Should stocks replace CDs these days?
An 80-year-old woman who needs income wants to use JNJ instead of a low-interest certificate of deposit. Hey, why not?
I got a great call Monday night on "Mad Money" from an 80-year-old woman whose situation pretty much crystalizes what's going on right now in this market. She has CDs rolling over now that pay 5%. She knows the current CDs won't give her more than 1% at best.
So she wanted my blessing to buy Johnson & Johnson (JNJ), and I said yes, because I liked the yield, the balance sheet, the new management and the breakup value.
Now, at no other point in history that I have seen would you ever suggest that an 80-year-old woman use JNJ as a replacement for a CD. Never. Sure, on an after-tax basis, the 3.5% yield that JNJ gives you is so much better than the current CD. And JNJ is perhaps among the top 10 trusted brands in the world, even after the production issues have dogged it so badly. It doesn't have the earnings power you would like to see, but it is pretty darned clear that if you broke the company up, it would be worth substantially more than its current value.
But still, this question represents the desperate shape of investors everywhere who seek a fixed-income replacement. Johnson & Johnson has to go down only $2.50 to make it so the CD alternative is better for this woman, and that could happen in the blink of a high-frequency trader's eye.
Yet somehow I think it is reckless to keep her in CDs.
It's funny, in the same show I interviewed Edward Aldag, the chairman, president and CEO of Medical Properties Trust (MPW), a real-estate investment trust that owns buildings and leases them to hospitals.
The trust yields 7.2%, and it has enough rental income to cover all of that yield and maybe a little more.
That would normally serve as a terrific fixed-income alternative. But I couldn't bring myself to suggest it, because if I did, I would fear that something could go wrong with MPW and it would be on me. But if something went wrong with JNJ, it would be on it!
Either way, I am spelling out the exercise because when people say there is a bubble in higher yield, they should remember this woman's call. She needs the income. She can't get it from CDs.
Why not go for JNJ? Not only that, but there's real upside.
Why not go for Medical Properties Trust? The stock should be yielding only about 5% to get in sync with the group.
Either is better than the alternative. It's as simple as that.
Jim Cramer is a co-founder of TheStreet and contributes daily market commentary to the financial news network's sites. Follow his trades for Action Alerts PLUS, which Cramer co-manages as a charitable trust and has no positions in the stocks mentioned.
More from TheStreet.com
A 1% CD yield less 2.5% of inflation and 10% - 15% for taxes is not capital preservation. It's a recipe for poverty.
And greedy toads like cramer would sell their granny's false teeth if it makes them a few bucks.
The advice she should have gotten is while JNJ is a good stock to invest in she should purchase 10 or more big name dividend stocks to make her portfolio risk adverse. I like to have a portfolio of about 25 Big Name Iconic dividend stocks in various sectors like Coke (KO) , XOM, COP, IBM, Intel, Kraft, Phillip Morris etc. If all of the go under then your money will useless no matter what you invested in!
I know of three banks that are paying 2.25 percent interest for checking account up to 25K then like .25 percent on balances over that.
I am parking my mad money there
Well, finally Cramer talk about this in the open....
Since the times of the famous Greenspan Put, the name of the game is this precisely, stop saving and investing on the long term and start playing in the biggest casino of the planet...err...invest in stocks.
BTW I was reading that gambling has increased in the US, I think this is due because it is way better to play with professionals in Vegas or guess in the lottery than invest in WS under the advise of some morons..
Hmmm governments are not doing anything to stop the Death Spiral of lost jobs and an ever weaker and weaker economy -- governments giving their citizens confidence has nothing to do with the greatest depression all around us.
WE NEED JOBS STUPID
The global economic recovery is weakening as government policies have failed to restore confidence, the International Monetary Fund has said.
It added that the risk of further deterioration in the economic outlook was "considerable" and had increased.
i replaced my cd's with a few high yield mutual funds (bond) and a couple of tax free closed end funds a few years ago. (i am able to survive for now.)
and a few short term investor grade corporate bonds
i still invest in stocks as well (like you would throw a few on a horse at a race track)
i was recently advised some REIT's but i remember how everybody got ripped off on them so i passed on that. when the housing shows solid recovery i will go into something else other than REIT's.
Romney ' WHERE'S THE BEEF' to your 5 point economic plan, all fake.
Romney the numbers don't add up. 8 Trillion means BIG tax increases for middle income.
Romney "47% of the people, I'm not interested in them their victims."
Romney Bain mgt style was corp raider not empathic at all to people.
Romney State run healthcare isn't balanced and fair it's a circus.
Romney Mass. came in 47 of 50 states for job creation, when you were gov'r
Romney "let GM go bankrupt", isn't a plan it's a Bain corp raider tactic
Romney immigrants "let them self deport" ...
Romney "women have there place"....
Romney is King.....of 'FLIP FLOPPERS' is the only reality here.....
MORE ON MSN MONEY
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Quotes are real-time for NASDAQ, NYSE and AMEX. See delay times for other exchanges.
All hail the bull market, which ended the week with a big rally. But it also is starting to look a little like 1987, which suffered an epic blow-out.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.