Watching the banks for signs of trouble
We've seen the big dividend-paying consumer goods sector correct sharply. The same could happen to other sectors.
By Marc Courtenay
As I wrote Wednesday on TheStreet, even the treasured consumer goods sector isn't sacrosanct in today's economic climate. The same is true for the banking stocks and the financial sector. Some meaningful headwinds like higher mortgage rates, a spike in the price of oil and the persistent rumors of a global slowdown linger on.
TheStreet's Jim Cramer commented on Wednesday about the current interest rate scenario and what may be on the horizon. His view is a temporarily disturbing one that holds true for all the big-name, dividend-paying stocks.
He wrote, "I think it says interest rates are still going higher and today's climb back up is for real. These stocks [consumer goods in particular] are all part of that bond market equivalent trade and they failed to rally when rates dipped back down the other day. This tells me that the decline in rates isn't for real and we will soon see 3% on the 10 year Treasury note, about a quarter of a point from where it is now."
Jim has a gift for saying a lot in just a few lines. If his predictive gifts are as well honed, we'd be smart to keep an eye on this situation. How will that "bond market equivalent trade" affect other sectors?
The big banks, including investment banks and the more traditional ones, could be the next canary in the coal mine. Rising interest rates can positively impact the sector's "carry trade" but...
Borrowing costs could really put the kibosh to the financial sector's lending business. I'm in the camp that doesn't believe the Federal Reserve is going to sit idly by and let its "children" suffer, so I remain optimistic.
If we look at the iShares Dow Jones U.S. Financial Services ETF (IYG) on a one-year basis we can see some clues concerning what may be unfolding.
IYG has had a breath-taking 10-month rally from November 2012 to the peak earlier this month. The same could be said for the three largest holdings, as illustrated in the one-year chart below.
The epic run-up of these companies has pushed the dividend yield-to-price downward. WFC currently yields 2.91%, JPM is slightly better at 3% and C pays 4 cents per year -- and perhaps it's the federal government's involvement in the stock that keeps it at current levels.
But as we stare at these charts, all seasoned investors may be concluding, "What goes way up must come way down." At some point that may happen, but not while current Fed policies remain in place.
Also, keep in mind that the big banks are selling at low forward (one-year) PE multiples. Citigroup's forward PE is less than 9. JPM's current and forward PE is slightly above 8. Wells Fargo is trading at the richest multiple with a current PE of about 11 and a forward PE of slightly above 10.
As Real Money analyst Sham Gad confessed Wednesday, "I can't seem to figure out why the financial industry still remains so shunned by a large part of the investment community. You can't blame one industry or group for the Great Recession; an economic calamity requires multiple constituents. And banks are again making gobs of money and isn't that what investors really want to see anyway?"
Perhaps so, but investors also want to buy at lower prices. That's why I'd recommend the possibility of a return to price levels we experienced in the "June swoon."
On June 24, IYG traded at an intraday low of $68.76. WFC corrected on the same day to as low as $39.40. JPM went down to $50.11, just below where it traded on Wednesday. And the government's step-child, Citigroup, pulled back to $45.06, about 6.7% below Wednesday's closing price of $48.31.
So keep in mind we may have a short-term "perfect storm" that includes the worst-case-scenario about the escalating situation in Syria. Plus, a lot of investors and traders are still out on vacation.
This reminds me of other temporary high-risk, high-anxiety times when the stock market needed a good cooling down before the next move higher.
The financial sector should be a good harbinger if that's what's coming. My mentors have always discouraged being a bettor when tensions and uncertainties are as high as they are now. One seasoned colleague said today, "This isn't a time for big bets, but for careful preparation for possible buying opportunities. What's unfolding before our eyes is about politics, power struggles, reactive fear and not investing." I would agree!
He also defined in his opinion what investing is all about: "Investing is about growth, valuations, expanding economies, increasing profits, and a rise in spending trends." Hopefully the Fed and the FOMC are watching carefully and will keep the markets in check.
As we have watched the big dividend-paying consumer goods sector correct sharply, we get a taste as to what can happen to other sectors. Watch the big bank stocks for signs of a malaise that may go viral.
At the time of publication the author had no position in any of the stocks mentioned.
More from TheStreet.com
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
3 stocks will be in the spotlight Thursday as investors try to make sense of the numbers from the sector.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.