Why is a calm market so scary?

The last time investors were this blasé about a record-breaking stock market, things were about to get very ugly.

By MSN Money Partner Jun 5, 2014 12:57PM
Image: Stock market © Zurbar/age fotostockBy Pat Regnier, Money.com

Market pundits are beginning to freak out about the shortage of people freaking out.

Indeed, the last time investors were this blasé about a record-breaking stock market, things were about to get very ugly. 

On the other hand, there are reasons to doubt that another big storm is brewing.

The stock market hasn't just been hitting new records. Its rise has been accompanied by a noticeable lack of anxiety among investors.
Here is what's happened to the VIX -- also known as the fear index -- a measure of the volatility anticipated by traders in S&P 500 index options. (Investors use options to bet on or to hedge against future movements in the market, so the way they are priced can give you an insight into what investors expect.)

Now market pundits are beginning to freak out a bit about the shortage of people freaking out.

Why? Three words: The Great Moderation. That’s what self-congratulatory policymakers and bankers had started calling the decades leading up to 2007. Inflation was low. GDP had smoothed out. Markets were calm, too. And then -- boom!

Josh Brown last week at the Reformed Broker:

Volatility is nowhere to be found -- not in currencies, in fixed income or in equities. Complacency rules the day as investors and institutions gradually add more risk, using leverage and increasingly exotic vehicles to reach for diminishing returns in an aging bull market. This as economic growth -- led by housing and consumer spending -- stalls out and the Fed removes stimulus that never really worked in the first place.

On Monday, Mohamed El-Erian on Monday raised the possibility of another "Minsky moment," last seen in 2008:

[The late economist Hyman] Minsky went further in demonstrating how stability ends up breeding instability . . . At some point, financial stability becomes too much of a good thing, because it encourages excessive and ultimately irresponsible risk taking by individuals and institutions. In the process, the economic system and, therefore, collective interest are threatened.

The Buttonwood columnist at the The Economist sounded a little less worried:

But this feels nothing like the late 1990s when equity markets seemed obviously bubbly; flows into equity mutual funds have been very restrained and there is no sense of popular enthusiasm for the market (depending on who you believe, in 1929, smart insiders sold stocks because elevator operators or shoeshine operators were dispensing tips).

What we have is a very odd market, in which volatility is extremely low, and economic optimism seems high as judged by the equity market but not by the bond markets, emerging markets or commodity prices.

One thing about the Great Moderation. Even at the time, people noted that despite big-picture, macroeconomic calm, individuals and households experienced considerable volatility in income, and not much growth. This turned out to be the economy's Achilles' heel: Once real-estate prices backed up, it became clear how much many households were depending on debt to stay afloat.

More than five years after the crash, Zillow reports that nearly 19 percent of homes are still underwater, meaning borrowers owe more than the house is worth. Households balance sheets are wobbly. Investors may be calm, but on Main Street the economy continues to feel precarious.

More from Money.com

Jun 5, 2014 1:21PM
After 5 years of lunacy a calm market is scary to most.
Jun 5, 2014 1:13PM
"The stock market hasn't just been hitting new records. Its rise has been accompanied by a noticeable lack of anxiety among investors."

Well isn't that the proof needed to show that most are just as Naive now as they have been in the Past. All they care about currently, stocks went up, until that stops, don't expect the lack of anxiety to really change. Once the House of Cards implodes, Then you will see just what anxiety really means.
Jun 5, 2014 2:46PM
Less volatility means less commissions. Money mangers don't like that at all but it's great for the buy and hold invertor. Nothing wrong with slow and steady in a world full of fast and furious..
Jun 5, 2014 1:19PM
Jun 5, 2014 2:23PM

The VIX is down, New Records (ex NASQ) set on a daily, weekly basis...

New Foreign capital coming into U.S. Markets...

QE slowly being taken out of equation...

Trading very thin, more so then usually...?

Older investors, past investors entering back into Markets on a low key basis.

Stocks or shares of Good Companies creeping up...Dividends have been slowly increasing.

Stock buybacks have effected prices and bolstered Company Values.

No Churn in the Markets are the only thing making the Big Boys nervous...THEY CAN'T MAKE $$.

Their hands and money are tied like the Small Investors.

Jun 5, 2014 3:05PM
The market pundits are scared because they can't drive the market and make money. In a slightly increasing or decreasing market the investors are making or losing a little money. If you buy and hold the industry makes no money. It's only when they can get a panic driving the market in either direction that the buying and selling really take off and commissions flow. This explains how news on China or XYZ one day can send the marketing crashing and a day or two later no change in that news causes the market to recover. An active market is good for the people running the market. If there are exotic products or deals being offered its because the industry is not making the money on the "calm" market and they are looking for other revenue sources. It's called investing not betting. A calm market is best for the regular investor.
Jun 5, 2014 3:23PM
Spending your days quoting posters on here are we?  Seems like a total waste of time to me.  Trying to prove to everyone how wrong they are and how right you are.......
I think Tog is doing just fine, and so am I, and many others.  Forecasting the end of days and repeating over and over again why everything is rigged....... 
Yet I've made a ton of money since 2009 so..... go me go!!!!
You and many others have been saying once the bond buying stops the world will end, it's been slowing every month and markets have gone up not down, so.......... find a new hobby maybe?
Jun 5, 2014 3:53PM
Duh! The markets been propped up by easy stimulus money that isn't being invested elsewhere. The market is at record highs; do you really believe that we have a record economy? ...Not!
Jun 5, 2014 3:00PM
The market appears to have been backfilling these past months in the 16 to 16.5 range.  Interest rates remain low.  I'm thinking we won't have a big sell off (crash) until a big jump in record highs - like in the 18 to 19 range then they'll be talking Dow 20,000.  Seems like that's the way it's gone historically.  Besides how are the big boys going to make any money if they can't lure the small investor in?  Interest rates will be the key as has always been the case.
Jun 5, 2014 2:45PM

"I'm not scared. . .I've been 'sitting on the sidelines' during this whole bull-run. . ."

Hmmmm, I don't know for sure, but that "sure as hell sounds scared" to me...??

Jun 5, 2014 3:41PM

Well,,, without the Fed dangling any new gimmicks to pump up the market it has been left to its own devices.  Picture a rocket at the top of its apogee.  Things are calm at the top but as it noses over things get exciting again.  What the Fed is worried about is that as they pull out, nothing else seems to be pushing the rocket. 

The bottom line is we are turning into an economy that doesn't need people to work for a living.  If you can't work, how can you buy the stuff the machines (or Chinese) are making.  Quite a conundrum.

Jun 5, 2014 1:19PM

"The Buttonwood columnist at the Economist sounded a little less worried:

But this feels nothing like the late 1990s when equity markets seemed obviously bubbly; flows into equity mutual funds have been very restrained and there is no sense of popular enthusiasm for the market"

Well if you don't or can't understand that equity markets are far more Bubbly now than then, then YOU should NOT be giving out investment advice. Don't mistake Breakouts in Modern Stock Markets to fundamentals nor Reality. We all know stocks can go much higher then anyone thinks before any Bubble Actually Burst. This has been no Different now then in the Past.
Jun 5, 2014 4:06PM

Boy is it only me or does the talk about market volume seemed to drop off the radar here for some reason?
Jun 5, 2014 3:42PM

The lull is because the media is not attacking the politics. When Bush was president there wasn't a week that went by without them talking about the deficient or high gas prices or something else. All you here in the media is how well things are and how much better they're getting. This doesn't make sense, all this new regulation driving prices up and tax increases make the economy better????

Higher taxes more regulation makes the economy better??? No

Jun 5, 2014 2:26PM
remember they can only rise so far before they fall
Jun 5, 2014 2:50PM
These bears have really missed out. Oh, they'll have their day, but will they have any money left?
Jun 5, 2014 4:54PM

A pound of pastrami is =          $13.89

A pound of chicken breast is=  $  9.89

a 1/2 gallon of chocolate milk= $  5.69  

If this isn't the "New Normal"

then INFLATION is about to burst

wide open.

And Wall Street will be the first bubble to pop..

Jun 5, 2014 2:50PM

CGT.....There she goes, blatting about the market, and then prattling about Obama...

                   TWO(2) THINGS SHE REALLY DOESN'T KNOW ABOUT....!!!

Jun 5, 2014 2:27PM
Jun 5, 2014 4:14PM
To stay on topic;
1. Many investors have stayed out of market and continue to do so.
2. Many investors don't see a reason to change course at this time.
3. Economic indicators have been mixed for some time now, no clear signal in direction or clear move to make.
4. The market has been some what stable the last month or so, day traders can't make moves if the market isn't moving.
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.


StockScouter rates stocks from 1 to 10, with 10 being the best, using a system of advanced mathematics to determine a stock's expected risk and return. Ratings are displayed on a bell curve, meaning there will be fewer ratings of 1 and 10 and far more of 4 through 7.

123 rated 1
262 rated 2
480 rated 3
651 rated 4
649 rated 5
629 rated 6
616 rated 7
496 rated 8
346 rated 9
111 rated 10

Top Picks

TAT&T Inc9



Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.

Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.

Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.