Wal-Mart's new light bulbs have a dark side
The retail giant finally has LEDs at a price its customers can afford. That's a nightmare scenario for the supplier.
Many consumers are still ignoring the quickest way to lower their utility bills.
Swapping out all of your older light bulbs for new light-emitting diode bulbs can save hundreds of dollars in power costs. And the fact that these bulbs can last up to 25,000 hours means you're all set for the next decade.
This new technology has been a notable success story for Home Depot (HD) and its key LED supplier, Cree (CREE). You would think that Wal-Mart (WMT) would also like to have been a major vendor of this cutting-edge, cost-saving lighting technology. But the LEDs it sold from many manufacturers have always been a bit too pricey for Wal-Mart's rank-and-file shoppers.
Yet a little-noticed announcement from GE (GE) changes everything.
Wal-Mart's new Great Value LED lights, made by privately held TCP Inc., are priced under $10, which is crucial in two respects. It's a price point that lures many more consumers to make the change, considering these bulbs can now pay for themselves in terms of power consumption in just two or three years. And it's a nightmare price point for Cree, which appears hard-pressed to make profits at such a price.
At least that's the view of Piper Jaffray's Jagadish Iyer: "At a $10 price point, we see a big squeeze on profitability at least initially for the OEMs, as we have highlighted in the case of Cree, where we think its light bulbs currently carry negative gross margins."
For a bit of context, Wal-Mart is selling GE's dimmable 60-watt-equivalent LED bulb for just under $11 -- roughly $2 less than Cree's price at Home Depot.
A long climb back
Make no mistake, Cree deserves a huge amount of credit for stimulating demand in the LED market, which had been slow to take off in 2010 and 2011. The company pushed hard to hammer down its own costs, getting many of its bulbs below the $20 price point in recent years. That's why I thought this stock was so appealing back when it traded for $20 in early 2012.
Yet as Cree's shares have now rebounded sharply, investors may be ignoring the serious challenges ahead for the company. Simply put, industry production capacity is growing at a rapid pace, which will surely impact pricing and gross margins.
Across the globe, companies such as China's Yankon, Elec-Tech International, and San'an, Taiwan's Epistar, and South Korea's LG-Innotek and Seoul Semiconductor are ramping up production of "good enough" products that may not be quite as leading edge as Cree's LED products, but good enough to be long-lasting and meet low price points.
In effect, LED lighting is about to be hit by the "Wal-Mart effect," where price trumps all, leading industry margins to remain wafer-thin.
Gross margins at a peak?
Cree's fiscal fourth-quarter results (for the quarter ended June) were just shy of forecasts, and tepid fiscal 2014 guidance has led the EPS consensus to drop from $1.87 to $1.77 over the past 60 days. D.A. Davidson's Avinash Kant used the quarterly results as the basis for a ratings downgrade to "neutral" (lowering his price target to $65), noting concerns that slower than expected margin expansion and revenue growth leaves very little room for upward earnings revisions.
Analysts have been continually forecasting margin gains as Cree more fully utilizes its manufacturing capacity, but so far, that's just not happening.
Cree has been able to make major gains in terms of its manufacturing efficiency and overhead absorption, but ever-tougher industry pricing pressures keep the company from benefiting from lower costs.
Will margins ever rebound?
Despite those apparent challenges, many of which reappeared on the fourth-quarter conference call in early August when shares slumped below $60, they've rebounded once again to near the 52-week high of $76 as investors again focus on the positive traits of the LED lighting industry.
But at current prices, these shares are no bargain, trading for nearly 35 times projected fiscal 2015 profits. Yet it's fair to wonder if the rapid fresh price declines for LED light bulbs (led by Wal-Mart and GE) will make it impossible for Cree to deliver the margin growth that the most bullish investors are anticipating.
Risks to consider: As an upside risk, Cree has long been seen as a buyout candidate, and some of the recent share price strength is attributable to buyout rumors.
Action to take: When shares of Cree were widely reviled in early 2012, shares traded for little more than 10 times forward earnings. Less than two years later, investors are now according a much richer multiple to this stock. As a result, Cree now faces a much higher hurdle. Investors may be in for a rude surprise if the company's profit margins remain stuck in neutral in coming quarters.
David Sterman does not personally hold positions in any securities mentioned in this article.
StreetAuthority LLC does not hold positions in any securities mentioned in this article.
More from StreetAuthority
- Forget Bernanke, Invest Alongside His Likely Successor
- Profit From The Age Of The Drone With This Secret Stock
- Pocket $1,333 Per Month In Rent... Without Owning Property
I am not a Wal-Mart shopper, but I would never, ever, pay $11 for a light bulb ! I'll put those in the same category as a $2000 laptop, $150 jeans, $75 steak dinner or $400 bottle of wine. And then I'll smile at the world since I am very
comfortable in retirement with plenty of money in the bank, freedom to live how I want, no mortgage on a large house, and a three year old car. I didn't get there paying $11 for a light bulb !!!
"Long lasting!" my butt!
I took the bait...4,5 times...maybe more....not ONE of my LED's lasted much more than the standard bulbs they replaced. MAYBE 6-8 months....maybe...in some of our most used lamps or closets.
Fool me once....you know the rest. I have a cabinet full of good ole regular light bulbs now...in all wattages....most cost $1 something for a 4 pack - it will be LONG time before I recoup the costs of those LED's that I overpaid for!
Lets do the math normal new low watt lights (curly light bulbs) you can get 8 60 watt for 11 dollars
about same price as one led bulb. so cost difference is $9.26 both say they will last about 4 years
one the curly uses 13 watts then other uses 9.5 watts
assume the bulb is on about 6 hours a day for 4 years that is 3.5 watts times 6*365*4 or 30 kilowatts hours of electrical power being used
at about 8 cents for a kilowatt hour this comes to a whopping $2.45 over the life span of the product
take additional cost $9.26 - $2.45 and you have lost about $6.81 by buying the LED's
that is a carbon tax of a lot as the worse coal burning plant produces just over 2 pounds of CO2 for 1 kilowatt. so we are talking 60 pounds of CO2 here (30 kilowatts) at a cost of $6.81 moving it up to tons means you are paying a carbon tax of $227 by using these bulbs
currently Great Britain has a $25 dollar carbon tax -- which will reach $38 a ton by 2019
So these LED bulbs have to drop in price to about $1.50 in order to be as good a deal as the curly bulbs.
good thing I've stocked up on the old fashion not-gonna-poison-you kind of bulbs! you know, the ones that don't cost 12 bucks each!
I read about one ingenuous fellow who, after the banning on the sale of incandescent light bulbs, was marketing them as 'heaters' to get around the sale as light bulbs. Brilliant.
But anyway, I don't give a sh** what Sprawl Mart sells or doesn't sell. I never go there unless I have no other option, even if it costs me more.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
The solid report comes a month after the retailer closed all of its Canadian operations.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.