Has Facebook lost its cool?

Should Facebook investors worry that it's losing the young? Yes. Twitter, Tumblr may benefit from teens’ disaffection.

By MSN Money Partner Jun 1, 2012 10:53AM

By Jon Freidman for MarketWatch


Can being on Facebook kill a teenager’s prospects of having a bright career?



Can it make a kid feel uncool? Definitely.


A Los Angeles Times piece reached those conclusions, measuring the social-media preferences of the coveted teen demographic.


Should Facebook (FB) fret about the Times story and worry that it may be losing its hold on a coveted age group? You bet.


In the volatile world of the social media, “product” perception often becomes reality. Remember, it took very little time for Facebook -- Twitter, too -- to become all the rage, overtaking the last generation of hot social media sites.


Now, if teenagers begin to drop out of Facebook and move onto the next big thing, look out.


Is your future boss on Facebook?

Teenagers “worry that one wrong move on Facebook could hurt their chances of getting to college or landing a job,” according to the L.A. Times


I believe it, too. I know of one summer-job applicant who uses an alias on Facebook to maintain some distance from prospective employers on Wall Street.


The Times story should send tremors through Facebook’s headquarters, as the suddenly embattled company tries to pick up the pieces following a spate of negative publicity about its initial public offering. Facebook stock fell into the $27 range this week. The IPO was priced at $38 and started trading on May 18.


At a time when Mark Zuckerberg’s flashy company is on the defensive over the flop, the last thing the company needs to see is a prominent newspaper questioning its growth.

Madison Avenue may begin to wonder, too, about Facebook’s long-term growth scenario. What if the momentum builds among young people that Tumblr and Twitter are more appealing social-media outlets for them?


Consumer product companies try to attract young people to their ranks because this demographic spends lots of dough on the latest gadgets.


Career worries are just the tip of the iceberg.


Parents should not be 'friends'

Facebook may say it is a victim of its great popularity. As young people first became hooked on it, it was inevitable that their ever-curious parents began to wonder what the hubbub was about.


Naturally, the older generation found the same sort of value in the various social media as their kids had. They, too, could use Facebook to find out what new and old friends and family members were up to, learn what people were thinking about movies and restaurants and the like and communicate efficiently by employing Instant Messaging.


Horror of horrors! Suddenly, to the kids, Facebook seemed a lot less exclusive -- and not nearly as cool. The teens felt they had lost a lot of the personal power that Facebook had once offered to them -- and, in a very real practical sense, they had forfeited a feeling of privacy.


After all, as long as their parents could become their “friends” on Facebook -- or find ways to monitor what their children were writing about themselves -- they had no secrets from their mothers and fathers. Their parents could effectively know what they were thinking, where they were going, and with whom.


Rebels aren't on Facebook

What’s the fun of being a teenager at all if you don’t even have the power to rebel against your parents? This kind of phenomenon has happened before.


Rock and roll music was once the domain of teenagers, and loving the hottest bands that everyone’s parents hated was a good feeling.


Teens in those days blasted their favorite bands on home stereos and secretly delighted in having a sense of empowerment when their parents could only shout helplessly, “Turn that screaming off!” (Yes, I can speak from my experience.) The music was theirs and theirs only.


Then, the old guard slowly but surely began to embrace the same kind of music. Even worse, you started hearing the songs being used in television commercials and radio jingles, and teens began thinking that rock and roll was pretty unhip, after all.


Eventually, rap and hip-hop -- emerging as new and dangerous forms of youth music -- quickly became the most popular entertainment among the young people.


Social media moves at lightning pace. Popular tastes can change overnight.


What’s cool today could be old news tomorrow. Rock and roll came and went.


Who knows? Facebook could be next.


More at MarketWatch.com


Jun 1, 2012 5:00PM

Do you think a billionaire cares?


No one cares what Zuckerberg thinks. What part of "yesterday" don't you understand?

Jun 3, 2012 5:25PM

Timeline is driving individuals away from Facebook. 

Jun 1, 2012 1:19PM
Jun 4, 2012 9:11AM
Never had it. People don't have real lives so they troll the internet for one. Virtual lives include friends, fads, news, sex and everything. So sad.
Jun 4, 2012 5:10PM

People finally realized that Facebook's utility purpose of being able to keep in contact with old friends is not worth the risk of having the whole world be able to see your "private" profile posts, opinions and articles that you wish to share. Especially when there is this awesome new invention called email where you can do all that and still have some semblance of privacy.


I personally haven't used it in a few months other than to pop in and say happy birthday or to accept a party e-vite. With more than half of the page dedicated to advertizing and polls Facebook is not so much "social media" as it is a free corporate marketing database with an IM program and personal blog space.


People want to express themselves openly and freely on the internet with the caveat of anonymity. Without the anonymity to hide behind people can't be the racist, homophobic, godless heathen, libtard, teabagging, hippie, liberal elite, bible thumping brainwashed zealots that they really are for fear of having to accept the reality of what being that type of person actually means when it is attached to their real name and picture. With anonymity people can sit behind their avatar and alias while spouting all the rhetoric and nonsenseical jibberish they can possibly muster all while keeping their poker face on. (of course I see the irony of what I am saying in this paragraph while hiding behind my own alias, and those who appreciate sarcasm and irony will get that)


People hate to be accountable for what they say and/or do or what ideals they are beholden to.

Jun 4, 2012 8:51AM
What a pitifully useless, overblown and overpriced company!  Anyone who listened to all of that hype and invested any significant amount of money in it, should be spanked and sent to their room.
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.


Start investing in technology companies with help from financial writers and experts who know the industry best. Learn what to look for in a technology company to make the right investment decisions.





Quotes delayed at least 15 min