Herbalife: Battle of the hedge funds

Loeb takes an 8.2% stake in the multi-level marketing company, countering Ackman allegations.

By Benzinga Jan 10, 2013 12:10PM
Person on scale Purestock SuperStockBy Scott Rubin

The Herbalife (HLF) saga is shaping up as the battle of the hedge fund giants. For those unfamiliar with the back-story, the stock has become one of the most controversial names on the New York Stock Exchange ever since hedge fund manager Bill Ackman of Pershing Square Capital Management revealed he was short more than $1 billion worth of HLF stock in December and called the company a "pyramid scheme."

While company executives have fiercely denied the accusations, the company received a vote of confidence Wednesday, when famed hedge fund manager Dan Loeb's Third Point Capital revealed that his fund has acquired an 8.2% stake valued at around $350 million in the embattled multi-level marketing company.

Later on in the day, however, The Wall Street Journal reported that the Securities and Exchange Commission was launching an inquiry into Herbalife, which sells nutrition and weight-loss products through a network of third-party distributors.

On Thursday, the company met with investors in an effort to counter Ackman's short attack and refute his allegations. As a result, the stock was up 3.5% in morning trading to $41.35.

Even prior to Ackman's short call, Herbalife's business model had garnered scrutiny. In April 2012, the stock touched all-time highs above $70 on the back of prolific revenue and earnings growth driven in large part by expansion in international markets. At the end of April, however, famed short-seller and value oriented hedge fund manager David Einhorn asked Herbalife's management some pointed questions on an earnings conference call.

Although a short position has never been confirmed, the mere possibility that Einhorn was sniffing around the company spooked the market. The stock subsequently fell under $50 where it remained in a range until Ackman's short attack in December.

On December 20, Bill Ackman gave a three hour presentation, which was accompanied by a 342-slide PowerPoint presentation, on his short thesis for Herbalife at the Ira Sohn Investment Conference which triggered a series of steep daily declines in the shares. The stock bottomed out at $25 on December 24 and has been steadily rising ever since as analysts and other investors have questioned the validity of Ackman's argument.

Herbalife also defended itself vigorously against the accusations. The company's CEO Michael Johnson accused Bill Ackman of "blatant market manipulation." He added that "This appears to be another attempt to illegally manipulate the market by a group of short sellers." On the company's investor relations website, Johnson also provides a detailed rebuttal to the short-seller's attacks in a video.

In addition, Herbalife hired boutique investment banking firm Moelis & Company and law firm Boies, Shiller & Flexner to defend itself while also publicly disclosing that it has $950 million left on its existing share buyback authorization, which ostensibly will be used to purchase stock at the current depressed valuation. Herbalife is also holding Thursday an analyst and investor meeting in New York to specifically address Bill Ackman's allegations against the company, with the aid of Dan Loeb.

Loeb, who happens to be a friend of Bill Ackman, has stepped into the fray when he announced his stake. The Wall Street Journal proclaimed, "One thing is clear about the financial showdown shaping up between Wall Street gunslingers William Ackman and Daniel Loeb: Someone is probably going to lose a whole lot of money."

The two money mangers views of Herbalife are in stark contrast to say the least. While Ackman has said his price target for the stock is $0, Loeb told Third Point investors that he thinks the stock can trade between $55 and $68, maybe higher.

He wrote:
The pyramid scheme is a serious accusation that we have studied closely with our advisors. We do not believe it has merit. The short thesis rests on the notion that the FTC has been asleep at the switch, missed a massive fraud for over three decades, and will shortly awaken (at the behest of hedge fund short seller) to shut down the Company. We find this thesis to be preposterous, particularly since the FTC has been sensitive to frauds of this kind.
Loeb also noted that the FTC has received fewer than 40 complaints per year against the company and that "we find it hard to believe the short seller's theory that hundreds of thousands of people who have been scammed supposedly are too ashamed to speak up."

The Third Point founder argued that if the company were to deploy its $950 million buyback authorization in the $40-$45 range, Herbalife's run-rate earnings per share for 2013 could be $5.50-$5.70 using the reduced share count. By applying a 10-12 multiple on earnings, which is well below HLF's historic multiple, the shares should trade between $55-$68 or even higher.

Loeb also pointed to Thursday's analyst day and the large short interest in the stock as further potential upside catalysts. According to the investment letter, Third Point built most of its position in Herbalife after Ackman went public with his short bet.

"The goal of our Dec. 20 presentation was to shine a spotlight on the company so that the world better understands the facts about Herbalife," said Ackman in a statement Wednesday. "The outcome of this investment is not about Pershing Square or anyone else who is long or short the stock. To the extent another investor, long or short, brings additional sunlight to the situation, we welcome them."

Speaking about the hedge fund battle royale, Gregg Hymowitz, founder of the $8.2 billion EnTrust Capital, told The Wall Street Journal, "One of them is going to be very wrong. Ackman thinks it's a complete and utter fraud, and Dan thinks it's a completely legitimate business." According to the Journal, Hymowitz is a longtime investor in both Pershing Square and Third Point.

Last Thursday, fund manager Robert Chapman posted a compelling argument as to why he decided to make a huge bet on Herbalife. The key to his thesis for the investment is that he believes Bill Ackman went public with his short crusade because he came to the realization that the FTC would not take action against the company. On Wednesday, Chapman toldT he Wall Street Journal, "This is shaping up to be potentially the bloodiest hedge-fund battle of all time."

Adding intrigue to the situation are published reports that the Securities and Exchange Commission has launched a probe into the company. The original report appeared in The Wall Street Journal, which cited an unnamed source close to the inquiry. Herbalife shares, rose a little better than 4% Wednesday to close at $39.95 heading into Thursday's key analyst meeting.

More from Benzinga
0Comments

DATA PROVIDERS

Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.

STOCK SCOUTER

StockScouter rates stocks from 1 to 10, with 10 being the best, using a system of advanced mathematics to determine a stock's expected risk and return. Ratings are displayed on a bell curve, meaning there will be fewer ratings of 1 and 10 and far more of 4 through 7.

118
118 rated 1
270
270 rated 2
472
472 rated 3
714
714 rated 4
624
624 rated 5
608
608 rated 6
623
623 rated 7
445
445 rated 8
319
319 rated 9
125
125 rated 10
12345678910

Top Picks

SYMBOLNAMERATING
AAPLAPPLE Inc10
ATVIACTIVISION BLIZZARD Inc10
BIDUBAIDU Inc10
BMYBRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB CO.10
CELGCELGENE CORP10
More

VIDEO ON MSN MONEY

ABOUT

Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.

Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.

Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.