1/4/2012 7:30 PM ET|
5 tax breaks help rich get richer
Because the wealthier have a higher overall tax rate, when they get a tax break, it's far more valuable for them than it is for the Average Joe.
When it comes to tax deductions, it is good to be rich -- the richer, the better.
Middle-class America enjoys some of the same tax breaks as the wealthy on things like the mortgage interest on home loans, capital gains on retirement investments and donations to charity.
However, the rich enjoy these deductions and others to a wildly disproportionate degree when compared with the rest of taxpayers. According to the National Priorities Project, America's top earners got an average tax cut of $66,384 in 2011 while the bottom 20% realized an average tax savings of about $107.
Seth Hanlon, the director of fiscal reform for the Center for American Progress, says that while all tax breaks are well-intended, the "upside-down" nature of some cause them to miss their target.
"Most people don't see these as being government expenditures, but from an economic and budget point of view, they're really the same thing as programs that spend money directly," says Hanlon. "There are ways to reform them to make them work better."
Many agree, including President Barack Obama, Warren Buffett and Bill Gates.
Here are five tax deductions that help the rich get richer.
1. Mortgage interest
The mortgage interest deduction on your federal tax return is intended to encourage homeownership by giving you a tax break on the interest you pay on your house note.
There is little question it benefits millions of middle-class homeowners as well as the wealthy. But does it provide a compelling financial incentive to own rather than rent? Not so much.
According to a study (.pdf file) by the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania, mortgage-interest deductions for households with incomes between $40,000 and $75,000 average just $523, while households with incomes above $250,000 enjoy an average write-off of $5,459, or more than 10 times as much.
You must itemize on IRS Form 1040 Schedule A to claim the deduction. If you do, you can also deduct the interest paid on a second home. The rich do both, but most of us do neither.
"For millions of taxpayers, therefore, the mortgage-interest deduction provides no added incentive to buy a home," says Hanlon. "It makes no sense in terms of targeting the incentive at the people who need or could use it."
2. Capital gains
Why does Buffett, a billionaire, have a lower income tax rate than his secretary?
Two words: capital gains.
Long-term capital gains, which derive from the sale of investments such as stocks and bonds held for more than a year, are taxed at 15%. That's well below the 35% maximum tax rate on ordinary income such as wages.
The preferential tax treatment of capital gains is widely viewed as regressive, because the rich, who derive a disproportionate share of their income from capital gains, pay less than half of the tax rate on that income compared with middle-class wage earners.
"Capital gains are highly concentrated," says Rebecca Wilkins, senior counsel for Citizens for Tax Justice. "Most of the capital gains are earned by folks in the top 10%, and it's even concentrated more than that. So the capital gains tax break, which is a 20 percentage-point difference in the amount of tax that is paid on those, is going almost all to the top 5%."
In fact, Americans with an annual income of $1 million or more, or 0.3% of all taxpayers, enjoy 70% of the capital gains benefit, says Hanlon.
The favorable capital gains rate is expected to save the wealthy (and cost Uncle Sam) $38.5 billion for fiscal 2012, according to the Office of Management and Budget.
3. Step-up in basis
If the wealthy enjoy roughly $40 billion in tax breaks each year thanks to the favorable 15% capital gains rate, their heirs save even more, courtesy of the "step-up in basis rule" in the U.S. tax code.
What's the step-up all about? Essentially, it allows the wealthy to pass along assets that have grown in value to their heirs without ever paying a dime of taxes on it.
Under special Internal Revenue Service inheritance rules, when you inherit assets such as stock, real estate or a closely held business, you are allowed to step up their basis -- what the deceased originally paid for them -- to their current fair-market value. Therefore, when you sell the assets, you would be taxed only on their gain in value from the time you inherited them.
Step-up in basis is expected to save the wealthy (and cost Uncle Sam) $61.5 billion for fiscal 2012, according to the Office of Management and Budget.
"Not surprisingly, this tax expenditure overwhelmingly benefits those who inherit from large estates because it allows gains to escape capital gains taxes if held until death," says Hanlon.
4. Retirement savings
Tax-deferred retirement plans are designed to help all Americans save for retirement. In 2011, Americans will save (and Uncle Sam will lose) $142 billion in taxes by sheltering their personal income in 401k plans, pension plans and individual retirement accounts, according to the U.S. budget.
Because the wealthy have more to save, they tend to reap more of the tax benefits of saving for retirement.
According to the Tax Policy Center, the top 20% of income earners enjoy 80% of the tax write-offs for retirement saving, while the bottom 60% take advantage of a whopping 7% of the tax savings.
Which is understandable, considering that the higher your income, the more likely you are to own a 401k plan with generous employer contributions. Nearly half of all Americans do not have access to employer retirement plans, and most who do can't afford to take full advantage of the tax incentive.
"It's, again, a question of targeting incentives," Hanlon says. "The tax benefits probably aren't as well-targeted as they should be. The wealthy probably would save regardless of the tax benefit."
5. Charitable deduction: Good cause, policy flaws
The charitable-giving deduction effectively operates as a federal matching program: If you make a charitable donation, you get a tax break. In fiscal 2011, the charitable deduction saved Americans (and cost Uncle Sam) $53.7 billion, according to the U.S. budget.
The problem with the charitable deduction is similar to that of the mortgage income tax break: The value of the deduction increases with income.
"If I give $1,000 to charity and I'm in a 10% tax bracket, I get $100 back on my taxes," says Wilkins. "But if I'm in a 35% tax bracket, I get $350 back from the federal government."
Plus, you have to itemize on IRS Form 1040 Schedule A to claim the charitable deduction.
"If we're trying to encourage charitable giving, we should be encouraging people with less money than people with more money to make those gifts," Wilkins says.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.