AOL: Will media laughingstock have the last laugh?
As investors await the company's Q1 earnings report on May 8, let's think back on what CEO Tim Armstrong and his charges have accomplished recently.
Last quarter, for the first time in eight long years, AOL's (AOL) revenues increased over the year before. The company's stock, after falling near $10 in 2011, now trades above $38. It has gained 50% over the last 12 months, and zoomed 32% in the first quarter of this year, surpassing the 10% gain by the S&P 500.
What a difference a decade makes.
AOL was hailed as the shining symbol of the new media when it acquired Time Warner (TWX) in 2000 in a deal valued at $350 billion -- making it then the largest transaction in history. Before long, however, the amalgamation was ridiculed as the worst deal in corporate American history. AOL was castigated by analysts, pundits and stock-pickers as the Pariah of Wall Street.
It didn't help that the combination was also plagued by endless internal strategic squabbles. I covered the blow-by-blow disintegration of AOL Time Warner, and I've never seen such backbiting, as the two merger partners continuously privately disparaged one another for years. Ultimately, and thankfully, the two companies split apart, with Time Warner spinning off AOL in 2009.
Two years later, AOL was making big headlines again, spending $315 million to buy The Huffington Post. If it wasn't clear before, it was now: AOL, the company that had been known for its Internet service and "You've Got Mail" slogan was a serious player in the media business, even if its profits still came largely from the dwindling dial-up subscriptions.
AOL's growth strategy now centers on content creation, directly pitting it against Marissa Mayer's Yahoo (YHOO). AOL is counting on The Huffington Post and the AOL On Network, a 14-channel video offering, to serve as catalysts. Google's (GOOG) YouTube still dominates online video viewership, but AOL is a (distant) second in the number of videos viewed, according to comScore. That's a promising sign since advertisers will pay more for video spots than traditional display ads. AOL’s overall traffic hasn’t grown much in recent years, but traffic to The Huffington Post has soared since the start of 2011.
Still, Armstrong and Arianna Huffington are betting on content at a precarious time for many content businesses. The advent of the Internet roiled the mainstream newspaper and magazine industries, forcing scores of them to go belly-up or radically change their publishing plans, wiping out decades of glorious traditions. The Internet advertising field is certainly not bullet-proof either. Online publishers have watched warily as their arena has been threatened by declining rates for web advertising. Yahoo, when it reported first-quarter earnings last week, disappointed analysts by posting a 7% drop in total revenue as its display advertising business weakened.
If AOL can avoid those kinds of disappointments, the investment community will continue to reward it. The stock surge has been fueled by AOL's $1 billion sale of patents last year, and its use of those proceeds to buy back shares. Some analysts, at least, are optimistic that operating results at AOL can continue to improve. AOL has impressed Barclays analyst Anthony DiClemente and others by cutting expenses and delivering that 4% increase in revenue last quarter, enabling the company to raise profits.
DiClemente suggested in a research report last month that AOL can bring on $100 million of annual profit by itself if it closes down its money-losing local-news network, Patch. If it keeps the local division, AOL has promised to have it break even by next year. DiClemente, who is more bullish on AOL's prospect than some other analysts, said the company's profit -- omitting interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization -- could soar 34% this year to $441 million.
After a difficult decade, we'll find out soon whether Armstrong & Co. can keep surprising the skeptics.
Jon Friedman is a contributor to The Fiscal Times.
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
With the universe of this category in its seasonal sweet spot, these picks have tailwinds propelling them into the new year.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.