Financial ETFs: Ignore the hype
The pros are professing newfound love for these funds, but you should tune them out.
By Gary Gordon, TheStreet
Goldman Sachs (GS) reported weak revenue, Citigroup (C) missed profit forecasts and Wells Fargo (WFC) merely matched estimates. In truth, JPMorgan Chase (JPM) is the only major financial institution that has reported inspirational numbers, but even "J.P." has problems in its mortgage division.
Herein lies an ongoing dilemma. You can improve your balance sheet by offloading troubled assets and/or writing off low-quality loans. You can ensure a measure of profitability by limiting your employee overhead, maintaining double-digit credit card rates, having some success in trading volume and/or offering next-to-zero savings rates to depositors. Yet financial stocks will still see "fits" without a more potent level of lending to small businesses and individuals.
Lately, many readers have been devouring rapturous reports on the incredible prospects for the financial sector. Hypothetically, economic expansion should encourage greater demand on the part of consumers and businesses alike.
On the other hand, the economic improvement is likely to be stronger for streamlined corporations than for families. Tech, energy, materials and industrials should help buoy stock averages, while higher-than-desired unemployment and record foreclosures imply that borrowers will struggle to qualify.
(Why take chances with credit quality -- unless, of course, the government forces lending activity. Oh, wait, didn't the government's direct and indirect involvement in the lowering of underwriting standards contribute mightily to the financial crisis?)
Scores of professionals are professing newfound love for SPDR Financials (XLF), SPDR KBW Regional Banks (KRE), SPDR KBW Bank (KBE) and iShares DJ Financial Services (IYG). On the flip side, I am avoiding the hype surrounding the financial sector. Here's why:
1. Financials do not show pre-recession revenue records
Across the spectrum of different industries, you see a wide variety of companies earning more money than ever before. Names include Apple (AAPL) and Intel (INTC) in technology, ExxonMobil (XOM) in energy, Vale (VALE) in materials as well as Potash (POT) in agriculture. In many ways, these corporations are operating as well as they did before the Great Recession.
2. The dot-com bubble is worth revisiting
The Nasdaq 100 is often viewed as a proxy for technology, as is the Nasdaq 100 tracker, Powershares QQQ (QQQQ). The QQQ is above the high reached during the 2003-2007, but it still requires another 94% to reach the pinnacle of 2000. Even after 10 years, the dot-com strain still lingers. (Cisco (CSCO), JDS Uniphase (JDSU), Sun Microsystems ... then and now, anyone?)
Expect financials and real estate companies to suffer a similar fate due to the credit/housing bubble's impact. For reference, the SPDR KBW Bank requires roughly 130% to reach its first quarter 2007 high mark.
3. Eerily similar circumstances during April 2010 earnings season
Not only did U.S. stocks outperform world equities in a 2-month run-up from Feb. 8, 2010 to April 14, 2010, but financial stocks led that charge. Their relative strength had been increasing dramatically. What's more, SPDR Select Financials (XLF) ran for 25%, vs. the S&P 500's ($INX) 14.5%. And all the while prognosticators were serving up brave new heights for financial stocks.
Then came the earnings disappointments. Nothing terrible ... but very similar to what we are seeing here in January 2011. Sure enough, the financial sector fell more than its peers and struggled for longer than its peers. With financials circa Nov. 13, 2010 to Jan. 18, 2011 demonstrating an eerily similar pattern to the previously mentioned vertical leap for the sector, could the so-so corporate earnings be the corrective dagger for a giddy marketplace?
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
3 stocks will be in the spotlight Thursday as investors try to make sense of the numbers from the sector.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.