Smart SpendingSmart Spending

7 painful changes to long-term care

Insurance for long-term care is undergoing a transformation that will be financially challenging for aging consumers.

By MSN Money Partner Sep 20, 2012 2:09PM

This post comes from Barbara Marquand at partner site logoAs the U.S. population ages, the long-term-care insurance industry is suffering growing pains.


Senior woman on wheelchair looking out of window with blinds © Design Pics, Don Hammond, Design Pics, Getty ImagesSome insurers have called it quits. Others are suspending sales of the most generous benefits and tightening up underwriting. And many are increasing premiums on existing policies.


Buyers now pay more for less coverage and face tougher health requirements to qualify for the best rates. (See: "Tips for buying long-term care insurance amid rising rates.")


The changes come as insurers grapple with big losses on older policies.


"Many insurance companies priced those policies based on erroneous assumptions," says Christopher Kimball, a certified financial planner in Lakewood, Wash.


Policyholders filed claims at earlier ages and lived longer than expected. Meanwhile, an unusually small percentage of customers let their policies lapse, which meant more customers eventually filed claims than insurers projected. Those factors, combined with historically low interest rates, created a perfect storm to challenge the industry. Insurers invest premiums and use the returns to help pay for benefits. Low interest rates make it tough for insurance companies to get the returns they need to make money or break even.


Here are seven consequences of the industry's evolution and how the changes affect you:


1. Fewer insurance companies offering coverage

"In the early 1990s, over 100 companies were selling long-term-care insurance," says Murray Gordon, founder and CEO of MAGA, a long-term-care insurance agency in the Chicago area. "Now we have six or eight companies with good ratings."


Allianz Life left in 2009, and MetLife pulled out in 2010. This year Prudential Financial quit selling individual long-term-care policies, and Unum Group exited the group market. Remaining players -- including Genworth, TransAmerica, John Hancock, Mutual of Omaha, and Massachusetts Mutual Insurance (MassMutual) -- are redesigning products.


"For us, these are moves that enable us to stay in the market," says Steve Zabel, Genworth's senior vice president of long-term care.


2. Long-term-care insurance premium hikes

Already covered? Your premiums probably will go up, if they haven't already. Kimball says one of his clients was hit recently with a 90% premium increase.


In an Aug. 1 earnings call, Genworth executive vice president Patrick B. Kelleher said his company will ask state regulators for approval of premium increases on many of its policyholders. The increases will average more than 50% over the next five years on older policies marketed roughly through 2003, and more than 25% over five years on most of the earliest of the company's newer generation of products, which were marketed after 2003.


"Previously, we had asked for more frequent, lower increases, but we will pursue fewer, larger increases going forward," he said.


Says Kimball: "People shouldn't get too angry when they get premium increases because it means the company is going to be there to pay claims." 

3. No more lifetime or unlimited benefits on new policies

A long-term-care policy lets you get reimbursed for care up to a certain dollar amount per day. Policies with lifetime benefits pay up to that daily limit for as many years as you need care. Without lifetime benefits, a policy sets a cap on the total amount of care you receive.


Insurers have suspended sales of lifetime benefits because they found that policyholders who had them tended to file claims earlier than those who had a limited amount of coverage, says Lisa McAree, a long-term-care insurance specialist in Boston. 


Gordon says he doesn't expect to see a return of lifetime benefits.


"Many in the industry became uncomfortable with these, and they're hard to price," Zabel says.


4. Less -- or more expensive -- protection for inflation

Inflation protection riders increase the dollar limit on daily benefits by a certain percentage each year to protect you from rising health care costs.


The standard inflation rider used to be a 5% compound increase, which would double your daily benefit limit in 14 1/2 years. Premiums for that type of rider have increased 30% to 60%, McAree says, and some insurers are no longer offering it. The best you can get from some carriers is a 3% compound inflation protection rider, she says.


5. Limited-pay policies disappearing

Limited-pay products let you pay off the policy over a certain period, such as 10 or 20 years. After that, you've got coverage and owe nothing in premiums.


McAree says John Hancock, Genworth, TransAmerica and MassMutual have all stopped selling 10-pay products -- policies you can pay off in 10 years.


6. Tougher to qualify for long-term-care insurance coverage

The application process for long-term-care insurance used to be quick and easy. "When I go back 37 years ago, one company had an 8 1/2-by-11-inch piece of paper -- that was their application," Gordon says.


Now insurers are requesting more detailed health information. "A lot of carriers are starting to ask for physician records for younger people," says Steve Casto, the founder and president of Strategic Wealth Solutions in Omaha, Neb. Until recently, that hadn't been the case for applicants in their 40s and early 50s, he says.


Genworth will require blood and lab tests for applicants for a new long-term-care insurance product it plans to introduce in 2013, and it will take gender into consideration when pricing policies. Traditionally, long-term-care insurers did not require lab work, and they rated men and women the same.

7. Costlier coverage

Prices for new policies have increased by as much as 17% in the past year, according to the American Association for Long Term Care Insurance, which analyzed premiums for the most popular policies offered by 10 leading insurers.


"It's really about getting the right price point for the risk that we're taking on," Zabel says. Genworth recently reduced discounts for spouses to 20% from 40%.


Despite all the changes, McAree says she thinks long-term-care insurance is here to stay. Insurers, she says, are making the necessary adjustments to remain in the industry, and some of those that left the market could return eventually.


"I wouldn't be nervous about it," she says. "Insurance companies have gone in and out of markets for years."


More on and MSN Money:

Sep 21, 2012 12:01PM
From where I sit it looks more like an insurance company bonanza to me......  We paid for long term care insurance for quite a few years. Now that we are getting on to 70-ish we dropped it as the premiums skyrocketed to over $4K and on retirement income it became either pay the long term care insurance or pay the heating oil bill.  So, all those years we paid in $$$ are down the drain, I would have been better to put it in the bank at (choke) a whopping 1%. Good deal for the insurance companies.... collect the $$ for lots of years then jack the prices so people are forced to drop it before they get closer to really needing it....... then the old folks wind up on some form of Gov't assistance when they are dumped into the horror that is titled nursing home..... I'd wonder what percentage of people pay into these policies but never use them and/or had to drop them like we did?
Sep 21, 2012 2:55PM
I bought long-term care insurance when young enough that premiums were affordable.  Since then premiums have gone up, coverage is less, and undoubtedly premiums will increase again in the near future.  

I put long-term care insurance in the same bucket as a lot of financial advice I was given years ago which included investments and other types of insurance.  This was all to set up for a relatively comfortable and worry-free retirement.  Boy, have times changed!  Now I'm neither comfortable nor worry-free.  I fear I will become one of those 47% of victims and moochers.
Mar 16, 2014 5:41PM

Ditto all the above.  There should be some protection for promises made that if LTC insurance if purchased at an earlier age would be not be cost prohibitive due to hikes in premiums.

Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.


Smart Spending brings you the best money-saving tips from MSN Money and the rest of the Web. Join the conversation on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.