9 ways Facebook is getting slimy
New moves aimed at making money are fine, but not when you anger users along the way.
Some of the moves have been downright infuriating, such as switching everyone's email address to a facebook.com address. Others have been just annoying, such as the new "sponsored stories" that now appear in feeds.
Nearly every move appears designed to make Facebook more money by increasing traffic, showing users more ads or persuading them to pay more.
Post continues below.
Sorry, Facebook, but you're getting a little slimy. I understand that you've got a bunch of shareholders now and you need to keep the money machine going, but little by little, the user experience is getting sacrificed.
Here are nine ways Facebook is getting shady:
1. Charging to promote posts
Businesses can now pay to promote a post and have it stick around longer in the news feeds of more people. Friends of people who have interacted with the post will also see it, possibly for up to three days, Facebook says. The company calls these "sponsored stories."
One of my friends liked the Nordstrom (JWN) page, for example, and last week Nordstrom's sponsored post showing a Diane Von Furstenberg dress appeared in my news feed. Really? No wonder PCMag.com called this feature "a new tool for jerks." Another tech site called it "not much more than sponsored spam."
2. The email switcheroo
Facebook automatically gives users their own facebook.com email address -- uh, thanks? -- but even worse, it then switched users' contact email addresses to those Facebook addresses. Craziness ensued. Some people said the contacts in their online address books were changed, and others reported lost email.
Facebook users had to go in and change their settings to hide that facebook.com email address. "Switching a user's contact information without their consent feels like an enormous breach of trust and leaves me less likely to trust such a company with any communication more substantive than happy birthday wall posts," wrote an astute observer on Mashable.
3. More and more ads
Facebook has steadily increased that number to seven. Now, Facebook is testing as many as 10 ads per page, reports AllFacebook. Once upon a time, Facebook only showed you one ad per page.
Fewer ads were one reason people jumped from MySpace to Facebook, writes John Koetsier at VentureBeat. "While you could argue that some ads are beneficial to the user experience if they’re relevant and timely, more is not necessarily better," he adds.
4. Users under age 13?
Facebook bans children under age 13 from joining, but that could change. The company is developing technology to allow children to use the site with parental supervision, The Wall Street Journal reports.
The idea drew immediate criticism from just about everyone, and prompted an inquiry from two Congressmen, Reps. Ed Markey (D-Mass.) and Joe Barton (R-Tex.). Facebook wrote the lawmakers in June and said this: "At this point, we have made no final decision whether to change our current approach of prohibiting children under 13 from joining Facebook."
5. No permission necessary?
Facebook is thinking about letting users play games immediately without showing them a Permissions box, AllFacebook reports. In the past, a user would see a little box asking for permission for the game to access a user's profile information and friend list. Soon, that little box may not be there.
Instead, the game would have a blue bar above it that lets users opt out and the information removed from the app. Why the change? Because Facebook says that the new way leads to more game installs and lower opt-out rates. "If users become more comfortable with their basic profile information being used to personalize websites, apps and games, the social network might eventually decide to allow some of this info to be used by default," writes Brittany Darwell of AllFacebook.
6. Adding a 'want' button
Facebook users are comfortable with the "like" button. But do they want a "want" button? One Web developer says he has found evidence that the company is testing the feature, perhaps with the ultimate goal of sharing your purchases on the site.
A "want" button is pure gold for advertisers. If somebody "wants" a pair of Old Navy jeans, for example, I could see Old Navy blasting that person and all their friends with ads for eternity. And Facebook would ring up some serious ad dollars.
7. Facebook is watching
Facebook loves facial-recognition technology so much that it bought Face.com, which specializes in the software. The company uses the technology to suggest the names of friends on photos that you upload. "Now I can take pictures of cute girls at the grocery store or at the park, upload them and Facebook will tell me who they are!" joked one hopeful commenter on Engadget. Not exactly, but the idea is scary enough.
One security researcher told Mashable that this recognition technology could lead to more forms of -- surprise! -- advertising. What if Facebook can also recognize products, and knows you're holding a can of Coca-Cola in your hand in that photo? There's an ad opportunity.
8. Monitoring our chats
Your Facebook chats are private, right? Nope, the company is using security software that scans chats for criminal activity, Reuters reports. Facebook isn't saying a whole lot about what goes into this, but Reuters says that in general, the software looks for inappropriate language and exchanges of personal information.
The Facebook software helped police bust a man in his early thirties who was chatting about sex with a 13-year-old South Florida girl and planned to meet her (see, even 13-year-olds shouldn't be using Facebook!). That this guy was caught is absolutely great. But the idea that Facebook's bots are listening to everything we say? Not so much.
9. Rotating ads -- because you just can't see enough
OK, fine, we'll take the seven (or is it 10?) ads Facebook shows us. But the company has kicked it up another notch. If you've been on the same page for a while, it will remove those ads and show you new ones.
"This change was implemented a few weeks ago and we think this will help people see more relevant ads," a Facebook spokesperson told ClickZ.
Users not as satisfied
It's no coincidence that as Facebook has ramped up its money-making engine, user satisfation has begun to fall. In surveys from the American Customer Satisfaction Index, Facebook only scored 61 out of 100 in customer satisfaction among active users. That's down eight points from 2011. Facebook scored lower than Twitter, LinkedIn (LNKD), Pinterest, YouTube and Google+ by Google (GOOG).
Facebook will give its first earnings report as a public company Thursday, and investors will be closely watching to see if the company can boost its revenue growth. The company is under pressure to begin making money from mobile advertising and increase its overall growth rates.
The company almost seems like it's throwing everything against the wall to see what sticks. I cringe now when I see any news item that begins with "Facebook is testing."
An awesome user experience is what helped Facebook build a base of more than 900 million users. Facebook is now walking that fine line between making more money and turning those users off. Don't blow it, guys.
More from Top Stocks
- 4 things new CEO can do to fix Yahoo
- Why Apple disappointed Wall Street
- McDonald's sees unprecedented slowdown
Facebook is kind of a sign of the times and the on-going spiraling decline of culture.
Television resulted in presidential candidates getting elected on the basis of how they look on TV (starting with Nixon/Kennedy debate) and an epidemic of obese "couch potatoes".
Add the commercialization of Christmas and every other holiday. A culture that denigrates intellectuals as "nerds" and worships sports figures like Joe Paterno and Michael Vick.
Now you have phony celebrities like Kate Gosselin and Kim Kardassian. Phony, ad executive-conceived bands and phony music.
Somedays I don't know if I'm in the Matrix or the starship Axiom from Wall-E.
Why not a commercialized delivery vehicle using phony friends as a front?
I much prefer seeing my buds in person, having a few, maybe some golf, bowling, ATV'n, snowmobiling, the list is kind of long. Can't do that sitting on my butt staring into a computer.
I have YET to see an AD on FB that has made me want to buy their product...
It wont be trash that pollutes the world, it will be ADs instead.
deleted facebook just prior to the IPO. I saw the writing on the wall...financial motivation as well as FB being used as a proxy for authorites, possible employers and misc unsavory folks to monitor you.
MORE ON MSN MONEY
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Quotes are real-time for NASDAQ, NYSE and AMEX. See delay times for other exchanges.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Thomson Reuters (click for restrictions). Real-time quotes provided by BATS Exchange. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Interactive Data Real-Time Services. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by SIX Financial Information.
Try as the bears might, they couldn't break US stocks. But investors still face frothy prices and considerable headwinds.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.