Ten kids paying $2 a round means you can give out a $10 prize and still make $10. This is why the larger the competitive field, the bigger the prize.

When you play, wait until the field has enough players to qualify for the larger prizes. Your chances of winning go down but you truly score big when you do. (Eagle eye mathematicians will no doubt recognize your expected value won't change with more people playing, but the base expected value in this game is higher because someone will win each time the game runs. This is not proof that more is better, only that this game is better than others.)


The two most popular and common of these types of games are the one where you shoot a water cannon at a target (usually into a clown's mouth) and any horse racing skee-ball type of game.


Here's a quick tip on the water cannon games. Watch which cannon seems to shoot water out the fastest. The water pressure won't be the same on every gun -- it's simply not possible -- so find the gun (or ask the operator) that seems to have the greatest pressure and use it.

The only exception to the carnival rule is the game where someone has to guess your weight, age, or month of your birthday. The game is still rigged, because each prize is going to be less than the cost of playing the game, but you can still leave feeling like a winner when they guess incorrectly.


Games to skip

In general, skip any game that relies on you beating the house. Each game is rigged in its own special way and beating it will require you to do something very few people do. Here are the most popular house games and how they screw you:

  • Basketball: In this game, you're trying to sink a basketball shot with the rim that's much farther away. A regulation basketball rim is twice the size of a regulation basketball. A carnival basketball rim is certainly not twice the size of the regulation basketball you'll be shooting. Not only is the rim smaller, it and the backboard are harder, and sometimes the basketball is smaller than regulation size.
  • Darts: In this game, you're trying to pop a balloon tied to a board. What makes this difficult is that the balloons are not fully inflated, the darts are dull, and they may be more heavily weighted on the tip. When you do hit one, the dull-tipped darts slide off the skin of the not-fully-inflated balloons.
  • Shooting out a star: You try to shoot out a red star on a white piece of paper using a BB rifle. The only way to beat this game is to shoot a circle around the star and have it fall out. You don't have enough pellets to knock out all of the red paper. You must cut the star out. Good luck.

If you are intent on beating the carnival at its own games, I recommend checking out this guide to beating carnival games. The guide gives you the best chance at winning these, and many other rigged carnival games.


More from Bargaineering and MSN Money:



Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.


Smart Spending brings you the best money-saving tips from MSN Money and the rest of the Web. Join the conversation on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.